News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by LeoNatan25 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:40AM (#10231900)
Content blocking requires a 64-bit CPU.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by Someone on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:49AM (#10231932)
Ah! Thanks. It might be worthwhile to mention in the FAQ that not this does not run on all devices running iOS 9. The App Store description shows a list of supported devices, but because of the fragmentation of the iOS market :-), it is so long and incomprehensible that I don't bother to read it.

And no, I don't think "requires a 64-bit CPU" is sufficient to describe it.

Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by LeoNatan25 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:53AM (#10231942)
I guess they are assuming that if you are installing a content blocker, you are tech savvy enough to know what CPU the device you own has. I agree this is a problem. This is a transition period. Most likely iOS 10 will be 64-bit only, so these kind of problems will get worse before disappearing altogether.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by cynix on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:55AM (#10232138)
This is really annoying. I don't want to update my phone to iOS 9 until a jailbreak is out, and my old phone is an iPhone 4S so I can't try out ad blockers on it.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by hauget on Friday September 18, 2015 @05:57PM (#10242298)
Not even the iPhone 5 is supported on all three (now 2 given Marco removing PEACE) ad-blockers. This is why even though I have an iPhone, I prefer my Android device. UPDATE: just found out about WeBlock. Works on iOS devices with iOS6+
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by heinrich5991 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:47AM (#10231923)
Interesting. Why is that?
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by LeoNatan25 on Thursday September 17, 2015 @02:52AM (#10231937)
Ask Apple :) See this tweet: https://twitter.com/awfulben/status/638510622167052288

Apparently, content blockers work on 32-bit CPUs, but Apple is restricting them on the store to 64-bit only. So you can go the BlockParty + EasyList route: https://github.com/krishkumar/BlockParty

It works very well.

Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by Armand_Grillet on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:23AM (#10232033)
Another open-source iOS 9 content blocker here, using EasyList and EasyPrivacy: https://github.com/ArmandGrillet/Adios (I'm the guy behind this project).
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by pinewurst on Thursday September 17, 2015 @12:36PM (#10234396)
As a data point, I just built/installed BlockParty on iPhone 5 and iPad Retina and see nothing but performance improvement. Many thanks again for the link!
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by ytch on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:01AM (#10231963)
Apple only says:

Note: Apps containing content blocking extensions for Safari on iOS are available only on 64-bit devices, due to performance limitations of 32-bit devices.

https://developer.apple.com/library/prerelease/ios/releaseno...

Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by jamestnz on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:06AM (#10231983)
According to the release notes for Safari 9 [1], it's because of performance concerns: "Apps containing content blocking extensions for Safari on iOS are available only on 64-bit devices, due to performance limitations of 32-bit devices"

I imagine there's no real reason that content blocking shouldn't work on 32-bit devices, but that Apple are trying to hit certain minimum performance numbers (for marketing/brand purposes)... and I'm sure they won't be upset if this should happen to encourage a few users of older devices to upgrade (i.e. forced obsolescence).

I think there are various examples of Apple doing this kind of thing (saying a certain generation of hardware is supported by software X, but then you find various things are disabled for you). Not exactly the same, but pre-2011 Macs cannot mirror their display via AirPlay (Apple saying the video hardware isn't up to the task) -- at least not until you install the third-party app AirParrot, then it works fine.

[1] https://developer.apple.com/library/prerelease/ios/releaseno...

Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by ytch on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:21AM (#10232027)
Maybe 32/64 bit isn't the issue, Apple just choose it as a flag to exclude slow CPU?
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by choppaface on Thursday September 17, 2015 @03:33AM (#10232069)
The 64-bit CPUs have a wider (and thus effectively faster) bus, and content blocking is probably rather strenuous on CPU cache (lots of string/pattern matching?). While the 64-bit cutoff is likely mostly a marketing artifact, content blocking on 32-bit CPUs could actually be 2x slower or worse than 64-bit CPUs and thus make page rendering times very painful for some sites.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by Yetanfou on Thursday September 17, 2015 @11:29AM (#10233878)
Nope, it is pure marketing. There is no technical reason whatsoever for ad-blocking to require a 64 bit CPU or databus. It actually works fine on a single-core sub-Ghz ARM7 like that used in my phone (Motorola Defy) with all of 512MiB of memory.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by choppaface on Friday September 18, 2015 @05:38AM (#10238253)
Huh, did you really run iOS9 ad blocking on a Motorola Defy? I definitely believe Apple's position is 99% marketing, but I can imagine there are some common pages that load really slow on older hardware. I've seen older iPads crash consistently trying to render complicated pages.
Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by Yetanfou on Saturday September 19, 2015 @09:45AM (#10244269)
Of course I did not run iOS on that Defy, why would I? Ad blocking was everywhere before apple finally decided to allow it on iOS. Inside those idevices are ARM-based CPUs, just like the ones in most other mobile hardware. What difference does it make whether the OS is based on Linux (Android), Mach/BSD (iOS) or even Windows (...Windows)? A regexp is a regexp after all...

The Defy does not crash rendering complex pages. It can get pretty slow though, reason for running extensions like NoScript for Android [1] (which runs just fine on the Fdroid.org Fennec build, ie. Firefox without the nasty bits) and uBlock origin.

[1] https://noscript.net/nsa/

Re:Crystal – iOS 9 ad blocker by Yetanfou on Thursday September 17, 2015 @11:24AM (#10233852)
Because apple knows ad-blocking is a much-desired feature, and as such can be used to 'convince' people it is time to ditch their 'older' devices (which, technically speaking, have no problems whatsoever in running ad-blocking software) and buy the latest&greatest.

For those doubting ad-blocking works on 32-bit ARM, have a look at the multitude of Android devices. Nearly all of them use a 32 bit CPU. Many of them run some form of ad-blocking software, ranging from proxy-based systems (a la privoxy) to browser plugins to host-based blocking. Often a combination of these are used, all on those 32 bit CPU's.