However, even if it WERE correct, I much prefer to think of internet as a service. It is incredibly frustrating to deal with tiers that are only slowly approaching the reality they use to defend the tiers themselves. I'm very open to the idea that bandwidth might be a dominating restriction, but the optimal way to deal with it would be a) transparency and b) incentivizing avoiding congestion. However, I'm afraid to tether my computer and actually take advantage of the service I'm paying for since the tools are horrible to actually figure out what the costs might be or how to avoid them.
For all of T-Mobile's plans except for the "unlimited" plan, it doesn't. I have 1GB of LTE data, after I use it on my device or through tethering I get throttled to EDGE and tethering is disabled until the end of my billing cycle.
Users on the "unlimited" plan only get unlimited usage on their device to prevent network congestion from people using it as their primary internet connection for their home (and there is a lot more people that would try to do this than you would think). These users get a separate 7GB bucket of tethering usage, and it is plainly spelled out when choosing a plan.
I'm fine with this. I don't like calling it unlimited if it's limited to your cell phone.
I would feel much more comfortable with straight up metered internet, variably-priced based on current congestion. I would feel much more inclined to believe you if it didn't look like the service providers were trying to change the meaning of internet access—it shouldn't matter which kind of device is "plugged in". That's just terrible service.