Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by akl on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @09:24PM
(#1013265)
You are crazy for doing that - one instance of downtime doesn't justify ignoring all the advantages DNS brings.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by cperciva on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @09:56PM
(#1013304)
When I made that design decision I wasn't considering the possibility of DNS outages at all; I was just thinking in terms of "there's a huge number of places between me and ultradns where someone could insert a spoofed DNS response".
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by jacquesm on Thursday December 24, 2009 @07:43AM
(#1013743)
What if amazon gets a new netblock assigned ?
Can you forcibly upgrade the software in that case ?
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by cperciva on Thursday December 24, 2009 @11:55AM
(#1014002)
Of course I can upgrade the software; and there's nothing forcible about it. We're talking about code I'm running on my server here...
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by jacquesm on Thursday December 24, 2009 @07:07PM
(#1014566)
Ah, my bad, sorry I thought you meant in the tarsnap client. Then I really don't know why people would make a fuss over you hardcoding the ips in there. All you need to do is keep an eye out in case they change them (which you could even automate).
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by cperciva on Thursday December 24, 2009 @07:42PM
(#1014605)
All you need to do is keep an eye out in case they change them
Exactly, and that's what I do. (With the caveat that I look for AWS endpoints being taken out of service, not for changes in what DNS tells me.)
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by derefr on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @10:04PM
(#1013313)
Are there DNS servers that support versioning? The best solution I could imagine would simply be to set Tarsnap to normally use the current DNS records for S3, but be able to rollback to a valid zone record if they encounter an update that makes the servers stop resolving.
Re:Amazon goes down; takes S3, Salesforce, Target, and other...
by cperciva on Wednesday December 23, 2009 @11:35PM
(#1013401)
The Tarsnap client only talks to the Tarsnap server, but I do cache that lookup in order to avoid problems with glitchy DNS resolution.
I could have the Tarsnap server cache DNS lookups if I was only worried about working around DNS outages -- but as I said, that wasn't something I was considering at all when I made the decision to eschew DNS.