News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by seibelj on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:51PM (#10153800)
I'm a big self-driving cars skeptic. Expecting humans to "drive less idiotic" is basically saying that google's cars won't work until human drivers are banned. Driving is something of an art, and it's full of edge cases. So many edge cases.

I'll just keep reading articles that say they are 5 years away, just as I did 5 years ago, and the armchair futurists will keep dreaming...

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by teraflop on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:05PM (#10153942)
> Expecting humans to "drive less idiotic" is basically saying that google's cars won't work until human drivers are banned.

You should be skeptical of drawing conclusions based on a news article's two-word excerpt of a presumably much longer comment. I seriously doubt Google actually thinks their cars will only be usable if human drivers massively change their behavior. It sounds more like an off-hand joke than a serious description of their product strategy.

> I'll just keep reading articles that say they are 5 years away, just as I did 5 years ago, and the armchair futurists will keep dreaming...

Ten years ago, the best autonomous vehicles in the world could barely make it through an empty desert test track. Five years ago, they could do a reasonable job of navigating urban areas that were closed off from normal traffic. Today they drive about 50 miles per day, per car on public roads with a safety driver. It's likely not much longer before the safety drivers are considered unnecessary.

If you want to get a skewed, unreliable view of how this technology is developing, feel free to keep listening to "armchair futurists". But if you actually look at what the engineers who are working on it say, and what they've actually achieved, it's clear that steady progress is being made.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by baddox on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:09PM (#10153985)
I can appreciate the claim that driving is an art, full of edge cases. But that claim on its own conceals the reality that humans are extremely bad at it. A ludicrous number of people die in automobile accidents. While it may be a long while before self-driving cars can match the prowess of an excellent driver, much less a professional one, I doubt we're far off from being able to exceed the ability of the average driver.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by ghaff on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:20PM (#10155831)
Define ludicrously bad. Yes there are a lot of accidents and fatalities every year. However the rate of fatalities in the U.S. Is 1 per 100 million miles driven which isn't intuitively a ridiculously high rate.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by baddox on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:04PM (#10156109)
I don't think that fatalities per miles driven is that useful of a statistic, except for the other conversation of how to enable people to drive fewer miles (which I certainly approve of). It's still just abysmal that 30,000 people each year die doing something extremely routine that is virtually required to live in most areas. That's something like a quarter of US deaths from accidents/injuries. And, of course, there are presumably far more injuries than there are deaths, plus property damage.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by fizzbatter on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:06PM (#10153958)
> I'll just keep reading articles that say they are 5 years away, just as I did 5 years ago, and the armchair futurists will keep dreaming...

I'm quite surprised that you can be a skeptic on the concept as a whole. Being skeptical about the given timeframes is perfectly reasonable (and probably correct), but humans do so, so many things terribly. We have automated away so many tasks in our world, both for efficiency and safety, that i can't even see an argument to counter that.

To extend that further then, why shouldn't we want human drivers off the roads asap? It's a dangerous act that, frankly, many people aren't qualified for.

Self-driving cars have so much potential behind them, that being a "skeptic" seems quite confusing to me. Just because it's a difficult problem, does not warrant giving up. The safety benefits alone, are well, well worth it.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by joeclark77 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:22PM (#10154103)
Cars give us freedom. The reason that technocrats love "self-driving" cars is the same reason they love trains of all kinds: it means that "the system" controls who may go where, and when. A lot of us are skeptical of self-driving cars because a lot of their advocates want the next step to be banning private citizens from driving, which you've just confirmed, thanks.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by fizzbatter on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:34PM (#10155918)
> A lot of us are skeptical of self-driving cars because a lot of their advocates want the next step to be banning private citizens from driving, which you've just confirmed, thanks.

Lol, i think you're mistaking my (attempted) logical thinking towards some type of agenda towards banning humans driving cars. You seem far more agenda driven, heh.

