Re:What happens if you take the Fifth in a civil case?
by pascalmemories on Sunday August 30, 2015 @10:03AM
(#10143314)
If there is other evidence to meet balance of probabilities, it's irrelevant whether you say something or not. Saying something is more likely to cause you trouble and open up avenues to hang you out to dry.
Of course, were that to be the case, any sensible lawyer would tell you to make a settlement pre-trial. That way the 5th is never an issue, nor is any testimony which would otherwise go on official record and be searchable for all time.
Re:What happens if you take the Fifth in a civil case?
by adebtlawyer on Sunday August 30, 2015 @05:20PM
(#10144517)
Your statement "other evidence to meet balance of probabilities" is concise but so abstract it's useless. Like most legal questions, there is no abstract way to reason about this. The answer is always "it depends on the context."
That may be true, but the 5th amendment seems like a risky civil strategy to me. Usually the other side won't be entirely dependent on your testimony to prove their case. There can be other evidence out there that you might want to explain with your testimony, or you may otherwise wish to make your case with testimony.
It's worth knowing that in a civil case the 5th amendment is much less powerful and has risks as well as benefits.