News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by Gmo on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:18AM (#10129934)
What is your forum software bringing compared to Discourse ?

I actually hate Discourse, for me, this is not the way a forum should be, and from my quick glance at your website, it seems that you go in a very similar direction (which makes me sad :( )

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by tobyzerner on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:51AM (#10130129)
Can I ask specifically what you don't like about the direction Discourse/Flarum are taking?

I can't hope to compete with Discourse on features (yet!), but I think Flarum's elegance sets it apart. Out of the box, it's pretty, fast, easy to use, and works beautifully on mobile. And it's written in PHP, so is super easy to install – any low-end shared host will do.

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by TuringTest on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:13PM (#10130283)
I like the fact that Flarum has an html-only version for browsers with disabled javascript, but it seems to be an alternate implementation, not the same content with less interactivity as it would be expected - it shows much less information and doesn't seem to have feature parity with the interactive version.

This means that the software will only be usable from interactive sessions on "standard" mainstream browsers, and won't be easy to integrate with batch-processing tools (like web scrappers or data warehousing) or non-standard environments (anything enabled for the semantic web or developers creating handcrafted personal scripts to enhance their workflows). Classic "static" forums don't suffer from such limitations, being based on simple html and having predictable navigation structures.

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by tobyzerner on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:17PM (#10130308)
On the other hand, Flarum has a fully-functional JSON API which can fulfill some of those use cases. See http://flarum.org/docs/api for more info - and you can see it in action at http://discuss.flarum.org/api/discussions.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by TuringTest on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:38PM (#10130479)
Ok - I see how it solves the automation problem. But it means that humans and bots are accessing different web resources to get the same content - it abandons the original idea of the World Wide Web where a single content resource was expected to be used by humans and computers alike using a unified, simple syntax.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by Gigablah on Thursday August 27, 2015 @01:01PM (#10130614)
Are you talking about content negotiation? I don't think a "single content resource" really makes sense. When humans access a page, they aren't just looking at a single resource, they're looking at a blend of disparate resources (e.g. all the content in the navigation, sidebar, footer, peripheral sections, etc). Hence the need for a dedicated API that returns pristine data.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by vruiz on Thursday August 27, 2015 @01:08PM (#10130665)
> it abandons the original idea of the World Wide Web where a single content resource was expected to be used by humans and computers alike using a unified, simple syntax.

I believe we are long past that idea, it's just too much of a restriction for the web in order to compete for audience with other technologies (meaning apps).

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by reitoei on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:36PM (#10130457)
> This means that the software will only be usable from interactive sessions on "standard" mainstream browsers

a.k.a 99.99% of the target audience. I'm sure syndication tools could be easily built into it to provide static views to scrapers etc.

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by Gmo on Friday August 28, 2015 @05:28AM (#10134461)
Sorry for the late response, I think this comment by babatong has the gist of what I don't like about Discourse : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10131932

Everything is "fluid" and flat (as in hierarchy flat). I like the more traditional hierarchical type of forum.

On top of that, with Discourse, you're never too sure if/when there is a new message and if you didn't miss anything.

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by jbrooksuk on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:33AM (#10130026)
I setup Discourse for a couple of days and absolutely hated everything about it.

- It actually ok to setup, following instructions.

- The UI is awful.

- Changing the sub domain didn't work until I executed some commands.

- The admin panel was awful, just a mess.

- The frontend didn't really guide the user through what they were doing.

Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by voltagex_ on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:54AM (#10130154)
Plus it takes 1+GB of RAM to run properly.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by tzumby on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:02PM (#10130222)
It just depends what framework/language you are familiar with. Discourse makes sense if you work with Rails (you'll have an easier time both deploying and customizing the UI). If you work with PHP then Flarum would be a better choice.
Re:Show HN: Flarum – Delightfully simple open-source forum s... by sanderjd on Thursday August 27, 2015 @12:58PM (#10130596)
I think a lot of the issues with deploying and managing Discourse are probably spot-on, but as a user rather than an administrator, it's by far my favorite forum UI of the many I've come across through the years. YMMV I suppose.