There seems a surprising amount of techno pessimism here. Just to take the other side I think it's very likely to succeed at least to some extent. If you just assume computing and scanning keep improving a similar amount per year to what they have been then we'll have the tech to scan and simulate for example in two or three decades.
Except that there are other things you could do with the money, some of which could potentially even give you a much greater chance of not vitrifying in the first place.
Now if you would divert all cryonics resources towards existential risk mitigations, AI or rejuvenation research, that would be a different story. But pretty soon we'd have to discuss how other resources are allocated right now, and next thing we know, we're talking politics.
If you ask me, the world can probably finance cryonics for everyone and AI research and anti-ageing research and existential risk mitigation and many other things I didn't think of, while preserving and improving our standards of living at the same time. The (huge) problem is getting our act together.
You say "talking politics" like it's a bad thing!
>If you ask me, the world can probably finance cryonics for everyone and AI research and anti-ageing research and existential risk mitigation and many other things I didn't think of, while preserving and improving our standards of living at the same time. The (huge) problem is getting our act together.
Well yes.
That was unintended. But it is difficult: http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Politics_is_the_Mind-Killer
You've misunderstood the business structure of modern cryonics. A cryonics org like ALCOR is actually two organizations: one is a commercial organization which charges for storage and for the messy business of cryopreservation, and the second is a nonprofit trust which 'owns' the vitrified brains, pays the rent, conservatively invests the rest, and which will pay for the revival procedures if/when such are invented. When the commercial organization collapses, the nonprofit will simply have to have the dewars transferred somewhere else (it takes something like weeks for those things to boil down to a dangerous level; LN2 dewars are really cool!); and I believe there have already been transferrals of cryopatients in the past.
When you die, your life insurance is paying much of that out into the trust fund. There's not much question of 'whether your estate will be able to afford the procedure', since that's what the trust is for. It's not your estate's business at all.
Is it likely to happen? Honestly I have a very hard time imagining the probabilities. Financial collapse versus deliberate destruction versus horrible accident versus actually getting revived? They all seem unlikely, but once your brain is in deep freeze, its fate is one of those.
It's hard to estimate, but nonprofits in the West have OK long-term track records and the cryonics double-organization model has worked well since it was created in the aftermath of Chatsworth (which demonstrated why the commercial side must be separated). Arguably, it only needs to work for another century, and it's not like it's that hard to keep some funds conservatively invested, pay rent regularly, and react once every few decades to a problem.
I'm no neurologist but wouldn't be surprised if there's information in the brain which is encoded in ways other than which neuron is connected to which. Like, firing patterns.
Maybe you should reread my comment.
"You're essentially making a bet that someone will find something useful to do with a frozen brain -- and that your estate will be able to afford the procedure -- before the company you've entrusted your brain to either makes a mistake or collapses."
The procedure your parent was talking about is revival, not cryopreservation. Your comment talks in detail about why you think ALCOR's corporate structure makes them unlikely to collapse, but the money in ALCOR's trust is only enough to keep people frozen, not to cover revival.
(ALCOR does claim that the patient care trust will be enough to cover revival, but (a) revival could potentially be very expensive and (b) ongoing maintenance expenses have been using up the money generated by the trust and this seems likely to continue).
So you understand exactly how it's supposed to work and what I was talking about, and you were playing dumb by claiming to misinterpret my comment. Thanks.
Apparently if you have signed up for some kind of life-insurance, you simply pay your regular insurance fee, and direct them to give it to Alcor for your preservation if you die.
Or if you wish to pay in total, I've heard it's ~$80K for head only. And ~$200K for whole body.
Once I can afford any of the above options, cryonics would be my top "burial preference".
(Think about it, in the US, it's a fraction of the amount you get to spend in the final year of your life. You could choose to waste a lot of money during age 79-80 on a losing battle, or you could call it quits at 79, for which right-to-die needs to be legal, and spend a fraction on cryonics. Suffice to say, I'm a big advocate of right-to-die as well).
[0] (Warning: loud intro) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0xiX9mPB_s
If you believe they are honest and competent (which I do), there are factors to consider entirely beyond their control. Even if we assume that there are still humans around to run Alcor, that energy prices haven't skyrocketed, that cryonics haven't been made illegal for some reason, and that some kind of war or natural or man-made disaster hasn't wiped out the facility, there's still a rather high chance that some future management of Alcor will be either dishonest or incompetent and ruin the whole thing. On a 200 year scale, I'd place the odds of that alone above 90%, even if I assume maximally effective present management.
Again, this doesn't have any effect on the present benefits (hope, etc).
A vastly more likely scenario is that the company is a scam in the first place, and has no particular interest in preserving your brain, given the complete lack of any possible accountability mechanism.
