News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:36PM (#10124661)
Yeah, well if you engage in a promise with someone that you're going to be in a monogamous relationship -- let's be real, that's what marriage is for the vast majority -- you're a prick if you attempt to break that commitment, and again, that's what being on AM is about.

Pretending otherwise is delusional, and having morals isn't a bad thing.

Is doxxing always unethical?

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:46PM (#10124741)
Then that's a breach of contract between two private parties which is of absolutely no relevance to outside observers. It is the married couple's prerogative to undergo court procedure if they so desire.

Being on AM wouldn't solely have been about breaking commitment. From what I recall, it became an inadvertent hub for gay dating due to its extraordinary gender/sex imbalance. AM's entire business practice was about hooking into people's desire to seek taboo and then be exorbitant with charging them fees, even for terminating an account. It was, in no minced words, a con.

Having morals means knowing when to stay out of things that are none of your concern.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by solipsism on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:22PM (#10125001)
Having morals means knowing when to stay out of things that are none of your concern

That's fundamental to your moral framework. It may even be fundamental to the moral norms in US or Western culture. But it's not fundamental to everybody's. It's by no means objective. That's why we have objective laws to go by.

Talking about morals means realizing everyone has different morals. Of what use is it to argue whether cheating or hacking or meddling in the business of others or vigilante justice is or isn't moral in general?

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:28PM (#10125056)
That's why we have objective laws to go by.

Which as far as I know were violated.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by solipsism on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:46PM (#10125169)
Right! Glad we could all find common ground.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by humanrebar on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:04PM (#10124884)
> Then that's a breach of contract between two private parties which is of absolutely no relevance to outside observers.

That's one way to look at things. I happen to have a different philosophy about marriage, that it actually does affect other people, and since you're so understanding, I'm sure you'll grant that my philosophy is equally valid.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by oldmanjay on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:32PM (#10125445)
If your philosophy involves your opinions mattering in people's private concerns, no, it's not valid.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by humanrebar on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:27PM (#10125796)
No. I think marriages actually affect people not involved in the marriage commitment itself. Especially when you consider populations and not just hypothetical individuals.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by Absentinsomniac on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:04PM (#10126015)
Yeah, but what does that have to do with random unassociated outside observers? Are you saying society at large has some kind of right to intimate details of personal relationships?
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by humanrebar on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:18PM (#10127166)
I'm saying it's impossible, especially across large populations, to assert that infidelity is wholly a private matter. It's a compelling notion that doesn't stand up to facts. Be sure to consider things like STD rates, unplanned pregnancy rates, rates of single parenthood, divorces resulting from infidelity, and so on.

I can assert that this data breach is immoral while also asserting that infidelity, especially organized infidelity, is not simply an intimate detail. I'm not sure why everyone feels compelled to square off into two camps on every issue.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jchrisa on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:47PM (#10125178)
A little reading would let you know that there is a significant chunk of happily married people who don't think monogamy is for them. They think honesty is more important. I don't know if these folks are AM users or if they've got a better scene.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by monochromatic on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:56PM (#10127445)
> significant chunk of happily married people who don't think monogamy is for them

There's a significant chunk that is ok with cheating. There's a far smaller chunk that's ok with the other person cheating.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by humanrebar on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:35PM (#10125853)
I'm aware of those people. I'll formally apologize in a twitter post if a significant portion of the AM clients were in open marriages.

> They think honesty is more important.

Yeah, that's a false dichotomy. And are monogamous marriages dishonest? That's oddly judgmental for an appeal for open-mindedness. Or you meant something else by "honesty", like realistic?. I guess that's slightly less judgy.

A lot of these philosophical arguments get bogged down in boring bickering about word definitions. Marriage, traditionally, has implied "monogamous". At least "adultery" and "cheating" do.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jsprogrammer on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:34PM (#10125466)
Married people's thoughts on monogamy are irrelevant.

The argument was that the breach of contract is no one else's business except for the two parties to that contract. This was rebutted by someone claiming that they hold value in knowledge about another's breach of a contract.

