News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by aamar on Friday September 18, 2015 @11:54AM (#10239914)
Classic example:

    The iron ball fell on the glass table, and it shattered.
    The glass ball fell on the iron table, and it shattered.
Human readers will pick the correct antecedent for "it" in each case, so it's not ambiguous. But correct interpretation depends on knowing something about how likely glass and iron are to shatter.

I love these kinds of examples, but I don't think they ought to significantly deter the kind of work shown here; it depends on the application, but basic interpretation could be very useful even if it can't handle every case.

Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by mrec on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:54PM (#10240286)
These are called Winograd Schemas; you can read more about them and see more examples at https://www.cs.nyu.edu/davise/papers/WS.html
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by kajecounterhack on Friday September 18, 2015 @12:03PM (#10239975)
Yeah, it's a bit of a nitpick over definition of "comprehension" but the program itself is obviously useful, I mean it's a poor man's version of Freebase. Freebase/Google Knowledge Graph doesn't claim to "comprehend" anything, it is just a large graph datastructure with an efficient querying mechanism. That's what this is (...given this is a poor man's version, efficient querying mechanism may be lacking for larger graphs)
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by aamar on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:09PM (#10240405)
We don't have to worry about the philosophical questions of comprehension to find cases like this present challenges. These types of example (better articulated in mrec's link) are cases where we can imagine straightforward, plausible queries that the computer would be unable to answer: "what shattered?" or "what remains?" Some of the examples are such that simple web searches wouldn't be helpful in resolving the ambiguity; you'd need some "common knowledge." (Again: not that that's an insurmountable or necessarily relevant problem.)
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by oh_sigh on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:19PM (#10240507)
For those curious, this process is called "anaphora resolution", which is the process of understanding what a reference(usually a pronoun) actually refers to.
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by reptation on Friday September 18, 2015 @01:19PM (#10240510)
While this is a interesting point, grammarians will bristle at such an imprecise use of 'it', which should unambiguously refer to one antecedent.
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by jameshart on Friday September 18, 2015 @04:23PM (#10241833)
Who are these 'grammarians', and why should anyone care what makes them bristle? They evidently have a complete lack of appreciation for the semantic content of sentences and can only see syntax. What a very poor view of language that would be.

Professional writers, editors, and teachers of language would be perfectly fine with those sentences, because they understand language as being made up of syntax AND semantics.

Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by reptation on Saturday September 19, 2015 @11:03PM (#10246436)
In the admittedly artificially constructed SAT, the second sentence would seem to be an almost classic example of unacceptable ambiguity. Perhaps in real life, you are correct that the adjectives provide sufficient context.
Re:A Simple AI Capable of Basic Reading Comprehension by T-Roy on Saturday September 19, 2015 @01:52PM (#10244993)
OpenCyc is a really cool implementation of one solution to this problem.

The way it was explained to me, computers don't know that when you turn a full cup of coffee upside down, the liquid will fall out. Cyc attempts to provide a framework for that.

http://sw.opencyc.org