There aren't that many companies in cryonics, but they've been around for a long time (30 years I think?). And there are things you can do to verify - e.g. visit their preservation rooms, etc. And people have done this.
That some dead brains are frozen at the moment?
You could verify other things too, but unfortunately, considering it's cryonics, there's not much you can verify except for the authenticity of the effort (e.g. you can't verify effectiveness of the effort since no one really knows).
It would be like a relic[1].
I'd add some testaments to it with untestable claims.
You know, the usual.
The main difference between Cryonics and more established religions is that Cryonics is an unproven sect. Major religions survived and polished their traditions for hundreds or thousands of years.
Cryonics movement is younger than Scientology[2]
---
Remember, this is a company that enters into a contract with you, if they don't do as they claim, they are hugely financially liable. They've been around for longer than many other companies, do you think they would have been able to hide massive fraud for all this time?
AFAIK, we're not talking about some "faith-healer" off in a corner somewhere, we're talking about an actually company, with facilities, doctors, etc. I imagine with open books as well, though I'm not sure.
Let me ask it the other way around - what would it take, theoretically, to convince you that it's not a scam? At least not in the way you are claiming (which is that they're not really preserving brains/bodies)?
I think there is some way to check, but why would anybody do it? Let's imagine that you work for Alcor as a technician and you find out that due to some refrigerator malfunction, dead bodies temporary unthawed.
Would you publicly report the incident or would keep silently collect your salary?
> if they don't do as they claim,
They claim to keep dead bodies frozen.
> they are hugely financially liable
Liable to what exactly?
> do you think they would have been able to hide massive fraud for all this time?
Of course.
Consider Bernie Madoff's Ponzy scheme. Alcor Life has much smaller revenue in comparison.
> convince you that it's not a scam?
Successful revival.
Do you know any technology that worked without successful tests of that technology?
E.g. they create microprocessor and claim that it works inside, but never tested it. What are the chances that this untested microprocessor would work?
"> they are hugely financially liable
Liable to what exactly?"
Well, the original point made above is that there is no way to verify they do as they claim, which is to freeze bodies/heads, in the hopes that someday in the future someone will know how to do something with it. I'm assuming that if they don't actually freeze the bodies as they say, they are committing fraud. That's what the discussion was about. That's what I meant by "liable".
"[What would it take to] > convince you that it's not a scam?
Successful revival."
Well, since no one is claiming that a successful revival is possible now, or even that a successful revival will be possible sometime in the future, I don't think that's a fair thing to demand.
Again, as long as they're clearly explaining the idea behind this, as long as they're not trying to trick anyone by promising something that doesn't exist, which they aren't, then I don't think it's fair to call it a scam.
I just find it a little sad that, at least as far as I can tell, most of the people involved in this are people who really believe in the mission. They're not lying, not misleading people, giving all the facts, and yet, everyone just assumes it's a fraud or a scam.
2) "in the hopes that someday in the future someone will know"
They promote and claim that revival will be possible in the future. Without any proof. So it is a confidence game. Hence "scam".
There is a good chance that successful freezing and revival would be possible in the future.
But it is very unlikely that revival of dead bodies that Alcor is freezing today would ever be possible.
> most of the people involved in this are people who really believe in the mission
You can say the same about any established religion.
> They're not lying, not misleading people,
Sorry, internal belief is not a guarantee that the statements are true and not misleading.
Again, if you're talking about some group like Alcor, they say it may be possible in the future.
I'd love it if you could provide some kind of evidence that they're not presenting the truth or trying to dupe people. Especially considering that so few people have actually signed up, so I'm guessing most people who sign up do it after a lot of research.
By default you should assume that stuff does NOT work.
If only few people actually sign up, that is a telling sign that most of people cannot find any proof that advertised service works.
It also may make sense to use cryonics for future cure of deceases, assuming that cryonics work.
But now we should assume that cryonics does NOT work, and everyone who claims (or hints) otherwise without testing is a scammer.
Their conference is in October. I'm going. (I signed up with Alcor after Hal Finney; the only thing worse is dying, and I'd like it to get better...)
$1k/yr between membership and a 20y 500k term life policy seems cheap enough to me.
Logic and reason assures that it almost certainly is not going to work, but the value of the potential upside is effectively infinite to that individual, so it still may be a rational investment.
Life does not have infinite value. People, including atheists, sometimes give their own life for some higher purpose (another life, freedom, a better standard of living for their village…).
Of course, this would be different if you seek to escape Hell. (You might be religious, and guilty of some mortal sin.)
The researchers from the future may put your brain into very painful condition in order to keep it functional.