What I don't understand is the reasoning that says a breach of contract is only meaningful to the parties of the contract. If someone is influenced by knowledge that someone breached another contract, then that knowledge is meaningful outside the confines of the contract.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:56PM (#10125595)
The argument isn't that it isn't meaningful, it's that it shouldn't be.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jsprogrammer on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:20PM (#10125739)
Well, I reviewed the argument that I was referring to and it wasn't what you are claiming.

Here's the text:

>Then that's a breach of contract between two private parties which is of absolutely no relevance to outside observers.

The argument claimed that the breach was "of absolutely no relevance". Yes, the word "meaningful" wasn't used, but I dare you to provide a definition of the word "meaningful".

>The argument isn't that it isn't meaningful, it's that it shouldn't be.

Can you point me to someone making that argument?

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:32PM (#10125828)
I'd say the part where vezzy-fnord talks about the couple's "prerogative" and "things that are none of your concern" set the context in terms of moral rights, not whether it can possible affect the other person.

I can see where one might read it differently, though, but I confess I fail to see the point in discussing from that POV.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jsprogrammer on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:01PM (#10125993)
Eh, there's very little here that has much point in discussion.

I only wanted to point out that this particular sub-thread was going off the rails (as many are, but I can't respond to all of them due to time constraints and HN's hard rate limit).

The information can't be destroyed now, so there is little point in discussions about what should or shouldn't have happened in this specific instance.

If someone breached a contract and this provides evidence to those ends, then it's simply a fact. I completely understand that facts can upset people.

If someone didn't breach a contract...well I'm not sure what the worry is in this specific instance.

In any case, it obviously sucks when information you gave in trust is leaked out and there is certainly a lesson to learn in data security here. There also seems to be a lesson to perhaps not trust companies who apparently fundamentally produce and specifically market a trust violation product. Of course, if you are in the market for such a product, formal calculation of your preference function may not be a priority.

>I'd say the part where vezzy-fnord talks about the couple's "prerogative" and "things that are none of your concern" set the context in terms of moral rights, not whether it can possible affect the other person.

This makes it sounds like vezzy-fnord is arguing for some kind of thought control regime; a regime where one may selectively engineer the exact perception to create in others. If someone can perceive something, they should be able to contemplate it.

Just as it is a couple's prerogative to seek court mediation for their breached contracts (this is the right the argument afforded the couple), it is another's prerogative to act on information that is known to them.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:07PM (#10124904)
Well, I'd like to hear you actually elaborate on your differing philosophy. That'd be helpful.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by tedunangst on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:18PM (#10124982)
Wasn't there some other difference of opinion regarding the philosophy of marriage recently?
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:05PM (#10124889)
Having morals also means speaking out about things when it is your concern. 37 Million (of course potentially non-unique) accounts on a website advertised with the express intent of cheating on your spouse with nobody knowing is fucked up. It's a sleazy website run by sleazy people with sleazy business practices, used by people who are trying to do something which their spouse VERY LIKELY disagrees with.

Of course there are portions of the AM leak which are bad, like the gay men in Saudi Arabia, but pretending that this is the norm and not the exception is feeding a delusion. Just because a small portion of the website does not follow the same perogative does not mean that we should derail the discussion from the main issue.

An epidemic of cheating over the internet is a concern for people who intend to get married. Estabilshing strong social taboos here is not some awful thing.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by balabaster on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:37PM (#10125116)
It exposes what is already human nature. Okay, it was a potential enabler... you have a fair point. But it having a large male populous turns out to be a popular gay hub. The people on this site were going to cheat anyway.

I don't disagree with it being run by sleazy people with sleazy business practices. From everything I've read, I'd concur with this statement.

An epidemic of cheating over the internet is no more a concern than the "epidemic" of cheating. The internet was just a means to an end... just like party lines, dating services, the bar, the office and everywhere else people of our species comingle without their partners. Cheating is no more an epidemic now than it ever was. People just changed media. Perhaps if it's truly the epidemic you suggest, then instead of that being a concern to people who intend to get married, we as a species need to re-evaluate if monogamy is actually human nature or if it's just wishful thinking impressed upon us by the dogma of our upbringing.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:46PM (#10125173)
I find the prospect of people making promises to people that we can assume that they love and being unable to keep those promises to be terrifying. If I believed that we weren't able to control our behavior and we were overrun with animalistic desire, I would kill myself. The same ideology is used to justify violence, rape, etc., and if I did not believe that these problems could be addressed or improved upon, I personally do not think life would be worth living.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by balabaster on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:02PM (#10125276)
That's your call. People break promises all the time. I find the prospect that you choose to believe peoples promises will uphold over time naive - that's my perspective and equally as valid to me as yours is to you.

