News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are a hospital's costs? by rayiner on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @04:34PM (#10188071)
I think everyone misunderstood my point, which is that apportioning those costs on a procedure level is a fiction. Almost all of your costs are fixed: salaries, facilities, equipment. And the amount of procedures you can do with those fixed resources varies dramatically.

It's definitely worth quantifying the cost of providing medical care, but doing it in a more fine grained way than at the department level.

Re:What are a hospital's costs? by SilasX on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @07:17PM (#10188762)
If I may give some feedback: I don't know how anyone could have read your post as being about the appropriate level of economization of medical care due to the relative importance of fixed vs variable costs. Your comment says nothing about that, and just comes off like the usual screed about "how dare you apply accounting to health care, this is too important for that!"

I think you could have been more explicit about (what you now say was) your core point.

Re:What are a hospital's costs? by msandford on Tuesday September 08, 2015 @10:34PM (#10189357)
> Almost all of your costs are fixed: salaries, facilities, equipment. And the amount of procedures you can do with those fixed resources varies dramatically.

Yes it does vary dramatically, but there's no way there's 3 orders of magnitude of variation and definitely not 2 orders. There might be a single order from top to bottom, a 2 hour surgery versus a 20 hour surgery or a 15 minute visit with a doctor versus a couple of hours with a doctor.

Lawyers have the same problem and while they do bill by the hour, they can generally give you a pretty good idea of what the more basic things might cost to handle. I'm not suggesting that they could give you a +-3% estimate for your SCO vs IBM lawsuit, but if it's a DUI or a will or a trust or whatever, once they've done it a few times they know how the game is played.

I totally get that people aren't courts and doctors aren't lawyers, but I think it's a decent counter-example to the notion of "it's hard so why bother trying?"