Just because i think we are extremely unqualified for driving, does not mean i want to ban the act. It be extremely improbable to achieve, with all the costs of upgrading the entire infrastructure alone making your defense of this almost seem like a half hearted joke. Moreover, even if in some magic realm where we can make all cars into self driving cars to abolish human driving, i'm just simply not in favor of removing human rights.

Yes, i would want to make it difficult for you to drive, but for your own (and mine!) safety. Our safety standards for driving tests are incredibly, and i mean incredibly, laughable. How often we enforce rules and laws for driving are also laughable. Almost no one even follows some of the most basic rules, like speed limits, and the more extreme people often break sobriety laws.

Self driving cars would give us a platform to A: Raise the bar for who can drive, and what sort of training you need. and B: Be more willing to ban someone from driving if they put others at risk, through speed, drugs, alcohol, or whatever.

We have a hard time banning drivers these days because it very negatively impacts your life if you cannot drive. In a world with self driving cars though, you can still have a first class life. Driving is now something of leisure.

Anyway, nice try at putting words in my mouth - next time make them a little less tinfoil though, please.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by linkregister on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @03:17PM (#10154977)
Given the current electorate in the United States, I think it would be nigh-impossible that human-driving cars would be banned. Notwithstanding the fact that the cost to equip every vehicle on the road with self-driving technology would be wildly expensive in the short term, Americans respond vigorously to threats to freedoms that are ingrained in their culture (visceral freedoms, not freedoms that are less tangible, such as electronic privacy). Examples: firearms, tobacco, alcohol.

I could foresee this happening in one or two Western European countries, though I would expect Germany and Central Europe to hold out (the German electorate resists regulation that impedes the speed and power of their automobiles).

An aside: how would a car being self-driving affect the owner's ability to direct it wherever he or she pleases?

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by joeclark77 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @04:05PM (#10155303)
If the car is driven by a computer at Google, then it can be "hijacked" by the computer. A few years after mandating that everybody have self-driving cars, the argument will be that certain roads don't need to be in the system because there's far too little traffic. After that, it'll be argued that Google should be able to divert you away from certain areas of town where there's been high traffic or other hazards, without asking you. Then it'll be argued that the government can mandate certain routes in order to preserve the environment or some such excuse. Then it'll be seen as entirely reasonable that all auto "routes" be managed by city planners who want to control noise, pollution, etc, for your own good. It'll be incremental.

Fortunately, as you say, there are still a majority of sane people who vote in the USA. Will that still be true a generation later?

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by dTal on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:43PM (#10156302)
>city planners who want to control noise, pollution, etc

I would predict electric cars before self-driving cars, so they won't have that excuse at least.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by joeclark77 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @10:19PM (#10157077)
I would predict that I'll never drive one of those deathtraps either!
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by lukaslalinsky on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @03:59PM (#10155272)
Self-driving cars will always have limitations. It's just not possible to make it ready for all kinds of road or even off-road surfaces. Fast-forward into future, if human-driven cars get banned, there will be no reason for self-driving cars to have manual controls and the only option for car will be to refuse to go into a situation it can't handle.

I very much believe in gradual improvements and that is what many large car manufacturers are doing. I can easily imagine not needing to control my car on a highway, in a city, or when parking it, but I expect the manual controls will stay there for a very very long time.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by koenigdavidmj on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:03PM (#10153926)
You are still not applying equal measures to the Google car and a hypothetical human driver. Your standard for humans is the current rate of accidents. Your standard for the Google car is absolute perfection. Not being in an accident. Ever. Even one caused by inattentive drivers. Otherwise, they're not ready.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by ghaff on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:01PM (#10153903)
Pretty much. All the summon-a-robocar with an app in 5-10 years predictions seem to merrily ignore all the edge cases having to do with weather, direct driver interactions (e.g waving someone out into traffic), construction, parking in unmarked spaces, etc., etc. I have little doubt that autonomous highway driving for example is both achievable and desirable but a lot of folks extrapolate that to the more general case which is much, much harder.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by waterlesscloud on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:03PM (#10153916)
The people developing Google's autonomous car say it will be available for consumers in four years.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by x3n0ph3n3 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:06PM (#10153950)
I'm a big human-driven car skeptic. Expecting humans to "drive less idiotic" is basically saying that accident rates won't go down until human drivers are banned. Driving is something of an art and it's full of edge cases. Can we expect all humans to be driving artists?
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by logicallee on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:57PM (#10153860)
except driverless cars have been driving around in California for a couple of years thanks to Google (and the fact that it's legal). Soon the term "driverless" will be like "horseless". Why would you keep your eyes on the road when a machine will do it for you, and with more awareness of its surroundings at 360 degrees, and the ability to judge the position and trajectory/velocity of any object to within a couple of m/s instantly, or react to anything in milliseconds?

