News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by azth on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:37AM (#10213654)
Misleading title. It does not say whether or not the salaries were normalized based on the type of job inside each occupation (hours, position, etc.). Almost surely they have not been.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by onion2k on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:47AM (#10213676)
So instead of indicating a level of inequality in pay for doing the same job, the data might indicate a level of sexism in the type of jobs people have (or number of hours worked, or number of years people are in the profession, etc). That still demonstrates there's a significant problem.

There is no way to read that graph, or the data behind it, that indicates things should stay the way they are.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:55AM (#10213695)
As I understand azth's objection, it basically means "This data has been stripped of all context that could make it meaningful". Which is to say it's a shocking, but ultimately useless graph.

You can say there's no way to read it as indicating things should stay the way they are. I believe azth's point is that there's no way to read it as saying anything coherent at all.

(EDIT: Typo.)

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Hyperborian on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:55AM (#10213694)
> That still demonstrates there's a significant problem.

Of course, but it's a different problem with a different solution. Isn't that important to know?

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by reitzensteinm on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:05AM (#10213715)
There absolutely are ways to read the graph in a positive light.

If pay is heavily influenced by seniority, and a profession used to be sexist in its hiring practices but no longer is, then it follows that there'll be a significant gender pay gap until the older - mostly male - members of a profession die out.

Of course, there are many ways to read it negatively too. It's so devoid of information that it's just meaningless.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Asbostos on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:12AM (#10213725)
How about women are more likely to change professions/jobs, so they don't get to the same levels of seniority as men. That might indicate they have a more varied and interesting life. Maybe that suits women better than men. So yea the graph says nothing.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by jldugger on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:38AM (#10213980)
> So instead of indicating a level of inequality in pay for doing the same job, the data might indicate a level of sexism in the type of jobs people have (or number of hours worked, or number of years people are in the profession, etc). That still demonstrates there's a significant problem.

The graph alone doesn't tell us a whole lot, other than women are almost always compensated less than men. There seems to be quite a bit of variation across job functions, which might be unexpected. Understanding why that variation exists might be useful in addressing the perceived problem, and avoiding corporate policies that accidentally make things worse.

For example, if the bulk of pay gap is years of experience, it would be foolhardy to increase starting salary for women; you'd be giving equally qualified men a competitive advantage in hiring they don't need. Similarly, the situation could be understated -- if I'm reading the methodology correctly, CPS data doesn't include independent contractors, since they buy health insurance separately, I expect a number of men forgo insurance entirely and pocket the difference, a gamble few women of child bearing age dare take. Corporate policy here could try to prohibit independent contractors, but that would substantially reverse the trend. Better, IMO, would be single payer health care, or at least an end to the tax subsidy we give employer paid health care.

More dimensions will give us a more nuanced view of reality, and a better grasp on the degree to which the gap is systemic vs personal.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by bitJericho on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:54AM (#10213692)
Is it sexism, or is it women not wanting to promote due to external factors? Is it women not asking for raises as often as men? There is a lot of missing data here.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by zorpner on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:39AM (#10213660)
Exactly! A big part of the problem is that women aren't promoted as often and much of the work they're expected to do (admin tasks, coordination that falls outside the scope of their official title) isn't accounted for in estimates of their work hours. Thanks for pointing out this important reason that there's a gender-based pay gap in so many occupations.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:27AM (#10213748)
I'm reasonably certain that that is not what azth was attempting to communicate. Is there a particular reason you are commenting in this manner?
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by zorpner on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:04AM (#10213818)
I was under the impression that they were pointing out the mechanisms responsible for the evident pay gap. What do you think they were attempting to communicate?
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:08AM (#10213820)
I believe azth was attempting to communicate that as processed and presented, this visualization can serve only to mislead. That it does not offer an accurate - and thus useful - amount of insight because it fails to account for a number of factors known to be significant.
Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by angersock on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:40AM (#10213661)
Sourced from here:

http://www.bls.gov/cps/cpsaat39.htm

I somewhat trust the Bureau of Labor Statistics.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by lotharbot on Monday September 14, 2015 @12:57AM (#10213699)
I mostly trust the BLS, but I don't necessarily trust every statistical conclusion someone can draw from running a script on BLS data.

Just as an example of how the numbers might not mean what they appear to: "lawyers" is near the middle of the chart, at around the 82% mark, while "legal occupations" is way at the bottom, around 57%. Does "legal occupations" include lawyers, or is it everything else in the law field aside from lawyers? If lawyers are included, then there's an obvious explanation for the large gap in legal occupations as a whole (namely, more male lawyers, and lawyers being higher-paid than assistants etc., dragging up the median compensation of males in the legal field); if they're not included, then there's a huge and unexplained gender discrepancy in pay among legal assistants etc.

These numbers have a very different meaning if they don't account for seniority, hours worked, or level of responsibility than if they do.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by thomasz on Monday September 14, 2015 @01:52AM (#10213794)
> These numbers have a very different meaning if they don't account for seniority, hours worked, or level of responsibility than if they do.

I don't undestand your point. Those are exactly the mechanisms most likely responsible for the pay gap. No employer would ever pay double wage for an y chromosome, but it's not unlikely that preconceived gender roles influence decisions about who gets promoted, who stays home with the kids and stuff like that.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by Kalium on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:19AM (#10213837)
By failing to account for obvious and known confounds, the graph is rendered significantly less meaningful.

By way of analogy, one could look at rainfall averages over the whole of the US and conclude that some place is/is not in a drought. You could do this by ignoring the obvious confound that different places get different amounts of rainfall. For some places, it would be true. For others, not.

Re:U.S. pay gap by sex by occupation by omonra on Monday September 14, 2015 @03:16AM (#10213937)
That's the crux of the matter.

Most people unhappy about the 'pay gap' are indeed implying that employers are paying double (or 21% more) wage for a y chromosome.

If the wage gap rather has to do with decisions employees make themselves (such as who stays home with the kids and thus works fewer hours / has less experience / doesn't get promoted) - then it's not really the problem of employers to contend with.