My wife is at the center of this. She recently left a job as "Director of Budget and Reimbursement", and now works as "Directory for Regulatory Affairs" for a healthcare financial consultancy. So she's been the one directly responsible for the way the hospital accounts for its costs (or fails to do so).
The primary problem, at least from her perspective, is that they're effectively forced to do it this way. Medicare, and Medicaid which largely rides on many of -care's definitional coattails, is a monopsony player in the market. When you hear people claim that Medicare is more efficient than conventional commercial insurance, that's significantly because they offload much of their administrative burden onto the healthcare providers. Every hospital has a department of several FTEs whose job it is to track a defined set of metrics, including various cost parameters, patient demographics, etc., and report them to the government (the so-called "Medicare Cost Report" that my wife and her department spent a month or so on every year). That is, getting paid by the source of the largest part of the hospital's revenue entails tracking and reporting the way Medicare wants you to do it.
So that right there forces hospitals into watching their costs according to a scheme effectively mandated by the government. Thus, they're not tracking the data in a way that would give relevant cost accounting data in the way you expect it.
There's your proximate cause. But it still begs the question, "why don't they also track costs in a rational fashion, actually reflecting reality?". Part of the answer is that their margins are so low that they simply can't afford a second set of accountants and the procedural overhead that it would require.
That's not a wholly satisfying answer, because hospitals are the only industry I'm aware of that still makes extensive use of secretaries. You'd think that if they need to be so conscious of costs, they'd be looking at the kind of personnel expenses that most of private industry has figured out how to streamline. Conversation with my wife hasn't yielded any insight beyond that.
So you have an added layer of abstraction between what the service is costing and what the hospital is being paid. This system was put in place to simplify the pricing procedure so that it did not have to be done on a case by case basis. But it limits most hospitals to only really caring to this higher level of detail.
I've been advocating that we require them to charge the same price for a given service to all patients regardless of insurance or anything else. To clarify, we should not dictate the price, just that one provider charge the same price to all its patients. I never would have thought they couldn't even figure out what those prices need to be.
Any business that doesn't even have a clue about these things is clearly rolling in dough and probably corruption.
The lobby needs to be mopped. The parking lot needs light. The lawn probably should be kept from turning into a forest. The heat should run in winter, and the cooing in summer.
Which hospital users get stuck paying for those things? What is your fair share?
Or we could just have single payer. But if we can't have that, I think the above would be a fair bit better than the mess we have now.
But what if it's not so serious, and not an emergency? People have rotator cuff issues that they take years to get fixed regularly. Or a hip replacement? That's rarely an emergency but rather a solution to long term pain that's not painkillers.
I think the other thing a lot of people would like to see is some kind of doctor and hospital report card so that you could compare on price AND quality. Which would be great as it'd force the terrible surgeons who regularly do such a bad job (accidentally or on purpose) that their patients have complications, die, etc out of that line of work.
Obviously there would have to be some kind of risk classification system so that doctors and hospitals that take on high risk patients wouldn't be punished for doing so, but I think that some kind of "hot or not" style risk assessment system could be developed whereby doctors spend 15 minutes a day reviewing risks anonymously for other doctors and each case gets rated 5 times and that determines the risk score to hopefully remove all bias.
It's definitely worth quantifying the cost of providing medical care, but doing it in a more fine grained way than at the department level.
I think you could have been more explicit about (what you now say was) your core point.
Yes it does vary dramatically, but there's no way there's 3 orders of magnitude of variation and definitely not 2 orders. There might be a single order from top to bottom, a 2 hour surgery versus a 20 hour surgery or a 15 minute visit with a doctor versus a couple of hours with a doctor.
Lawyers have the same problem and while they do bill by the hour, they can generally give you a pretty good idea of what the more basic things might cost to handle. I'm not suggesting that they could give you a +-3% estimate for your SCO vs IBM lawsuit, but if it's a DUI or a will or a trust or whatever, once they've done it a few times they know how the game is played.
I totally get that people aren't courts and doctors aren't lawyers, but I think it's a decent counter-example to the notion of "it's hard so why bother trying?"
How on earth could you possibly makes a cost vs. value trade off if you don't know the cost? You might have a hospital with better outcomes that charges 1/2 of that of another hospital with worse outcomes. Unless you know the cost, you'll never make the system efficient.
Medicare already does it. There are ~700 diagnosis codes that capture everything you might need to do to a patient admitted to the hospital. The diagnosis codes are linked to a dollar amount that is supposed to cover everything (except labor which is a separate payment).
I'd also argue a routine diagnostic procedure, like a blood test, is pretty comparable to a mechanic doing an oil change.
Sure, like with anything, there may be some unknowns that cause some variations in the implementation of the procedure, but it's likely a valid (in most cases) way to track performance and control costs. If some hospital is regularly charging 2 standard deviations more than other hospitals for same procedures, that seems it would be a red flag.
Or if a doctor is regularly taking 2 standard deviations longer to perform same procedures as the rest of his/her peers, that's a red flag.
FYI defining the "peers" part of that calculus is the hard part. Physicians choose their patients. Those that choose low hanging fruit do quite well in metrics. It doesn't require much skill to pick low hanging fruit. It turns out that those who are good at picking fruit from the top of the tree, tend to be called on to pick fruit from the top of the tree.
Individual procedure codes in no way communicate anything about difficulty.
Ultimately I think those edge cases can be fleshed out and monitored with regular auditing.
You sure about that? I also use my experience to filter out clients that are going to be a huge pain in my tail. When I was less experienced I ended up with some jobs that were huge messes because I didn't see the warning signs. Now that I can better predetermine the work involved I can choose not to take the job, or I can correctly tell the client the job will be much harder than it actually appears to be.
In the long run, though, I think (in an open market system) always turning down hard cases (for example referrals from peers, or people who specifically seek you out for your expertise) can negatively affect your reputation. In the end I might call it a wash because the person who is truly trying to do the least amount of work for the most personal benefit wouldn't try to stand out by finishing their work substantially faster than their peers or charging substantially less. So you probably lose a lot of the marketing benefit of out performing your peers since your ideal scenario will be to remain hidden in the pack. And by doing, it seems reasonable to assume people won't be trying to knock down your door to get you to do work for them like someone who is accepting the more challenging work and doing so successfully.
At least not as a broad generalization. However of course people who are good at what they do generally have more opportunities to make more money than those who are not.
Flat rate mechanics have a book that says repair X takes Y many hours. If it takes the mechanic less, the shop benefits. If it takes more, the shop loses. But in the end, only Y many hours are billed.
Why can't it work similar for hospitals?
That seems pretty silly. There are plenty of procedures with marginal effect on survival and/or quality-of-life, and a health-care consumer will have varying preferences for them.
A rich man might be willing to spend an hour in an MRI if he's sprained his ankle; a poor man might prefer to keep his money and walk it off. Neither is wrong: they just have different preferences.
For that matter, given a choice between a $15 pill of Tylenol and dealing with an ache, I'd take the ache every day of the wee.k
Hospitals have no clue what it costs them to serve an individual patient.
The lowest level where they understand costs is at the service level (e.g. ER, cardiac lab, stroke center). It's one of the reasons why you see all the wonky prices from hospitals: they just "create" prices for individual procedures until it covers their aggregate costs. It doesn't really matter to the hospital if procedure A is $1K and procedure B is $5K. As long as Arate + Brate > costs, they are fine with it.