People do things for many reasons you are not privvy to all the time and while they may seek comfort in the arms of someone outside their relationship, doesn't automatically justify violence and rape. I find this argument to be as laughable as those making arguments that same sex marriage is comparable to marrying animals.

If understanding and accepting human nature for what it is makes your life not worth living, then only you can evaluate that.

I choose to believe that people are inherently good. I choose to believe that while their interests align with my own, they're likely to make good on that promise. But I equally believe that accepting someone else's promise without question or qualification is naive at best. I cannot expect them to honour that promise when their interests are no longer aligned with mine.

Does that make my life not worth living? Of course not. I love people, I enjoy being around them. People are amazing, wonderful and fascinating creatures.

...but to expect that one person uphold a promise they had no hope of truly understanding when they made it, for the entire duration of the remainder of their life... and then holding them accountable for failing to keep it. That's beyond ridiculous, I don't care what religion you are.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by oldmanjay on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:38PM (#10125497)
Do you feel like your hyperbolic response to something that isn't actually even your concern to be a convincing argument of some sort? Without trying to be too callous, your suicide-in-potentia is dust in the wind compared to the sort of misery that would be produced by trying to live according to the standard you thankfully have no right to set.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by anigbrowl on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @06:12PM (#10126338)
You're equating an injury to the an imaginary-symbolic construct (the exclusively monogamous relationship) with an injury to an actual person's body that occurs in the case of violence or rape. Contracts are valuable, but they're not people.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by task_queue on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @09:44PM (#10127062)
Life will last much longer for you if you accept that people will most likely act in what they perceive to be their self-interest.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by task_queue on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:12PM (#10127146)
How are 37 million private accounts, having nothing to do with you, your concern at all?

You brushed the consequences of this vigilante justice under the rug. Those Saudi Arabians will most likely suffer severe consequences, probably death, for being exposed.

The public is not a judge, jury or executioner, no matter how good it makes you feel to play morality police.

None of this excuses an irresponsible exposure of private information.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:10PM (#10124928)
Raw numbers aren't of much use here. You need to also gauge intent and opportunity, which is much harder, and at least in the case of opportunity, there was virtually none. You can't do that, so just stay the hell out.

"An epidemic of cheating over the internet". My God, do you think adultery was invented recently? This is a classic fallacy of blaming the mere institutions as opposed to the root cause.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:16PM (#10124966)
The intent when you register on a website designed for cheating on your spouse seems pretty clear to me. If you found your spouse registering for AM would you assume that it was just to see if they had a sleek UI?

Hook-up culture has always existed as well, but let's not pretend that Tinder hasn't changed the pace/availability of hooking up. In the same light, let's not pretend that the anonymity of the internet hasn't facilitated people comitting adultery.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:22PM (#10125007)
In the same light, let's not pretend that the anonymity of the internet hasn't facilitated people comitting adultery.

In the same light, let's not pretend that the anonymity of the Internet hasn't facilitated people engaging in terrorist activity and drug trade. When do we build the firewall, captain?

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:40PM (#10125137)
So you're going to let my intent argument stand?

We build the firewall around prosocial behavior. I think that if the names of all of the coke dealers selling their wares through TSR came out today I would not be upset either, because it's a scummy, exploitative industry. If you're breaking a social contract, my expectation of other people upholding their social contracts with you, in that area, are very slim.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:49PM (#10125190)
The whole purpose of a judicial system is that blanket vigilantism based on "social contracts" is ineffective and prone to high margins of error. I understand that you do not share this belief and instead want to mold people around allegedly "prosocial" behavior, even if it's a legal contract outside your jurisdiction as a natural person. We will have to disagree and cut the argument here.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by task_queue on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:27PM (#10127197)
You wouldn't care if people who are not at all involved are implied to be coke dealers because they had their identity stolen?

