There are parents at all social levels who are very involved in their children's academics and view the school system as only one component of their children's academic achievement (and as a consequence their chances at succeeding professionally).
There are other parents who see the school system as _the_ only tool and the only institution with the responsibility to educate their children --that is a great mistake and to the detriment of their children. I've seem this parental attitude in both poor parents and middle class parents.
I've been places where every extra penny earned by a parent go to their children --they forgo any non essentials in their lives in order that their children have a better chance. They more or less see the escape from poverty as a multi-generational effort and are willing to put their part in wholeheartedly. In exchange, the parents have expectations from their children as the parents enter old age.
So, academic achievement can be reached even for the poor kids, so long as their society and the individuals accept other means of achieving this end.
It happens with some immigrant groups within the US as well, so it's not unheard of in the US. And it's not only the economically privileged who can achieve academically.
In addition, to many of them, joy comes in the form of seeing their offspring do better than themselves. So, to them sacrifice does not equate to not enjoying their lives. Their state of mind is different.
When the world was normal, this stuff didn't happen. But it isn't anymore. Your goofy startup building Über for lawnmowers will only hire candidates who signal "A player, 10x rockstar". So what do you expect people to do?
That's life.
If their behavior seems bizarre, perhaps addressing the root cause would help?
There is the effect on children of growing up in a household where there are books around, where the effects of education show in the topics and manner of discussions at the dinner table. That I don't think you can get away from. It existed a hundred years ago, and will continue to.
While that is a gross oversimplification, it would do wonders to increase the quality of life for families who elect to have one earner only, with the other (gender regardless) providing more time and resources towards child development.
You're right that there's a level of income at which one parent staying home is just not a plausible choice. But it's a lot lower than I'd expected -- I've met some homeschooling families that are doing extremely well by their children at a substantially lower income level than I'd thought feasible. I think the issue here in most cases is less a problem of economics than of cultural values. (Before anyone reads anything pernicious into that, all I mean is that I think American culture overvalues possessions and professional accomplishments and undervalues family in specific and relationships in general.)
The days of the American nuclear family with the dad having a career and the mom becoming a world class housewife are pretty much over.
And considering that low income / low skill jobs are more available to men and that low income jobs will not be able to fund childcare that pushes lower class families to become single earner families even more.
Combine all those factors and many more and you get to a point where income inequality actually forces people to become stay at home mom/dad's while the more financially stable classes can afford to continue with their careers.
It's closer to $96-100K/year actually. In a lot of cases, its economically rational for one spouse to stay home and take care of the house when that much value is provided versus a traditional job.
http://www.washingtonpost.com/pb/blogs/on-parenting/post/a-h...
http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2012/02/06/mint_estimat...
If a stay at home mom is worth 100k then a full time housekeeper/nanny should earn 100k? The highest figures I've seen in NYC with an educated nanny/housekeepr/superperson (nursing, child development really wierd stuff) is on average 700 a week for a 10.5 hours work day and that's in very very upscale areas while usually taking care of 2-3 children. So yeah they'll be earning about 50K a year while taking care of the 1% of the 1%, while in Austin or Chicago for example that figures drops to 23-24000 for the same service.
Sorry but a click bait blog http://blog.mint.com/ for a budge management application https://www.mint.com/ isn't really a reliable source in my books, if those numbers were even close to being a reality on average or under any case you would see pretty much every other family in the states where the dad is a stay at home dad and the mom goes to become a super(rich)nany or vise versa...
This disgusting hypocrisy is not only normalized but is actually encouraged.
Want to end inequality? Go live in a non segregated communities, support/start/educate local businesses. Stop sending your kids to segregated schools. And for god's sake shut the fuck up on twitter.
I'm very much disgusted by the difference in opportunity a poor kid has in a bad neighborhood versus a rich kid who get's sent to the best private schools. Education should NOT depend on one's socioeconomic status. But I don't insist that the parent with means should sacrifice their children to shitty schools to somehow "make up for it".
For some reason that totally escapes me, many people in America are opposed to voucher programs and other ways for concerned and involved parents to send their children to any school other than the shitty designated public school. If you live in a certain geographic area, you're doomed to whatever school has claimed it. I just don't get it.
At the end of the day, I will do whatever I can for my children, even if it doesn't fit with some social justice framework.
Throwing money at the problem is never the right solution in situations like these.
considering how much damage this has done to my own vision, focus, and inspiration; I don't have the slightest bit of problem with this. I'm well out of university btw, and still learning how to protect myself from it.
Anyone who begrudges a parent who wants to live in a good community has never felt the brunt of living in a bad one.
the more of them I meet, the more I understand why my mother made the sacrifices she made to put me in a good environment, push me into a good college, etc. I owe her so much.
> How do you respond to the criticism that the problems you're describing affect only privileged kids?
I was really disappointed by this question and the answers the authors gave.
Firstly because, this kind of parenting actually does have a large impact on underprivileged kids. It's the reason their failure is virtually guaranteed relative to the privileged kids. The underprivileged kid is one student, competing against the privileged kid, who is essentially a multi-person team of cheaters with a bankroll.
Secondly because, the answers the authors gave to the question pretty clearly demonstrate that they're only thinking of this subject from their perspective. And it sounds like their perspective is that of the parents to the privileged kids.
This could've been an article about parental involvement in academics and the impact it has on fairness and meritocracy and social mobility. Instead it's some rich ladies talking about how their kids would've been even more privileged if they did a little less of their homework for them.