Re:Examining the Black Family in the Age of Mass Incarceration
by hnpc123 on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @06:32PM
(#10223570)
This would be another explanation for why African Americans (and Africans) are doing so poorly.
It's a good argument and so it weakens the likelihood of my argument but it doesn't actually refute or argue directly against my points.
Your argument proceeds like this: Group X is badly off, because group X is inferior, therefore it's group X's own fault. Well, if you knew a group was at an enormous starting disadvantage in an iterated economic competition, naturally you would expect its position to decline over time. But if you were to provide group X with resources to mitigate its disadvantage, why would you not expect it to revert to the mean? On the other hand, give me a license to systematically oppress any group - people in your family tree, for example - and after a few decades I'll be able to make them underperform significantly, especially if operating the machinery of oppression allows me to collect economic rents.