Would cryonic worth it?
Shambling about like some lonely museum piece come to life sounds pretty worthless to me, personally. The value of a human life is in its context of family and society.
Have them sign up with you!
Seriously, do have them sign up with you. You don't have to be alone.
Your brain might contain nothing of value to that society, except as a store of archaic knowledge, or maybe as a substrate for computing. They may never even bother reviving someone as a conscious, self-aware being, or if they do, it may be for a zoo or a lifetime of slavery for the machines which I assume for no particular reason will have taken over.
Dying in the jungle in pursuit of the fountain of youth or bathing in the blood of the young rightfully comes off as bonkers to healthy people.
Check your arrogance levels, they're way off.
Sane people are actually very much afraid of death. Anyone would have a much easier time proving that it is insanity not to be afraid of death, than the opposite.
> It takes a weird sort of narcissism to pursue cryonics.
It takes a much nastier sort of narcissism to be judgemental about how people decide their bodies will be handled after death.
> Dying in the jungle in pursuit of the fountain of youth or bathing in the blood of the young rightfully comes off as bonkers to healthy people.
Nobody is bathing in blood. If this is what you are actually reading in this topic, I recommend therapy.
A more neutral example would be someone who thoroughly investigates dietary health, and makes sure to eat a nutritious, healthy diet full of fresh vegetables and whatnot. Which is CLEARLY insane, /s.
I think people are comfortable only because it is inevitable. Given a universe that death did not exist in, would you consider it sane to introduce it?
Considering the long history of the motivation of seeking immortality in literature, and that it's not typically presented in a "hey, look at this freak, what sort of nutjob would want to be immortal, am I right?"[0] sort of way, I think your use of the words "sane" and "weird" aren't on the right track.
Narcissism... sure. But a normal sort.
Also, religions in general seem to spend a lot of time and effort on helping people overcome discomfort with death. Why? Are most people insane, then?
[0] Cautionary tales aplenty, yes, but authors don't typically expect the reader to consider this as a strange motivation, I would say. Why caution against pursuing something no sane, merely-ordinarilly-narcisistic person would pursue anyway?
What? Why should people be perfectly accepting of cessation of existence at ~80? People not wanting to die at 20 is perfectly normal, are you meant to get bored of life at 80 or something?
>Dying in the jungle in pursuit of the fountain of youth or bathing in the blood of the young rightfully comes off as bonkers to healthy people.
Let's rephrase that a bit to apply to money:
>Dying in the jungle in pursuit of the city of El Dorado, or killing people and selling their organs on the stock market rightfully comes off as bonkers to healthy people.
...and therefore pursuing money is clearly psychotic, and we should throw all entrepreneurs in the loonie bin?
The concerns about your frozen remains spoiling before anything happens is valid, but I personally suspect that unfreezing will play out like Social Security, but in reverse order. If we're unfrozen, it will be paid for (or prompted, in whatever post-scarcity Star Trek economy exists in the future) by our children and grandchildren, who will be unfrozen by their children and grandchildren, or childhood friend who misses them, or former coworker, and so on down the line.
There's probably no practical or economic reason for future people to unfreeze corpsicles, but there are sentimental ones. So I'm not so much worried about estates needing to pay for unfreezing or some future banks needing COBOL programmers.
Something is deeply wrong with this way of thinking: it doesn't value human life at all.
Here's another version. Someone comes to you seeking for help. He's dying. He could be saved by some recently devised miraculous medical procedure, which would return him to full health. The catch is, that procedure is relatively expensive (let's say a few weeks worth of your own salary). Question: would you let him die?
Put it this way, of course not. But we tend to forget that cryopreservation, if it works, is exactly the same.
See, a preserved person, provided she can actually be reconstructed back to life, is not actually dead. She's mostly dead. There's a difference. Think of it as a very deep coma. So, if we ever devise a proper reconstruction procedure, we have two choices: (i) pay for the procedure and heal that patient at last; or (ii) don't pay and let the patient drift into utter annihilation.
Heal or don't heal. It's that simple.
---
Now maybe you assume a frozen brain is not a living person. Maybe you're right. Maybe the preservation wasn't good enough on this particular brain. Maybe the preservation procedure was flawed to begin with. Maybe the brain doesn't hold enough information about a person to begin with. Maybe we won't find the technological means to actually get the brain back to its old state —even if it's theoretically possible. Maybe we won't be able to fix whatever caused the brainwaves to go flat in the first place —if that's fixable even in theory, see Alzheimer. I'm sure I've forgotten lots of ways this could go horribly wrong. Anyway, if any of this is true, that frozen brain can't be recovered, does count as dead, and you'd be right to call it a "frozen brain" instead of a "patient".