Public exposure of individuals' private information is irresponsible, period.

Vigilantism is against the social contract, upholding it implies you gave up that power to the institutions that have the responsibility to judge and prosecute.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by s73v3r on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:08PM (#10126038)
"Having morals also means speaking out about things when it is your concern. "

Nobody on AM was your concern. At all.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by sbarre on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:40PM (#10124696)
Yes, it absolutely is always unethical.

Who are you, or anyone else, to question or evaluate "commitment" in a relationship that you have no part of, and know nothing about? Or to force someone's personal private life out in the open where it will be used to judge them without context?

Nothing is as black and white as you are claiming it to be.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by chrischen on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:45PM (#10124739)
Privacy isn't a natural right, just like lying to someone via marriage isn't universally considered unethical.

Your right to privacy isn't naturally guaranteed, and is only granted by some mutually agreed upon rules in the form of privacy laws.

But if I know some fact about you, what gives you any right to say I can't reveal that information? Wouldn't you be limiting my speech?

If you argue that lying in marriage is a complex issue, then privacy rights is also a complex issue that's not black and white.

A world with no secrets and a world where everyone has a right to secrecy are both potentially equally valid.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by Zigurd on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:13PM (#10124956)
One could argue privacy is a more natural right than, for example, property rights since strong encryption can give you absolute privacy, even against the state.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by dnautics on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:36PM (#10125104)
that would be a right to encrypt, not a right to privacy. the 'right to privacy', as established in the US, constitutes a 'reasonable expectation of privacy' that is - if you passively (e.g hiding behind a wall) or procatively (enclosing a letter in an envelope) take measures to hide what you are doing then you have the legal right to go after someone who tries to breach this privacy.

In the context of encryption, A right to encrypt says that no one can stop you from encrypting your work. A right to privacy says no one is allowed to try to break your encryption.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:46PM (#10125165)
I think you and I have different ideas of what absolute means.

Encryption protects infromation as long as A) the computation power, time and desire available to break your encryption does not exceed the level you encrypted, B) the underlying math principles on which the encryption was based do not see a change in some manner reducing the effectiveness of the algorithm for this task, or C) The implementation of the encryption algorithm did not suffer some flaw reducing it's effectiveness to the level if can be beaten.

I know A and C have happened in the past. I'm unsure whether B has occurred. It's worth noting that in the case of B or C, the strength you choose now may not have any effect on the outcome.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by Zigurd on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:20PM (#10125381)
While one could be wrong about the basics of physics and math, you can encrypt things, cheaply and quickly, that would take a computer made of all the matter and all the energy in the universe to break in more time than the universe has existed.

You have to take some care. But an NSA magic code breaking machine is in the same category as flying saucers at Area 51. Exceedingly unlikely.

That's about as good a guarantee as nature can offer.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by kbenson on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:31PM (#10125442)
There's a very specific reason I included B and C in my listed cases. I agree in many or most cases it could be said that it's unlikely certain encryption methods would be bypassed, but to me that only gives you a fairly good prospect of being secure, not an absolute certainty. That may or may not affect your original argument, I'm not sure.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by jfb on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:44PM (#10125154)
Ease of technical implementations does not a natural right make.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by walshemj on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:21PM (#10124998)
A lot of courts think it is
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by scythe on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:51PM (#10124781)
>Yes, it absolutely is always unethical. [...] Nothing is as black and white as you are claiming it to be.

The irony thickens.

Let me rephrase you: "Who are you, or anyone else, to evaluate 'abuse' in a relationship..." -- the answer is "anyone who knows how to count". While there are exceptions to every rule, the majority of cases fall into rather ordinary examples. Not everyone is special.

Of course, indiscriminately doing this sort of thing like the AM hackers is terrible -- notwithstanding those in third-world countries facing draconian legal consequences -- but plenty of the people exposed certainly deserved it.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by eli on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:02PM (#10124865)
Nobody asked you to intervene in their marriage, investigate their spouse, or enforce any laws -- adultery isn't even a crime in many places. You do not get to impose your morals on others. A stranger cheating on another stranger has nothing to do with you.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by nostrebored on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:12PM (#10124946)
Clearly from the response we're seeing from society outside of this tech bubble where your privacy must be protected at all times otherwise doom ensues, people want to know when their spouse is cheating on them. You make an assumption that quite frankly ignores reality in favor of a weird moral relativism where any sort of judgment is bad.