Don't kid yourself: humans aren't some kind of perfect driver. A bit of sleepiness, a text message, a tiny distraction in the car, and their responsiveness plummets.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by joeclark77 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @02:43PM (#10154735)
Cars give you the freedom to go anywhere, any time, without having to file a plan or ask permission from the government or from Google. You want to give up that freedom in exchange for a little safety? Go ahead, but a lot of people will never be converted.
Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by logicallee on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @02:55PM (#10154830)
joe you did not give this serious thought. Cars are highly regulated, you need to get a state-issues driver's liccense just to drive one, they need to be registered, etc.

I was going to just reply with "Horses give you the freedom to go anywhere, any time, without having to build roads or get a drivers ..." and then I'm like, wait a minute.... there's all sorts of stuff you need for a car...

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by joeclark77 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @04:00PM (#10155273)
Not a reasonable comparison. You might as well have said "you have to BUY a car, so it's not FREE". Yes, you have to buy, register the car, and learn how to use it, and obey the laws of the road. But they allow a kind of mobility that is impossible for Europeans and other jelly-kneed metrosexual weenies to enjoy. Owners of cars don't have to organize our lives around where train stations are located or anyone else's schedule.

Driverless cars, on the other hand, aim to "tame" the automobile and make it a kind of mini-train, with someone else deciding where you may go and how you may get there. Google is already creepy enough without handing over your freedom (and privacy) of movement to their computer.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by zaphar on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:00PM (#10153889)
A huge number of those edge cases are caused by other Human drivers though. The superior solution is to get rid of the human driver. Safety goes way higher and things like highway congestion go way lower. It's clearly superior.

It's only in the near term that it gets a little dicy.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by chimeracoder on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @12:58PM (#10153874)
> Expecting humans to "drive less idiotic" is basically saying that google's cars won't work until human drivers are banned.

Or until there is a critical mass that people adapt their expectations of how many drivers violate minor road rules, like running a red light or running through a crosswalk.

Also, even if self-driving cars aren't perfect, from the data we have so far, they're still several orders of magnitudes better than regular cars. If every self-driven car today were replaced with a regular car, we would see more crashes, not fewer, overall.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by themodelplumber on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:06PM (#10153955)
How about something like this? You can opt to pay (e.g. hit a payment button inside your car) to enable manual, hands-on driving on a per-roadway basis. Otherwise you let the car drive in what it sees as the most efficient way, and pay nothing. When traffic problems are at their worst, you pay the most. Conversely, on an open road, no charges apply.

In addition, some multiplier involving driving conditions (rain, wind, proximity to other vehicles) and driver stats (driving record) comes into play.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by melling on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:02PM (#10153915)
I think you're making an invalid claim. If half the cars were self-driving and we had just as many accidents, we're still better off because half the people would be freed from driving.

Personally, I would guess that there would still be a reduction in accidents, thus fewer deaths and injuries.

Re:Google Says It’s Not the Driverless Car’s Fault. It’s Oth... by revelation on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @01:29PM (#10154163)
You should keep reading articles, because you clearly didn't read this one. The Google car is perfectly safe in the presence of morons.