But what's the benefit? Maybe a few percent speed/power efficiency boost? We've already seen that Apple will go to extraordinary lengths for a few percent improved performance, particularly when it comes to power efficiency. A few percent here, a few more there and soon you're talking an hour+ extra battery life.
I think this is highly plausible. There just doesn't seem to be any particular reason why they wouldn't do it, and plenty of reasons why they would.
How is LLVM IR (which I am told is arch specific) different from GCC with RTL?
Remember the transition from VAX to Alpha? And they kept the binary and source compatibility in quite an inventive way (with both binary translation and by making MACRO32 just another high level language).
Margins is the only important thing for Apple, nothing else matters.
x86-64 isn't. I've measured this: the average instruction length is just about 4 bytes. REX prefixes add up quick.
Sure, the semantic gap exists. But ARM and x86 have evolved and have overcome a lot of difficulties.
People like to bash x86 but it has a big advantage: it's compact. ARM Thumb is compact but not so much.
Also remember how big the last 'new ISA' (Itanium) success was?
Compiler and processor front-end beat "perfect ISA" today