Los Angeles to San Francisco 400 miles
Los Angeles to San Diego 150 miles
NYC to Philadelphia 92 miles
NYC to Boston 220 miles
NYC to Washington DC 226 miles
Chicago to St Louis 260 miles
Dallas to Houston 240 miles
Dallas to Austin 200 miles
Austin to Houston 170 miles
Tampa to Orlando 85 miles
Miami to Orlando 235 miles
---
Population of Rome: 2.7m
Population of Milan: 1.3m
Rome to Milan: 355 miles
* smaller: not really... depends where you count.
* more population dense: nobody is expecting good rail transit in Wyoming or Montana (although, Scandinavia seems to do okay with low density). The Northeast, Midwest, and California are all very dense and still have much worse rail transit.
Yes, the EU is quite a bit smaller than the US - but there is an awful lot of Europe that isn't in the EU.
Personally, I think it's about the distribution of population in Europe - where most population centers are reasonably close together and with the peripheries less populous whereas the US has populations towards the peripheries and a relatively sparsely populated center (roughly).
China: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/cd/Populati...
USA: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_U.S._states_by_populat...
People concentrate regardless of land size. Feel free to quote population density when you are a russian farmer in Siberia brewing vodka, but chances are the argument falls utterly flat.
http://static.persquaremile.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/u...
Wyoming, in particular, has a lower population density than Siberia!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Krasnoyarsk_Krai
[NB And there appears to be an even bigger and emptier bit of Siberia next door but I haven't worked out what it is yet!]
Saying Norway has high speed rail is like saying that the US has a monorail system.
Europe can afford to have better trains and public transit systems across the board because it's easier for us to have a consistent level of quality, since we simply have much less area to service and trains are a viable alternative for a massive portion of the populace.
If instead that money could used to revitalize that stretch, it could be much more useful. America rail went through each small town as it already existed and the track is too twisty to go very fast over a lot of the stretch.
And it's all so we can have trains that go from DC to Chicago in like 12 hours + 0-3 hours of delays. That route is unnecessary. A DC to Chicago flight is 1:45 hours and is cheap as fuck. Plus we have buses that use the highways.
Our rail sucks because we propping up useless routes.
But, yeah, from a utilitarian perspective I've never found inter-city Amtrak travel to make a lot of sense in the US outside of the Northeast (nor, in many cases, Europe for that matter).
https://www.google.de/maps/place/Boston,+MA,+USA/@42.2970681...
Germany simply doesn't have that. The infrastructural implications are massive.
The article sort of went off the, um, rails when it basically suggested that if only US cities were bulldozed and re-engineered to the priorities of less land-rich continent then rail would make a lot more sense.
I even like taking the train in general but it's hard to make the numbers work in much of the US.