Nonsense. Evidence : https://www.portfoliovisualizer.com/asset-class-correlations ( 2009-2015 time period )
Example: VTI and TLT (total stocks vs. total bonds) has -0.34 correlation.
In 2008, bonds AND stocks fell because of all-out panic where individuals dumped everything and tried to go into cash. The only thing not falling were US Treasuries since that is where all the capital ended up.
In 2015, we have a different issue -- a lot of the market is controlled by algos which, upon seeing instability, sell and go to cash. This causes a valley for all asset classes except the safe harbours (US Treasuries...maybe gold.)
But the claim was not "everything is correlated almost to a degree of 1". The actual claim was "when things go wrong everything is correlated almost to a degree of 1". Look at the data from 2008, not 2009-2015.
Correlation = -0.49 for 2008.
I stand corrected.
He said "... bad advice as they are now positively correlated."
Where are you getting this information, on which the whole comment is based? It has always been very volatile and stocks and bonds have almost never been "uncorrelated assets". They change sign very frequently. Here's a research report from PIMCO [1] that shows the change in sign of the correlation to be 29 times in the past 90-odd years.
https://media.pimco.com/Documents/PIMCO_Quantitative_Researc...
The bottom line is, there are many periods of time when stocks and bonds are inversely correlated and many times when there is a positive correlation. That's the whole point.
This is a gross simplification. Historically, to the 1930s, stocks and bonds were inversely correlated. Only recently has that behavior not held true (around 2008, according to the very PIMCO paper you cited).
To put it simply, it all comes down to interest rates. The only reason stocks and bonds are no longer inversely correlated (in my opinion) is the Fed's QE efforts. Historically, funds would move between stock and bond asset classes based on market sentiment (stocks when bullish, bonds when bearish).
Now, with an excess of cheap funds available (thanks QE!), both asset classes are being inflated artificially.
http://www.rba.gov.au/publications/bulletin/2014/sep/pdf/bu-...
http://blogs.wsj.com/moneybeat/2013/07/25/why-arent-stocks-a...
http://money.usnews.com/money/blogs/the-smarter-mutual-fund-...
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-08-26/something-...
http://time.com/money/3981692/what-the-bond-market-says-abou...
Not true. In 1927, the correlation was around 0.18. The correlation was close to 0 in 1928 and it was 0.4 in 1929.
>Only recently has that behavior not held true (around 2008, according to the very PIMCO paper you cited).
Again, not true. From 1965 to 1995, there were only a handful of years when stocks and bonds were negatively correlated. See figure 1 in the research report from PIMCO if you want to find this.
Bonds with higher risk (states, municipal, various corporate) will tend to track the federal bonds with some higher yield due to the higher risk you're taking. The amount of risk you're taking is a function of the state of the economy since in a bad economy e.g. corporations are more likely to default (overall). So one could say that yields going down are indicative of increased risk except they often lag. The phenomena we've seen over the last several years has yields going down while the perception of risk is that the risk is reduced. People considered the risk to be highest during the financial crisis and dropping since. So stocks have sky-rocketed because yields are down and the perception of risk has lowered. At the same time bonds went up because yields are down due to QE and low short term interests (that's just math).
The stock market is a form of a risky investment. While some stocks have a yield directly in the form of dividends others supply it in the form of growth. The price of a stock today vs. some expected price in the future is similar to the yield on bonds. If the risk did not change and bond yields are down one can expect stocks to go up. Now obviously stocks are very much influenced by people guessing how much growth is in there but at the same time given some fixed guess there is a price that correlated to some return %... Stocks are also influenced by volatility as people tend to want to get a better average return if the outcome is very volatile.
So at the end of the day, all investment options "correlate" (negative or positive depends on what you measure) with each other because if there was a single investment that had a better return for the same risk then there would be an arbitrage opportunity. At the same time they respond differently to changes in the perceived risk because the riskier assets are a lot more sensitive to risk (duh)...
EDIT (some more thoughts): Inflation expectations also influence the relative pricing of bonds and stocks. That's because stock prices will tend to go up with inflation (as corporate revenue will tend to track inflation almost by definition).
The really tricky bit is that the economy as a whole is I think a chaotic system. A butterfly flapping its wings in China can send oil prices down in the US. So it's hard to say something like these things used to correlate and therefore they will always correlate in some non-trivial way. (EDIT: esp. when thinking about things like growth, inflation and even policy which are the core things that move these other assets around)
>In the short run, stocks and bonds tend to run in opposite directions to fluctuations in investor risk appetite
I take this excerpt to mean that Pimco shares the same "common wisdom" assumption that Chollida1 does
When Tinkerrr's cited paper says that "stocks and bonds tend to run in opposite directions" they are saying they have a negative price correlation.
Take the EM crisis we've been experiencing. Yes, everything going downhill, but many EM investors bought USD as a 'response'. If USD has problems, maybe certain commodities go up. It's hard to tell.
That's not possible. At the very least, cash cannot "go down" along with everything else. If everything is down then, by definition, cash is up because you can now buy more of everything with the same amount of cash.
Yes, if you held cash in 2007, you beat the market, but you weren't wealthier than you were the year before.
During that time period the numbers in your bank account didn't get any bigger. But if that were the sole qualification for "increasing wealth" then the folks constantly worried about deflation are totally wrong!
However, until someone seriously suggests keeping a significant fraction of your investment portfolio as cash (preferentially to e.g. bonds) as a hedge against market crashes, I don't think it makes sense to classify cash as an investment instrument.
Or is it an issue of inequality - too few investing firms owning/managing too many assets?
Are the markets just so efficient that assets that once had clearly distinct risk/reward profiles are now blending together?
Is there even a good hedge available for Joe Investor and his 401k?
> Bond mutual and exchange-traded funds now own 17% of all corporate bonds, up from 9% in 2008, according to the ICI. In periods of market stress, more-concentrated mutual-fund ownership tends to mean larger price drops, the IMF said last year.
It used to be the case that stocks, bonds and other commodities like gold has inverse correlations. Or in other terms, when stocks were down, bonds and gold were up....
This lead to the Efficient Frontier from Markowitz where you would choose a risk level you were comfortable with and then build a portfolio of "uncorrelated assets" to get you optimum return for your risk level.
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/e/efficientfrontier.asp
The issue now a days is that this no longer makes much sense as when things go wrong everything is correlated almost to a degree of 1. Or in other terms, when the shit hits the fan, everything (Gold, stocks and bonds) all go down together.
TL/DR the old advice about investing in both bonds, stocks and gold for diversivication of risk is at best much less pronounced than it used to be and at worst just bad advice as they are now positively correlated.