Re:Understanding Hitler’s Anti-Semitism
by dang on Sunday September 13, 2015 @02:44AM
(#10210564)
On HN we try to avoid generic dismissals of new work. I'm afraid this comment counts as one.
Yes, the burden of proof is on Snyder (not "this guy") to make an argument. But he just wrote a book about it and you haven't engaged with anything specific in the argument he did make. Nor have you offered a counter-argument; that anti-Semitism was common doesn't imply that Hitler's was garden-variety. To say it was unusual "only" in how it ended is weak—that is more than unusual enough. And to criticize Synder for starting with an intuition is unfair. Much scholarly work starts that way.
Yes, the burden of proof is on Snyder (not "this guy") to make an argument. But he just wrote a book about it and you haven't engaged with anything specific in the argument he did make. Nor have you offered a counter-argument; that anti-Semitism was common doesn't imply that Hitler's was garden-variety. To say it was unusual "only" in how it ended is weak—that is more than unusual enough. And to criticize Synder for starting with an intuition is unfair. Much scholarly work starts that way.