News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by LeoNatan25 on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:05PM (#10218773)
On a personal note, I'd say it's pretty sad that a taxi company is raising more than a company attempting to further the technological front. Not popular to say anything against Uber here these days, but this is not against Uber specifically, more the perverted culture that we live in. Imagine these 8+ billion going to cancer research, for example.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by davnicwil on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:15AM (#10218916)
If people can get around cheaper and more easily using Uber than they could previously using taxis, that's an enabler for better productivity and quality across the entire economy.

Not even to mention that Uber, in complete opposition to taxis, is massively incentivised to drive self-driving tech forwards as quickly as possible. That will be a huge, huge multiplier on the above.

Your use of 'perverted culture' in reference to demand for improvements in transport services puzzles me. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding your intent. People getting around, seeing other people, working with other people is the very basis of, well.. everything in our economy, and in our lives.

Even if only on an academic level, I really struggle to see how anyone couldn't be excited by the improvements companies like Uber are making right now, and the potentially more drastic improvements they could make in the future, in this sector.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by gozo on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @07:09AM (#10219929)
You somehow think Uber is going to continue subsidize taxi travel forever? Is that what all these investors are putting money into, of course not. The technological mertis of Uber does not take that much money. They might be working on self-driving cars, but so are several other startups and car companies. Just not as some lofty future goal, but as actual incremental improvements.

I think most peoples excitment over Uber is reactionary. Because they clearly aren't as excited about all the other companies that are now using similar technology without the poor ethics of Uber.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by pbreit on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @11:22AM (#10221146)
I don't like some of Uber's ethics but its execution overall has been exceptional. There is one impressive technical component around matching up riders along the same route. Otherwise, the Uber service is mostly just well-executed technology. But where Uber is way beyond others is operations, scale, marketing, etc. All worthy characteristics even if they don't resonate so much with a pure technical crowd.

Also, on a gross basis, Uber's 20-25% take rate makes it wildly profitable.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by LeoNatan25 on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:03AM (#10219192)
Thanks for this. I was not aware of Uber's investments in the field, and I didn't want to compare Uber in particular. By "perverted culture", I meant the high-tech world in general, where Facebook buys Instagram and WhatsApp for billions of dollars for ... uhm ... important reasons. I am not holier than though myself, I participate in the crazy spending myself. But seeing the numbers here just made me think.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by brianclements on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:45AM (#10219292)
So by that definition, SpaceX is truly going "full Uber".
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by intopieces on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:21PM (#10218798)
Uber is buying up robotics departments and pushing into autonomous vehicles. They're definitely furthering the technological front. Also, I think you'll find plenty of criticism of Uber around here, it's not one of the most well-regarded companies.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by binarycrusader on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:44PM (#10218852)
Uber hasn't done anything meaningful to further the technological front yet -- certainly nothing that is or will affect all of humanity. And we are literally talking about Rocket Science here...
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by intopieces on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:38PM (#10222402)
>certainly nothing that is or will affect all of humanity.

If we're setting the goal post for "furthering the technological front" at "helping all of humanity" then technology is at a standstill and the Internet is a failure. After all, fewer than 50% of the world uses the Internet.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by atrus on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:54PM (#10218877)
And has SpaceX?
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by pyridine on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:17AM (#10218923)
From wiki article on SpaceX:

The first privately funded, liquid-fueled rocket (Falcon 1) to reach orbit (28 September 2008)

The first privately funded company to successfully launch (by Falcon 9) Orbit and recover a spacecraft (Dragon) (9 December 2010)

The first private company to send a spacecraft (Dragon) to the International Space Station (25 May 2012)

The first private company to send a satellite into geosynchronous orbit

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by EazyC on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:18AM (#10219060)
Both Uber and SpaceX are technically 'transportation companies' in a loose sense. None of the things you listed above really further any field in basic science and academia. SpaceX's achievements simply sound cooler because it is with big rockets and more tangible to write down for record keeping. They are essentially using rocket tech in a new, different way that employs a new business model for success - which, surprise surprise, is exactly what Uber does as well but with terrestrial transport vehicles.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by _nedR on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:16AM (#10219058)
None of those things has had any affect on my life or the lives of anybody i personally know (yet).

I booked a ride on Uber just the other day.

edit: typo

[dead]
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by _nedR on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @02:32AM (#10219256)
Wow. No need to go hyperbolic.

First off, SpaceX had little/nothing to do with any of the stuff you mentioned.

Second, I am not devaluing what SpaceX has done or is trying to do. I am a big fan actually of such ventures which strive to find new frontiers.

My reply was in the context of this thread where lot of people are dissing Uber saying they are not a real technology company, and people lamenting the fact that a taxi company raised more money than a space faring company.

I was pointing out the close-mindedness (if you will) of those people. Uber is having tremendous impact in the here and now across the world, and touching the lives of millions of people. What they have done is nothing to dismiss. Also the vision of the future they are working towards could be even more transformative (possibly save hundreds of thousands of lives a year).

What SpaceX is trying is far more riskier and ambitious and its rewards for humanity (if it succeeds) lay further into the future and may end up having greater impact on the future of humanity (or it may not). In the interim its impact is limited (because it is a long-term project).

