News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by glogla on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @04:58AM (#10151363)
I think free speech can't survive the internet for a different reason - because everything is someone's backyard.

You can say whatever you want in public space, but nobody has to let you write in his newspaper, post on his notice board, put passages in his book, let you speak in his living room or broadcast what you say through radio. That's okay, because there are public places.

There are no public places on the internet. You can't say what you want on Facebook, because it's Facebook's property and that's like speaking in someone's living room or in someone's newspaper. You can't say what you want on Google+, because that's Google's property. If you want to create your own message board, hosting provider can refuse you service - it's their property. If you make your own server, the ISP can refuse you service, because it's their own property.

There are no truly public spaces on the internet, everything is someone's backyard.

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by chronial on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:31AM (#10151457)
The solution to this has not changed. Public spaces are not public because they are not owned by anyone – they are public because they are owned by public entities. You can do that with computers and infrastructure just as much as you can do that with land and buildings.

The one difference is that for land you can actually be there, whereas on the internet you will probably go through some privately owned infrastructure. The simple solution to that is encryption, the thorough solution is government regulation.

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by necessity on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:36AM (#10151466)
A public space is government's backyard, the argument is moot.

See China - government acts as the censor, not ISPs or companies. To favor "public spaces" it's not enough to argue that private backyards have censoring issues, but that public spaces would not have them.

More so, anyone can open his or hers private space to say what he or she wishes in the internet, much more easily than IRL. For instance, if my country prohibits me to speak about certain topic, with a bit of cleverness I can anonymously rent a VPS in another country. If the issue is just a deleted Facebook post, moving out to the competition or creating your own blog is trivial. The real issue is government censorship, which is enforced by the use of force. You can easily leave a website, but not so easily leave a country.

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by jahnu on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:20AM (#10151420)
How about the blockchain?

Edit: This is a serious question. I don't understand the downvotes. Is it possible to extend the idea of the blockchain to facilitate an uncensorable area for speech?

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by Joeboy on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:39AM (#10151475)
http://twister.net.co/ is an attempt to do this. As far as I know it basically works, although it's obviously subject to the Network Effect.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by btrask on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:24AM (#10151437)
Great comment. Another aspect is that you can only rent space (hosting, domains, connection, etc.) on the internet, you can never own it. If you have a landlord they can kick you out, but if you own your own place then you have a much greater deal of freedom.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by chronial on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:36AM (#10151463)
This depends on where you live. In Germany, the landlord can not kick you out (http://library.fes.de/pdf-files/netzquelle/awo/awi762.pdf) – Government intervention can solve a lot of problems.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by mdpopescu on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:31AM (#10151590)
You don't own any land in that sense, all governments can kick you out (see "eminent domain").
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by mirimir on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:21AM (#10151422)
It's not hard to create workably public space. One can rent VPS for 5-10 USD per month, and pay with Bitcoin. Then setup Isso or phpBB or whatever, as a Tor hidden service. If you want more privacy from snooping by the hosting provider, lease a server from PRQ etc and use LUKS.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by the8472 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:23AM (#10151433)
> One can rent VPS

Which is someone's property? So you're not addressing those concerns.

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by mirimir on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:29AM (#10151452)
Unless the provider looks inside your VPS, they won't know what hidden service you're running. Privacy-friendly VPS providers won't snoop unless forced by LEA. But LEA won't know which VPS provider to force, unless your OPSEC is bad.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by the8472 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:13AM (#10151542)
That just obfuscates things, it doesn't turn them into public property. In the end you're still relying on others letting you do your thing.

E.g. the provider could disapprove of Tor in general.

Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by mirimir on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @07:43AM (#10151741)
No, obfuscation doesn't make them public property. But with good OPSEC, one can create virtual public property on leased assets. The primary goal is to protect the provider from negative feedback, so they don't nuke your VPS. And for sure, the provider could block Tor. So then you access Tor through a VPN service. Or whatever it takes to get enough slack.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by anon4 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:05AM (#10151521)
4chan is about as public as you can get.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by 542458 on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @06:11AM (#10151538)
Even 4chan has topics that are (for better or worse) no-go.
Re:Can free speech survive the internet? by iammyIP on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @05:23AM (#10151435)
thats why it's important to propagate ideas for symmetric upload/download connections and self-hosting.