Re:Two logic puzzles
by RiderOfGiraffes on Thursday December 24, 2009 @09:39AM
(#1013825)
I agree that they are difficult, but for me, they fall into the category of:
"I can probably solve these by long and convoluted
means, but I suspect the solution is neither clean
nor elegant and, to be frank, I can no longer care."
The beauty of the 100 coins problem is that the solution, once seen, is clean, simple and elegant, and it is possible to reason to it - it doesn't require complete inspiration from nowhere.That's why I liked it so much. YMMV.
Actually the solution to the 3 god version is clean and elegant, and long and convoluted reasoning doesn't shed any light on it.
I like the solution to the variant of the Knights and Knaves problem in Every Man For Himself And God Against All by Werner Herzog.
To determine the liar, Kaspar Hauser asks both people -- the liar and the truth teller -- if they are a tree frog.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hardest_Logic_Puzzle_Ever
I extended it to the general case!
http://www.srcf.ucam.org/~te233/maths/puzzles/evenharder.htm...