So if we optimize for supersonic flight it won't be so good for transonic and vice-versa... I agree with you in that probably there's no way to passively eliminate sonic booms, maybe some kind of "active" solutions, but the weight problem strikes again.
Also, I don't know if a rocket can be made without boom, as the transition in the nozzle is abrupt. Maybe it's time to review those aerospikes!
(I'm a computer programmer, not an aero engineer, so probably both these solutions are naive)
Also, at what altitudes does a boom become irrelevant? This thing will be very high so cross-continental might not be an issue either.
Typical pattern traffic is much slower than 600kt. It's a hazard to have aircraft at 600kt zooming around 747s approaching at 200kt and so on. You can come up with protocols to minimize the risks (eg running patterns at different flight levels and on different runways) but there's only so far you can take it, and there's still an increase in risk, particularly in emergency situations.
When trans-sonic aircraft are operating at low speeds they're operating inefficiently. The longer and slower you're running them, the higher the fuel burn. That translates into higher operating cost and longer flight times. In an ideal world you would want them supersonic as soon as they can possibly get to cruising speed.
You need to be pretty high before supersonic booms stop being a problem. The Concorde could do up to 60k altitude and was still a nuisance. So maybe 75k or 100k feet? Even that might not be enough - booms can travel as far as 100 miles and the difference in air density isn't significant enough to fully dampen this. You might be able to get away with flying lower with an aircraft that was designed to reduce booming.
what is the problem with sonic boom? i grew up on navy base in pretty militarized region and we had fighters frequently producing the booms (USSR, first half of 198x). It was fun, at least for us - for children :)
The only known shape which produces no sonic boom (Busemann's Biplane) also produces no lift. There is a known shape called the Sears-Haack body which produces very little turbulence - basically it's like a very long pointed football. The best we have been able to do is make airplanes resemble that shape by having short stubby wings at the widest portion of the airflow body, with an elongated snout and tail. It does reduce turbulence to a degree, but again you are hurting your lift.
I think this may actually be an insoluble problem. You need to disturb the air to produce lift, i.e. create a low-pressure zone over the wing, and a high-pressure zone under the wing. My fear is that this is inextricably linked to sonic booms, as we just seem to be exploring various locations within a space defining the tradeoffs between lift and sonic booms.
We may be able to do it if we get the sonic boom low enough, but this gets back to the cost tradeoff. A rocket is certainly one possible solution within this space - a no-lift body that follows a ballistic trajectory could probably be constructed not to produce a sonic boom. However any solution on this end runs right back into the cost problem that you noted. Rockets need a lot more fuel and maintenance than a fixed-wing craft, and they're a lot less safe.