Successful startups in exchange for shitty labor protections are a shitty trade for the vast, vast majority of people.
I like that we have both types of labor climates in the first world. High-risk, no safety-net and unshackled by regulation like in the US, but also a more cushy albeit less dynamic one in Europe.
Also if we mean it to allow upper lower class to lower middle class, then we could see consequences such as: people not caring about education and higher skills development (blue collar union job mentality) no big deal by yet could strand these people later. Second, it pushes lower skilled people out of the labor force. Why hire someone who barely went to highschool when you can get a liberal arts grad at that wage?
Living wage does have a specific definition - it is a minimum subsistence wage, that takes into account the cost of living for a various area as well as various things that are necessary to be able to work (eg child care, transportation, and medical coverage). It does not budget time or money for any entertainment or leisure time, or any long-term financial planning such as retirement or savings.
So in short it's a minimum wage, except a minimum wage that's actually based on the immediate day-to-day costs needed to keep you working at your job. In fact it's really less political than the minimum wage itself, since the minimum wage is just an arbitrary number someone chose - one that's usually low enough to require the government to subsidize businesses who employ minimum-wage workers, through various social programs. Why is the minimum wage currently $7.25 instead of the $15 equivalent it was in the 70s? We simply haven't legislated an increase.
Can you change what costs are considered essential to keeping you working? Sure, and those do change over time. 70 years ago you wouldn't have had to include child-care costs since you'd have a stay-at-home wife to care for them. And indeed such things should change when justified by conditions on the ground - we no longer live in an economy of 1-income households, and it's not just foolish to pretend we do - it's harmful.
I assure you that Americans demonstrate ample resistance to perceived increases in the living standards of the poor, it's unnecessary to preemptively rule out any changes down the road.
I don't see the contradiction. Today, if we move min wage to 20, undereducated people will get pushed out by people with two years of coll.
In the long term, if we increase min wage to make it a livable wage by which you can raise a family, what would motivate a 16 yo to further studies and become the two year comm cool grad? I grew up with disaffected youth. These are the guys and gals who thought, I dont need much, I'll get a job at Joe's dad's shop. College ain't for me.
For instance, you don't go to the store, take a can of WD-40 home, use it, then go back to the store to pay for the can.
Labor (unjustly, but not hugely so) is given to employers on credit from workers. You work a week (giving the commodity of labor away for free during that week because you have no choice in the matter) then get paid afterward.
The point of this push for labor rights is that laborers aren't being fairly compensated in a variety of dimensions for the work they've done.
That's true, but may have more to do with an unwillingness to track a squillion IOUs for individual cans of WD-40 than a sign of a fundamental difference. Were you a company buying a pallet of the stuff, things would be different.
(That said, if I pay by credit card it'll be at least a month before the card issuer thinks about charging me interest, so things aren't so very different as an individual, either...)
Depends on the relationship. Instead of a hotel, say you decided that you enjoy a massage and after some research you find a license therapist in your area and you have a trial massage and, having appreciated said massage, you decide to establish twice weekly massages.
So you talk with the therapist and establish a nice $125/hour rate for them to come to your house every Tuesday and Thursday at 2:00pm for an hour massage. Having negotiated a rate, you agree that this is an ongoing deal until one or the other of you decides to cancel it.
Now, you've agreed to effectively $1,000/month salary for this person. Are you really going to go ahead and pay them the agreed upon $1,000/month even though they:
a) catch a virus and are unable to come for two weeks.
b) take a vacation to Pittsburgh and are not going to be there next Thursday.
c) have a child and aren't going to be coming to give your massage for the next six, eight, or ten weeks?
d) have signed up extra clients and will reach sixty hours by Thursday morning, so they won't be able to provide their Thursday afternoon or Friday appointments due to hard limits on overtime.
e) now that they have a kid, you're going to pay an extra $10 per session for child care.
For some reason, my gut feeling is that you're not going to do any of those things and instead put it on the therapist to manage their business and accept that they will get paid for services rendered and nothing else.
* a business center with pc/printer/fax machine
* a gym
* a 'meet-and-greet' with complimentary beverages
* an inexplicable twice a day cleaning schedule
* tennis/basketball courts
* shuttle service
* cable television
All of which I do not use, but are definitely included in their overhead costs and passed on to me, the consumer.
Or, you can decide not to get involved too much with your kinds, eventually shipping them off to a boarding school. even for that, you have to pay dearly.
Ah yes, the good old macho culture that has been disfiguring men emotionally and physically for longer than I know. The macho culture is probably one reason why we don't live as long as women do, since we consider going to the doctor to be expressing weakness, which is verboten. Aside from that aspect of the issue, it's no secret that worker rights barely exist in the US, and a strong parental leave policy enshrined into law would massively help both men and women.
Getting real worker rights in the US be like pulling teeth from a stone (sic), though. We don't even have sick days by law-- seems like those should come first.
A quick list of things we direly need which we don't have:
1. Paid sick days
2. Paid vacation days
3. Hard limit of hours worked per week
4. Overtime pay for salaried employees
5. Paid parental leave
6. Control over scheduling of hours
7. A realistic minimum wage or some other way of guaranteeing survival of the poor
8. Paid childcare