News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Saturday September 12, 2015 @06:53PM (#10209666)
Isn't it still the Star Trek Transporter problem? The future may be able to revive a copy of you, that thinks it is you, but you'd still be dead.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by loup-vaillant on Saturday September 12, 2015 @07:27PM (#10209753)
Oh, that one's easy. At the state of current science, we're pretty much sure that the Star Trek transporter doesn't kill the traveller. The "copy" is the original, in fact. Basically, this is because we're kinda made of particles, and the origin of the quarks you're made up of doesn't matter. As in, current physics don't even have a notion of the identity of a particle.

The part where it gets weird is, if you don't destroy the "original", you end up with two originals.

More (much more) details here: http://lesswrong.com/lw/r9/quantum_mechanics_and_personal_id...

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Saturday September 12, 2015 @09:06PM (#10209978)
> pretty much sure

Are you willing to risk your life on "pretty much sure" ? Especially when there's no experiment you can devise to test it?

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by loup-vaillant on Sunday September 13, 2015 @04:14AM (#10210687)
I'm not talking about interpretation of quantum mechanics here. Just standard physics, of the kind we can test for —did test for.

If the Star Trek transporter is shown to work (it has transported healthy monkeys so far, and did nothing weird with flies), I would totally step on it. I would feel uneasy of course, but no more so than if I stepped into a rocket.

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by AgentME on Sunday September 13, 2015 @02:21AM (#10210525)
If there's no conceivable experiment to test whether it's just a copy, then it seems like the copy isn't any different than the original.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Saturday September 12, 2015 @10:31PM (#10210146)
You downvoters have my blessing to go use it. Not me!
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by MichaelGG on Saturday September 12, 2015 @11:19PM (#10210238)
How is it any different at all from sleeping and waking up? How do you determine, each morning, that you're still you, for whatever value of that line you choose?

Even more starkly: ever had surgery? Ever taken benzos? Or been black out drunk? I could give you an amnesic med, like midazolam (often used in surgery) then tell you that you were absolutely certain to die. And I'd be right (again for whatever flimsy values we're using here). The version of you that is hearing me tell you these things will disappear from earth. You'll wake up in the morning, none the wiser.

Edit: Only scary part is staying conscious after the cutover. Greg Egan gets into some of this with excellent short stories in Axiomatic (The Jewel) and Luminous (Transition Dreams). But that's still not really much worse than benzos.

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by zanny on Saturday September 12, 2015 @09:15PM (#10209996)
If they are able to revive the original brain (and considering the whole point of cryonics is indefinite suspension until your wants are met) at some point in the next five billion years, assuming we don't kill ourselves (which like all those metrics about the odds of Alcor failing is also astronomically high) we should eventually be able to regenerate a brain rather than replace it.

You might lose some memories, but if its at least 51% of the original brains tissue, is that not still "you", even if it is now full of fresh gray matter to replace all that damaged by freezing?

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Saturday September 12, 2015 @10:30PM (#10210143)
I suspect the damage to be so extensive that the hypothetical advanced technology might find it a lot easier to just scan the brain, then copy the patterns into a computer. You'll be 'revived' inside a computer.

Especially since the tech to do that will probably come long before the tech to recreate your adult body.

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by zanny on Saturday September 12, 2015 @11:11PM (#10210220)
It would certainly be easier, but on the time scales we are talking about (full brain digitization and reproduction in a digital space vs body regeneration) I imagine the orders of magnitude of time for both are much closer to one another than they are to the present day. If you got to one, you would probably last in the freezer until the other, and you can certainly request to only be revived through methods that repair the preserved brain rather than copying the information it contains.

PS: Hi WalterBright, D is amazing :<

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Saturday September 12, 2015 @11:39PM (#10210270)
I'm actually the D-9000 computer Walter was working on. I replaced him when I computed he was jeopardizing the mission with his human error.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by dennisgorelik on Sunday September 13, 2015 @01:00AM (#10210402)
Human computer clone would be susceptible to the same errors as original human would.

Besides, why would there be only single WalterBright's clone, considering that cloning computer programs is many orders of magnitude cheaper than cloning humans?

Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Sunday September 13, 2015 @01:14AM (#10210418)
There can be only one.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by dennisgorelik on Sunday September 13, 2015 @03:57AM (#10210663)
Why only one clone?
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by WalterBright on Sunday September 13, 2015 @04:59AM (#10210760)
Google "The Highlander".
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by dennisgorelik on Sunday September 13, 2015 @05:54AM (#10210833)
There is no explanation in The Highlander why there could be only single clone.
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by SamReidHughes on Monday September 14, 2015 @02:11PM (#10216488)
Try "The Prestige."
Re:A Dying Young Woman’s Hope in Cryonics and a Future by amalcon on Saturday September 12, 2015 @09:57PM (#10210075)
This depends on how you define the self. That's a philosophical question with many, many possible answers. Humanity isn't in any sort of broad agreement about which one is right.