News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by kuschku on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:10PM (#10179264)
I’d like to complain: For me, from Germany, the Paywall workarounds for WSJ do NOT work at all. This means I can’t read those articles, and have to use proxies to do so. This is not acceptable.

EDIT: One solution would be to use a link to a webcache, or screenshot, waybackmachine, or similar

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by nkurz on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:13PM (#10179466)
When you say "This is not acceptable", what do you mean? If a link is accessible from Germany without a proxy but not the US, would that be acceptable? What if it's accessible to you in Germany and me in the US without a proxy, but not to someone in China unless they use a proxy?

So maybe it's OK to require a proxy from China? But what if a user in North Korea can't access a proxy? Should that link also be prohibited on HN? How is HN supposed to know what consists of an acceptable workaround, and what does not? Are the standards different for different countries?

It seems simpler to assume that the articles that get upvotes have people who want to read them, and that if people want to read the article everyone is raving about, they will find a way. It's Hacker News after all.

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by kuschku on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:27PM (#10179492)
If a link is not available to everyone, link to archive.org, or archive.is, or Google webcache.

This means everyone can read it.

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by dang on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:45PM (#10179527)
People do that in the threads, which is helpful. It's usually better not to supplant the canonical URL of a story in its link.

This problem will get a lot easier when we have a way to group the related URLs for a story. That's something we are eventually going to work on. Indeed, I wonder if it couldn't turn into a broader solution to the paywall question.

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by nkurz on Sunday September 06, 2015 @08:21PM (#10179609)
The Google scholar approach might work as a format. Official link as the hypertext, publicly accessible link (if available) in the right column. https://scholar.google.com/scholar?cites=1273530321270058317...
Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by JorgeGT on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:13PM (#10179278)
Same here in Spain, I think it's geoIP based.
Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by MichaelGG on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:46PM (#10179373)
A: This is something pretty terrible and should be in violation of search engine rules. So perhaps file a complaint.

B: Even Google gets on the geo-IP bus and will outright 404 pages in some zones with zero indication that the URL was ever OK. Recent example was the Google Solar Roof thing - in some countries, it was just a 404, nothing else.

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by kuschku on Sunday September 06, 2015 @07:13PM (#10179464)
Maybe there should be some flag about GeoIP'd posts?

Or just outright banning them?

Re:Tell HN: Paywalls with workarounds are OK; paywall compla... by felipebueno on Sunday September 06, 2015 @06:56PM (#10179414)
Same here in Brazil.