News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by breck on Sunday December 27, 2009 @03:58PM (#1017589)
I tried this for my hometown of 100,000 3 years ago. I spent about 50 hours on it (it was called brocktonpost.com). It had amazing features. No one used it.

My recommendation: Wait for Craigslist to come in.

> less than 15,000 people or so

If 1% of people used this, that's 150 people. You might want to start with a simpler email group instead. If you can get 150 using an email list, then make a website to accompany it.

The hard part isn't the software. In fact, it's 1000x easier to get the software going than to get people to use it.

Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by joe_the_user on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:12PM (#1017629)
Yes,

Especially since craigslist will come in eventually and so your fix will be temporary if it's only aiming to be like craigslist.

Hey, you could even write Craig and ask him to include you. I know places in rural California well-served by craigslist.

Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by JayNeely on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:31PM (#1017660)
I have to disagree.

1) To clarify on the purpose a bit, it's aim wouldn't be to be just like Craigslist. Craigslist is good, but has plenty of room for imrpovement. And the unique characteristics of a local community make a more customized solution (church sections, farming & agriculture sections, different job categories as a few possible examples) a better option. While this may start by being a simple classifieds Craigslist-like, it could evolve into something very different.

2) One of the main points of what I'm looking for is the ability to setup a simplified Craigslist-like site. Craigslist has too many subsections to make it easy to show activity in a newly active area.

3) It's always easier to promote, and gain buy-in, for a more specific (in this case, local) solution.

None the less, thanks for the comment, and idea of writing Craig directly to ask for an area section to be created.

Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by cvg on Sunday December 27, 2009 @05:49PM (#1017744)
While you're waiting, might as well ask if Craigslist could create a geo for you. It doesn't seem to be too difficult for them to add cities these days. You'll probably need to make a good case though.
Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by JayNeely on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:08PM (#1017618)
If you were to do it again, what would you do different? What worked best for getting some users?

I definitely understand the software is the easier part -- that's why I'm getting started with it and looking for the simplest option available. I understand the basics of building community sites:

* seed content, and seed interaction with a small core of dedicated users.

* setup natural flows from existing online communities serving portions of the same audience. Facebook communities, Hiawassee's Topix forum, etc.

* Reward action, and encourage sense of belonging in a community.

Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by breck on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:55PM (#1017697)
I would just start an email list.

I would go door to door if I have to and tell people "I want to create a classifieds for our community, can I add your email address?" (Then ask them for their neighbor's emails too)

To post, people can send you an email and then you can compile it.

Do this for 1 week and see if you can get 100-500 people this way.

Then create a simple 1 page site that just reposts the emails. Then create a simple form that allows people to post directly. Then add categories.

I wouldn't skip any steps.

Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by jasonlbaptiste on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:45PM (#1017684)
Craigslist started as an email list.
Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by breck on Sunday December 27, 2009 @04:52PM (#1017693)
exactly
Re:Ask HN: How to setup scaled-down Craigslist for my strugg... by jasonlbaptiste on Sunday December 27, 2009 @05:10PM (#1017714)
Also, I see a need for some type of local email/sms/update service. You could throw classifieds or something like it in there. My university has an alert system when alerts happen. I would love to get that for my local town.