Data itself doesn't change, usage patterns do, and that is why restrictions like this exist. My internet connection at home is a reasonably fat 75/5Mbps 'business-class' pipe, I'm paying for a service that expects pretty high usage and the infrastructure is designed to handle it - the coaxial cable going to my house has enough bandwidth and so does the fiber going from the local cable node back to the big datacenter where my traffic eventually gets routed to the rest of the internet.
Mobile has an extremely annoying limitation in that we can't just run a cable to every phone, we want stuff to happen wirelessly! Well, since there's no wires providing service every user has to in essence share the same bandwidth coming from a cell site. We can make sure there's plenty of fiber going to each site, but physically 10Mhz of spectrum can only provide so much bandwidth, and that is a huge limiting factor of wireless service.
Your 3-6" smartphone has very different usage patterns compared to my 13" ultrabook. You may watch a couple youtube videos, stream some music, maybe even watch a movie on Netflix - but you are unlikely to do so for extended periods of time or on a frequent basis, the usage is very sporadic and lends itself well to sharing with other users.
Usage on a tethered laptop or other device is very different, I'm sitting down right now connected to my work VPN 'getting stuff done', checking email, moving large files around, downloading an update for Visual Studio, the list goes on. And this is not something that I do for 10 minutes or even an hour, this is my entire work-day, and I regularly use 10's of Gigabytes of data, something our limited wireless spectrum is not well suited to handle for a large amount of users (that's what WiFi is for!).
Unless nationwide we are going to turn a large enough block of wireless spectrum into a national wireless ISP (we're talking probably 100-200Mhz) we simply do not have enough bandwidth over the airwaves to support people with these usage patterns.
I would feel much more comfortable with straight up metered internet, variably-priced based on current congestion. I would feel much more inclined to believe you if it didn't look like the service providers were trying to change the meaning of internet access—it shouldn't matter which kind of device is "plugged in". That's just terrible service.
However, even if it WERE correct, I much prefer to think of internet as a service. It is incredibly frustrating to deal with tiers that are only slowly approaching the reality they use to defend the tiers themselves. I'm very open to the idea that bandwidth might be a dominating restriction, but the optimal way to deal with it would be a) transparency and b) incentivizing avoiding congestion. However, I'm afraid to tether my computer and actually take advantage of the service I'm paying for since the tools are horrible to actually figure out what the costs might be or how to avoid them.
For all of T-Mobile's plans except for the "unlimited" plan, it doesn't. I have 1GB of LTE data, after I use it on my device or through tethering I get throttled to EDGE and tethering is disabled until the end of my billing cycle.
Users on the "unlimited" plan only get unlimited usage on their device to prevent network congestion from people using it as their primary internet connection for their home (and there is a lot more people that would try to do this than you would think). These users get a separate 7GB bucket of tethering usage, and it is plainly spelled out when choosing a plan.
I'm fine with this. I don't like calling it unlimited if it's limited to your cell phone.
I just don't like that "tethering" is a thing at all as opposed to just "using your phone's radio".
http://www.t-mobile.com/cell-phone-plans/individual.html#
As an ex-T-Mobile customer, I will completely admit they do a passable job of information (especially compared to other carriers). I think mostly because they take the saner business strategy of "limited 4G + unlimited <= 3G". But the phrase "unlimited data" still appears an awfully lot on that page, without a lot of caveats...
Unlimited data isn't unlimited if they limit the devices you can use it on.
To me, AT&T (via Uverse) is the ridiculous conclusion of this. They'll happily set up a number of "wireless" (!!) HD receiver boxes that have content streamed to them over WiFi. Nowhere in the marketing materials do they ever mention this potentially having an effect on your data connections.
Most consumers just think of wireless transmission as magic with infinite bandwidth.
That said, while the above is my realistic appraisal, I do 100% agree with you that using whatever firmware hacks you can to fully utilize TMO's "unlimited" plans, while they continue to market them as that, is completely moral. If they don't want people trying to use unlimited data, then they should quit marketing it as such.
You don't get to tell lies / weasel truths and then cry when people hold you to the same expectations that made it an effective marketing campaign in the first place.
All of T-Mobile's materials explicitly state unlimited usage is for usage ON YOUR DEVICE. This is not hidden 'fine print' or misleading marketing, it's RIGHT THERE.
Don't believe me? http://i.imgur.com/tb2BYAe.png
https://www.google.com/search?q=t+mobile+billboards&tbm=isch