Every story and comment from the Hacker News API, in a layout borrowed from 2001.
A comment on Myths about /dev/urandom. Parent comment
No. Doing random in userland is just wrong. If your program has access to /dev/urandom, use it. If not, use arc4random().
> “Random Number Generators: Introduction for Operating System Developers”
Or look how OpenBSD does it. (getentropy(), arc4random(), the subsystem)
> The entropy pool used by /dev/urandom must be saved between reboots.
OpenBSD does this, and more. The bootloader basically seeds the kernel with old entropy from before the reboot.
There are no comments on this comment yet.
No. Doing random in userland is just wrong. If your program has access to /dev/urandom, use it. If not, use arc4random().
> “Random Number Generators: Introduction for Operating System Developers”
Or look how OpenBSD does it. (getentropy(), arc4random(), the subsystem)
> The entropy pool used by /dev/urandom must be saved between reboots.
OpenBSD does this, and more. The bootloader basically seeds the kernel with old entropy from before the reboot.