Odds are that people don't want their spouse cheating on them.

Someone stealing from someone else doesn't have an affect on me either, but I would operate under the default assumptions that 1) they want their things 2) they would want to be notified if someone wanted to steal their things 3) they would want to be notified if someone actually stole their things

And guess what? People acting in this way has the prosocial implication of teaching people that stealing is bad, and gives me the assurance that if someone is trying to steal from me that people will let me know!

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by eli on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:26PM (#10125035)
Hacking into a dating website is not analogous to merely observing someone stealing. If you set up cameras pointed into my bedroom, I'd have a big problem with that even if it did catch a burglar.

The fact that some people approve of vigilante justice and disrupting the personal lives of people they don't like doesn't mean it's a good idea. There are many obvious historical examples of terrible harm that sort of thinking has caused. If you think adultery is a crime that requires help from people not involved in the marriage, I suggest you campaign to make it illegal in all states and ask for police resources to be dedicated to it. If you see someone stealing, you should call the police.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:19PM (#10124986)
Again, you have no way of gauging intent. An example the poster above gave is a really great one. A couple having a consensual S/M relationship that involves controlled pain, possibly leaving visible marks. Your method would be to immediately rat them out to the authorities. Congratulations, you just ruined a happy couple's relationship because you can't see past your own thin worldview, and never bothered to think before you act.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by scythe on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:49PM (#10125560)
BDSM is legal under Lawrence v. Texas in the United States, as I recall. The police are generally aware of this. Though, in this situation, a reasonable person would ask first.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by btilly on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @08:23PM (#10126800)
That decision legalized sodomy, not S&M.

S&M is in much more of a grey area. See https://ncsfreedom.org/key-programs/consent-counts/consent-c... for details.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by chc on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:27PM (#10125421)
From what I've seen, interest in the Ashley Madison leaks has been almost entirely prurient ("OMG look at this guy!"), which is a common human foible, but not something that's generally considered good to encourage. Many people also reacted positively to the theft of compromising photos from dozens of celebrities last year, for very similar reasons.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by s73v3r on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:13PM (#10126064)
"people want to know when their spouse is cheating on them"

That's completely different than people outside the family wanting to know.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by scythe on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:45PM (#10125541)
I didn't (and wouldn't) do anything. I can very well say you deserve to fall without believing that I deserve to push you.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by btilly on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:04PM (#10124885)
Let me rephrase you: "Who are you, or anyone else, to evaluate 'abuse' in a relationship..." -- the answer is "anyone who knows how to count". While there are exceptions to every rule, the majority of cases fall into rather ordinary examples. Not everyone is special.

I'm guessing that you haven't talked about this with anyone who is into BDSM. Just because you witness something that you think is violent abuse doesn't mean that you're right.

Conversely I've seen perfectly pleasant looking couple who engage in constant verbal abuse disguised as pleasant commentary. Most people won't recognize it for what it is. Go read http://www.amazon.com/The-Gentle-Art-Verbal-Self-Defense/dp/... and you may do better than most people.

Be very, very careful about judging what happens in other people's relationships. It may be bad. Or you may not know. For real.

Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by eli on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:44PM (#10124730)
At best you're arguing for vigilante justice. An internet mob accountable to no one and meting out punishment to people who, for the most part, have not violated any laws. No, that is not ethical. I don't want self-appointed Morals Police going around ruining lives for perceived crimes. I don't think mob justice is ever ethical.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by soylentcola on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:56PM (#10125978)
So...basically a large scale version of ruining someone's life for being an asshole? I dunno about you but while I'm not married and have never cheated on a spouse, I've certainly been an asshole before and I'm glad my life wasn't completely screwed over it.
Re:Who Hacked Ashley Madison? by s73v3r on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:07PM (#10126030)
"Is doxxing always unethical?"

YES