I generally dismiss a lot of the things the author is saying for 3 reasons:
1. The author is listing a lot of problems without actually specifically listing why they are in fact problems. For instance, he states that neither Windows nor Unix can teach you how to program. Why would my OS need to be able to teach me how to program? That's like complaining that my Car doesn't teach me how to rebuild the transmission, or my refrigerator doesn't teach me how to generate refrigerant. That's just an obvious example that jumped out at me, there are many others.
2. The author is pointing out a lot of problems without actually pointing out any solutions. People who point out problems but provide no solutions are generally useless. If you ever worked on a project with a person like that, you know what I am talking about.
3. c2.com lacks any sense of design or taste. The author also lacks any ability to communicate his point of view in a logical and consistent manner. I wouldn't trust the author to design a Ski Free game, let alone an operating system. In reality, if tasked with a job to write a Ski Free game, the author would instead return a 30 page paper on the subject of problems with modern game design.
The content on c2.com is not the work of any particular author - it's a wiki whose articles are collaboratively created and edited. Each paragraph may be the work of one or more anonymous or named writers.
In fact, c2.com happens to be the world's very first wiki, designed by Ward Cunningham. (The wiki's content has been frozen and is no longer editable. I seem to remember that Ward is working on a next-generation replacement for it.)
It has the very best design! http://motherfuckingwebsite.com/
For some history, the Jeff that he keeps talking about is a former student of mine at Stanford. I wasn't a big deal at Stanford, I was a TA for a Xerox PARC guy, when he retired Stanford asked me if I'd teach the class.
This was the papers class in operating systems. If you don't know what "papers class" means it means there are no text books, this is where you go to learn at the cutting edge. Pretty advanced class and Stanford let me teach it. To this day I wonder what they were thinking. That said, I'm proud of how I taught that class. The students learned a lot.
Jeff Bonwick was a student who was doing a major in statistics. Somehow he ended up in that OS class. I could tell he was sharp and I was working at Sun in the kernel group, I recruited him as hard as I could. He asked me why I would want him, his exact words were "I can't program in C". I told him that I could teach him how to program, I can't teach people how to be smart. He was very, very smart. I told him when he came to Sun he would go far higher than I ever did and I was right, he did.
Bryan is cut from the same cloth. He's an OS geek. There aren't many of those geeks around these days. Go him.
Mostly what I learned was about people, it wasn't about OS.
Do we not?
I watched your interview, but I don't recall you saying anything about research ideas. You even made a jab against Spring which rubbed me the wrong way.
An orthogonally persistent microkernel-based operating system, even another Unix, would be great. Which is why I'm looking at MINIX 3 and Hurd as interests. The latter has its anachronisms, but it's still a step forward.
Sadly we will get a userland full of container-ized apps (via systemd) and a monolithic kernel (still linux). Worse is better.
Finally, in terms of Spring: based on the fact that you are implicitly defending it, I would guess that you never had to run it. As one of the very few outside of Sun inflicted with that flaming garbage barge, I can tell you that it was not at all a pleasurable experience -- and that whatever novelty it represented was more than offset by its horrifically poor implementation. If I ever harbored any illusions about Spring, they certainly didn't survive my first encounter with a machine running it...
Most "micro"kernels aren't micro at all, they are bloated crapware. QNX was not like that, they actually had a micro kernel and it worked. I ran 4 developers on an 80286 (no VM) and it worked just fine. Far far better than the VAX 11/780 that had more memory and more CPU power. The VAX was running 4.1 BSD.
Sure, if all you do is read Linus Torvalds ranting.
If you decouple the logical bits of the kernel from each other all you'll get is greater impedance and message passing overhead.
Debunked many times, as early as 1992 in fact: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.51.1...
Microkernels have come a long way since Mach.
And for what? A "clean" architecture?
You clearly have no idea what the advantages are.
Basically, I'll believe it when I see it.
You're seeing it in the billions of L4 deployments worldwide in wireless modem chipsets. You're seeing it in QNX being everywhere.
But then again, you might not see it, because you are willfully ignorant.
Calling EC2 a micro kernel success story also seems like quite the definitional stretch.
No personal attacks, please.
I'm not assuming that. Any amount of research could be no research or close to none. People who have done very little research shouldn't opine. People who have done lots of research are more likely to be correct.
News flash: it is possible for informed people to disagree.
Well of course. Someone who's barely informed can disagree with someone who is far more informed. That would be two informed people disagreeing.
If someone has done adequate research and I'm correct, they must agree with me, otherwise the amount of research wouldn't be adequate or I must be wrong. I can avoid being wrong by avoiding having strong opinions on things I don't understand or know much about it.
If it needs to be said, this time was a terrible atmosphere in which to aspire to OS kernel development, a suffering that I expanded on (at far too much length!) in a recent BSD Now.[1] I do not miss the mid-1990s at all, and even now, I find that this ill-informed screed fills me more with resurrected anger than it does any sense of vindication or nostalgia...
[1] http://www.bsdnow.tv/episodes/2015_08_19-ubuntu_slaughters_k...