Re:One Major Difference Between Clojure and Common Lisp
by dragonwriter on Monday September 14, 2015 @10:10AM
(#10215113)
It's true that it is more difficult to port from Common Lisp or other Lisp-2 dialects to Scheme, Racket, or Clojure (which are Lisp-1 dialects) than it would be to port to other Lisp-2 dialects. But that certainly doesn't make Lisp-1 dialects "not Lisp" while Lisp-2 dialects are "Lisp".
Re:One Major Difference Between Clojure and Common Lisp
by lispm on Monday September 14, 2015 @11:57AM
(#10215693)
Porting code from Lisp-2 to Lisp-1 is not that difficult.
Example:
Lisp-2:
(defun new-map (f l)
(dolist (e l)
(funcall f e)))
Lisp-1: (defun new-map (f l)
(dolist (e l)
(f e)))
Another example:Lisp-2
(defun foo (l)
(flet ((new-map (f l)
(dolist (e l)
(f e))))
(new-map (function sin) l)))
Lisp-1 (defun foo (l)
(let ((new-map (lambda (f l)
(dolist (e l)
(f e)))))
(new-map sin l)))
To make it easier, just define FUNCALL, FUNCTION and FLET in Lisp-1...
True, and I have to apologize for that. But I don't have the time, nor the priority to go into full detail. The main points are: different community, different goals, almost zero code sharing, different technical solutions, different literature, ... The differences are technical and social. Each of the points would need more explanation, for which I don't have the time.
For me 'Lisp' is something practical. I have a bunch of non-trivial code -> can I compile/load it? Can I port it easily? Are there people who would be interested to share? What are they using? Can I work with them?
Example:
Macsyma is an old Lisp program. New Lisp dialects appeared. Macsyma was ported to them: Maclisp, Franz Lisp, NIL (New Implementation of Lisp), Lisp Machine Lisp, VaxLisp, Common Lisp...
This software can't be ported to Clojure or Racket, without fully re-architecting the software, and I'm only thinking about the basic Macsyma, without GUI or other system dependent parts.
> that the 'vague' definition serves a much more practical purpose
which one? to confuse people? To raise expectations of collaboration in a community, which are then not fulfilled?