I just don't see a charity economy being long term sustainable on the web...
I agree with the idea that there are existing alternative business models, but I don't think a voluntary model will generate enough revenue to sustain current content standards.
Also, this seems a lot like "branding & marketing" version 2.0. I don't like branding. And I don't want to like what people write just because of what they have written before. I want to read or listen to work, and then decide if I pay for it.
Do you have a better way of viewing this?
This dissonance has been, and (it seems) will always be, the primary stumbling block in the discussion of the information economy.
Why are pirates immoral? Why are they not immoral? Why is DRM immoral? Why is DRM not immoral? Who owns the copyright? what is fair use?
All to do with information. All fighting this central dissonance.
This is why the Patreon model should be advocated when it comes to information. Because as a tool, the market is utterly unfit to operate in this arena.
And it's one reason why I support Basic Income as an idea. I feel like the potential prevalence of creation is huge. But everybody is wasting away their life in "day jobs".
It's interesting to consider in fact, that Patreon is kind of like a one-person basic income.
Really I'm not sure basic income enters into this. Patreon is a pretty aggressive arena, only the people that generate public interest get funded, that's not everyone.
If you don't like what they make, you stop subscribing.
> Artists set up a page on the Patreon website, where patrons can pledge to donate a given amount of money to an artist every time they create a piece of art, optionally setting a monthly maximum. Alternatively a fixed monthly amount can be pledged
So it either turns into a monthly subscription fee, or becomes another game for the ad-tech industry to solve.
(It's still an important point for individuals though.)
But I see no reason the NYT or some such site couldn't fund itself the same way.
[Edit, posted in reply to the wrong person]
In the Patreon model, you can support the creator directly, and their ability to produce content scales with that support. It's like a subscription, except you allow anyone else to free ride.
A Patreon supported site could run no ads at all and still make a stable income. It would no longer be fighting its readers to force them to view manipulative nonsense. It would no longer be answerable to pushy, content-controlling advertisers. It would have more editorial freedom, bounded only by the willingness of people to pay.
IMO the Patreon model answers all the problems of the advertising model and I'd like to see it becoming the norm.