The thing is, to the best of our current knowledge, the odds are not nil. They're not good, but they're not nil. There is a chance that the brain is actually alive —I mean, in some real deep coma. I'm not talking about some abstract hope here, but some actual probabilities of the kind you have for experimental drugs on cancer patients. Slim, but real.
And of course, if we somehow come up with an actual reconstruction procedure, if we somehow can examine the brain and be assured that yes, a return to full health is not only possible, but highly probable, then we'll know that brain was alive all along. That it was a living person in dire need of healing.
Surely the people of the future would be willing to pay for such healing? If not strangers, maybe (distant) relatives? Some philanthropist? The transhumanist community? Government or mutual funds? Today, people pay good money to give Kim a very slim hope of living again. In what kind of bleak world would no one be willing to pay for a probable return to full health?
This one.
People are dying now because of diseases we have basically eradicated in rich countries. The choice you're talking about making, saving a life for a few weeks worth of your own salary, is one that is already available to you and many others. What are you doing about it?
Now, I think you're right that it's horribly wrong to be letting people die when it's so easily avoidable, and I donate half my salary to help make things better, but most people don't think this way--most people just spend their money on themselves. Which means that if you're relying on the generosity of others to revive you you're probably going to be out of luck.
You're living proof of this. (Me… less so. I don't donate much.)
Amalcom on the other hand formulated things in such a way that it would be normal, expected to receive no outside help from the future. I disagree with that assumption. Expecting from the outset that the future will not help us is ludicrous. It's not guaranteed, but come on, we still have people like you, philanthropists, governments, and mutual funds —there's some things to say about the effectiveness of collective action vs individual choice: it's easier to donate or pay up when you know you're not alone.
So I ask again: in what kind of bleak world would NO ONE be willing to pay?
Edit: > In what kind of bleak world would no one be willing to pay for a probable return to full health?
This one. People die of totally curable conditions all the time in the real, modern world.
Even Greg Egan took a whole short story to do it.
http://ttapress.com/553/crystal-nights-by-greg-egan/
“You know what they say the modern version of Pascal’s Wager is? Sucking up to as many Transhumanists as possible, just in case one of them turns into God. Perhaps your motto should be ‘Treat every chatterbot kindly, it might turn out to be the deity’s uncle’.”
edit: and when I scroll down I see I've been beaten to the Greg Egan punch. Great minds, I suppose...
And mostly dead is partly alive. If she were all dead, well, there's only one thing you can do -- go through her pockets and look for loose change.
The part where it gets weird is, if you don't destroy the "original", you end up with two originals.
More (much more) details here: http://lesswrong.com/lw/r9/quantum_mechanics_and_personal_id...
Are you willing to risk your life on "pretty much sure" ? Especially when there's no experiment you can devise to test it?
If the Star Trek transporter is shown to work (it has transported healthy monkeys so far, and did nothing weird with flies), I would totally step on it. I would feel uneasy of course, but no more so than if I stepped into a rocket.
Even more starkly: ever had surgery? Ever taken benzos? Or been black out drunk? I could give you an amnesic med, like midazolam (often used in surgery) then tell you that you were absolutely certain to die. And I'd be right (again for whatever flimsy values we're using here). The version of you that is hearing me tell you these things will disappear from earth. You'll wake up in the morning, none the wiser.
Edit: Only scary part is staying conscious after the cutover. Greg Egan gets into some of this with excellent short stories in Axiomatic (The Jewel) and Luminous (Transition Dreams). But that's still not really much worse than benzos.
You might lose some memories, but if its at least 51% of the original brains tissue, is that not still "you", even if it is now full of fresh gray matter to replace all that damaged by freezing?
Especially since the tech to do that will probably come long before the tech to recreate your adult body.
PS: Hi WalterBright, D is amazing :<
Besides, why would there be only single WalterBright's clone, considering that cloning computer programs is many orders of magnitude cheaper than cloning humans?
On the face of it, it seems insane. You're essentially making a bet that someone will find something useful to do with a frozen brain -- and that your estate will be able to afford the procedure -- before the company you've entrusted your brain to either makes a mistake or collapses. Given the near-total lack of progress on the former front (there's been considerable progress in the freezing part, but almost none in finding a useful thing to do with a frozen brain), the odds seem phenomenally bad.
On the other hand, it does offer something to those who are still alive: the hope that your exstence could continue indefinitely, and that you might get to be with lost loved ones again. This is a valuable hope, so much so that it's built into most religions in some form or other. It's possible that the benefit of this hope makes the costs worth bearing.
For now, I've left cryonics in my "not for me, but I won't try to discourage anyone else" bucket.