Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by hga on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:18AM
(#10129936)
The estimate for the overall deaths in the Greater East Asian Co-Prosperity Sphere were 250,000 per month, we'd only liberated the Philippines from it. Korea, which had been under their boot for half a century, Malaya as it was called back then, the populous Dutch East Indies, now Indonesia, South East Asia, they had captured a lot of territory and people, all of whom they viewed as untermenschen.
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by prof_hobart on Friday August 28, 2015 @03:14AM
(#10134081)
That's an entirely valid point in relation to WWII (although as I'm sure I've seen research suggesting that Japan was already trying to mediate a peace, and that the US were aware of this, before the bomb was dropped so it may not be as clear cut as those figures suggest).
However, my point was that even if it is true for WWII, it doesn't make it automatically true for any war as the quote seemed to be suggesting. The quickest way to finish a war isn't always the best.
Re:Lecture from the Man Who Dropped Both Atomic Bombs
by derrickdirge on Thursday August 27, 2015 @10:18AM
(#10129519)
Putting personal/national pride ahead of the health and safety of your citizens is certainly immoral.
And it can be well argued that the Japanese civilian deaths should be blamed on the imperial army for not capitulating when it was obvious the war was lost.