It makes no sense to compare the two ventures as some competition. The worlds needs both. There is nothing wrong with the fact that Uber has a greater valuation than SpaceX. Uber provides greater value to their customers right now. And they could provide greater returns to their investors sooner (if they chose to ). SpaceX as of now is much more riskier investment and its real returns lay farther in the future.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by leoedin on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @05:54AM (#10219747)
Space technology in the 60s certainly resulted in wider benefit. Today? There's definitely some innovation happening, but broadly (compared to, say, consumer electronics) space is an incredibly slow moving, incredibly risk averse field. It often takes decades for components developed for other fields to end up in space.

A satellite today will probably be filled with electronic components designed 20 years ago. Justifying doing anything new is hugely expensive and so rarely happens.

Ultimately, in the past designing for space was a new field with rapid development but as the field has matured the huge cost involved in launching anything has made the whole industry hugely risk averse. There is innovation happening from new players (cube sats, spacex), but even these areas are mostly about finding cheaper ways to do things rather than inventing new stuff.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by eru on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @03:39AM (#10219428)
> You enjoy the fruits of space experimentation on the ISS every day.

What has manned (!) space flight ever done for us?

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by elektromekatron on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @05:05AM (#10219638)
Helped keep the peace between the USSR and the USA through the cold war, by giving them something to collaborate on and so build some trust and keep communication going.

edit - there is other stuff as well, but 'peace' seemed the best option to go with given the way you phrased the question - https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/6/66/Hubble_I...

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by eru on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @11:23PM (#10224501)
Ok, that's an interesting hypothesis. How can we falsify / verify it?

(One competing hypothesis is `nukes kept the peace'.)

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by elektromekatron on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @01:03PM (#10228091)
Well, we can imagine another world where we still have superpowers with nukes pointed at each other but without big civil collaborative science projects going on between them.

Both worlds could end up in an all-out nuclear war, but which one do you think is more likely?

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by eru on Wednesday September 16, 2015 @07:06PM (#10230581)
We can imagine a lot of things.

I was thinking of rather more evidence-based evidence.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by elektromekatron on Thursday September 17, 2015 @06:17PM (#10236419)
Well, without going down the road of trying to find plausible probabilities for imaginary scenarios it is difficult to chip away at either hypothesis, given we do not have a variety of different earths to test on.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by Redoubts on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:37AM (#10218960)
That's not a front though, that's just doing it with a different revenue stream.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by nitrogen on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:15AM (#10219050)
There was a lot of "first" in the previous comment, which might as well be synonymous with "front" in this context.

As an example, Linux wasn't the first UNIX-like kernel or the even the first free UNIX-like kernel, but it (with GNU) was the first free UNIX-like kernel to bring a UNIX-like kernel to the mainstream PC world and span the entire vertical range of computing scale from microcontrollers to TOP500 supercomputers. I'd call that expanding the technological front.

Edited for GNUtical correctness, which makes it quite a bit harder to read

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by Redoubts on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:43AM (#10219139)
>There was a lot of "first" in the previous comment, which might as well be synonymous with "front" in this context.

Not really. It's literally doing what was done before, 30 years ago.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by zarkov99 on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @06:10AM (#10219787)
Re-usable rockets are pretty meaningful. And SpaceX is a couple of launches away from achieving them.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by Taek on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:12AM (#10218909)
Uber has improved my quality of life, and improved the ability of my social group to get together despite being fairly spread out. Before installing uber, I paid for transportation maybe twice a year. Now it's closer to twice a month. That's pretty significant.

I'm glad SpaceX is doing well, but I'm also glad Uber is going well.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by jeffwass on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @03:51AM (#10219458)
Totally tangential, but I'm genuinely curious where you live if you've only needed to pay for transportation twice a year. (Assuming you are counting car and bike maintenance and car fuel in that comment?)
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by dylanjermiah on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:12AM (#10219045)
Billions of dollars a year already go into cancer research. Infinite funding != faster progress.

I'd say the allocation of capital has been fairly efficient. Uber will be doing self driving vehicles(among other companies), and that will be as transformational as the automobile itself.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by XorNot on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @03:00AM (#10219340)
Also "cancer" is not one disease. It's thousands of separate diseases.

Moreover, technology is not a straight line. For example as far as cancer research goes, computer gaming and the incredible investment in graphics card technology (and the consumer market for it) has done more to help in recent years as a general effort then any other specific advance.

But people have definitely sat around saying "we shouldn't spend money on this..."

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by pbreit on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:22AM (#10218931)
I'm going to disagree. It's a slippery slope to start making comparisons like that because the logical conclusion is that you only spend money on cancer research.

Also, I think transportation is fundamental and worth investing in. And further, it's (currently) a pretty good and very flexible way for a variety of people to earn income.

Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by imglorp on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @01:05AM (#10219026)
At least it's not fart apps. They're both selling real services. One of them is concrete and the other overvalued, is all.
Re:SpaceX Has Nearly a Full Uber Funding in Contracts by hsod on Tuesday September 15, 2015 @12:33PM (#10221569)
It is very, very popular to say things against Uber here these days.