News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by zdw on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @09:59AM (#10122847)
Imagine the dystopic future where Uber then colludes with the legal/prison complex, and can track everyone.

Even if you don't use their services, their roving band of rfid/wifi/bluetooth sensing cars with cameras that read and recognize object like other cars, license plates, and other people in their environment will be observing everyone and everything, all the time.

Every vehicle, a subpoena-able bundle of sensors.

Watching.

Personally, I find that even scarier than the mass destruction of public transit.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by BurningFrog on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:09PM (#10123902)
Imagine the worst possible future with the system I dislike.

Then imagine the best possible future with the system I do like.

My system is clearly superior!

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by zdw on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:31PM (#10125438)
While I get your point, I don't particularly dislike Uber.

The point is that, like arguments for backdoored crypto, imagine when Uber hits some political roadblock it's had trouble overcoming, and uses the described "eyes everywhere" idea as a way of selling one of their already gathered externalities as a public safety benefit.

Basically, it comes down to what kind of sci-fi you like - are the baddies evil corporations, or evil government. I just happened to conflate/combine the two...

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by gentleteblor on Thursday August 27, 2015 @03:20PM (#10131459)
I mostly second this thought (our potential dystopia resulting from some combination of corporate and government misbehavior).

I'll just add that it isn't exactly science fiction. I think it's happening already, case in point, the frequent: NSA +- AT&T, Google, [corporation recently accused of collusion]

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by woah on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:37PM (#10124136)
Imagine a system where the subways are used as mandatory transportation to forced labor camps. Government trains transporting citizens to government factories, where they are forced to sing the national anthem before another grueling 14 hour shift. And if there are any problems, well, the subway is deep underground and out of sight.

A truly sinister system of subterranean socialism that stands in stark contrast to the red-blooded freedom of the open road.

That's almost scarier to me than Uber bans.

</sarcasm>

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Apocryphon on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:45PM (#10124228)
I can't imagine a system like that, because the American taxpayer is already unwilling to pay enough to barely support a passenger train system as it is, much less some sort of efficient totalitarian government train system. And digging subways? As if this totalitarian government will be able to get its contractors to do that on time, and fight off the complaints from the totalitarian EPA.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by placeybordeaux on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:22AM (#10123509)
For the price of a police helicopter police departments can continously monitor a 10 mile wide area from the sky. That is a lot better than waiting for cars to recognize stuff, subpoena all of them then work on the very hard problem of pieceing it all together.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by 6d0debc071 on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:01PM (#10124371)
The existence of this system is rather odd then:

https://youtu.be/QGxNyaXfJsA

Not that the level of surveillance that's becoming possible (and even expected) isn't deeply repugnant, I'm just not convinced it's quite as cheap as you make it out to be.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by djrogers on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:38AM (#10123637)
I think you are vastly underestimating the cost and complexity of tracking everything/everywhere. It's not just a matter of mounting a couple of go-pros on a chopper and putting it in the air. Heck, even if that were all it took, that's very expensive.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by somebodyother on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:01PM (#10123828)
Actually, you can look find cases of this already. Complete neighborhood-wide monitoring of every car down to the license plate, and every individual's basic outline are captured by surveillance planes.

https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/mysterious-planes-over...

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Apocryphon on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:45PM (#10124235)
Well yeah, that's why you use much smaller, cheaper, and quieter drones instead of helicopters.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by masterleep on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:31AM (#10123119)
You find government owned transit better in this regard?
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:41AM (#10123194)
A government is (in principle) accountable to its citizens. A private company is only accountable to its owners and shareholders.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by masterleep on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:58AM (#10123313)
In reality, governments enjoy low accountability compared to private companies that must compete for business. That is why failed government programs hardly ever get replaced.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by pavel_lishin on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:09AM (#10123390)
I'm less afraid of unreplaced-failed-government-programs, and more afraid of unreplaced-successful-privacy-invading-companies, especially when they have government approval.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by wfo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:40AM (#10123648)
In reality, private companies enjoy low accountability compared to government because while they perpetuate the myth of a highly competitive market, it isn't so; they are generally inefficient small fiefdoms. And government isn't allowed to keep secrets the way private companies are; and is required by regulation to act in a certain fair and reasonable way. If someone asks you for every email you've sent in the last year and you're a CEO, you give them the finger and laugh. If you work at a government agency, buy a couple thousand reams of paper and start printing.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Kalium on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:59AM (#10123815)
Are you familiar with the many abuseable exemptions in FOIA?
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by wfo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:52PM (#10124293)
Once private companies have a FOIA of their own that applies to their internal communication I'd be happy to examine the exemptions in the two statutes and how they compare.

But for now it's so disgustingly false to claim that companies are less accountable than government that it's hard to believe such a claim is not intentionally dishonest.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Kalium on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:32PM (#10124622)
First, that's not any claim of mine, so please be nice.

Second, my point was that FOIA doesn't bring as much transparency as you might hope.

Third, the question of accountability is two-fold: to whom and to what extent? Governments and companies are accountable to different groups and to different degrees. But just as the government of Brunei is not accountable to a randomly selected American, a company of which you are neither customer nor shareholder is not accountable to you. Given that companies rely more on consent that governments, the degree of accountability to shareholders is perhaps greater.

Thus I submit that measuring accountability purely in degrees is... incomplete.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by wfo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @05:57PM (#10126282)
It wasn't directed at you, I'm sorry if it came out that way: my claim about transparency was a relative one and not an absolute one and in fact I agree with your perspective that transparency even in government isn't as good as it could be in an absolute sense (in some cases, of course); it just doesn't have any bearing the point I was responding to, which is a direct comparison between public sector and private sector.

And very few top-level employees of very large publicly held companies consider themselves accountable to a very tiny elite group of wealthy shareholders. I don't think that this is what people mean when they use the word 'accountable' though. If you want to stretch the use of the word that far, you could say everyone is equally accountable because they are accountable to themselves, or religious people are more accountable because they consider themselves accountable to God while Atheists don't. I think it's fair to assume when someone uses the word 'accountability' in this context they mean to society as a whole.

I would also reject the notion that companies rely on consent more so than governments; they are dictatorships run top-down by generally a single manager who commands his underlings. Companies and governments are enormous bureaucratic organizations which have enormous impact on the societies in which they operate and the people that live in them. Government has checks and balances and voting and are required to publish information about their operations and are open to being changed by the general public (through voting). Companies are secret private dictatorships which do as they please without regard for the wishes or needs or desires of the general public (only when those wishes happen to coincide with a profit motive; a rare happy accident) and publish nothing about their operations by design.

I think it's quite fair to make the claim about relative transparency/accountability, that governments beat companies always; governments are required to try, companies do not even pretend to try (in fact the most profitable companies actively refuse to try). I think you have a very good point about how transparent this minimal transparency is in government, but the fact that it even exists means governments beat companies hands down every time.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Kalium on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @07:55PM (#10126702)
Companies rely on the consent of employees and the consent of customers. Many governments are not so nice about this. The dictatorships of companies are ones that people voluntarily subject themselves to. That is consent - to maintain otherwise is dadaist absurdity.

Beyond that, how do you define "society as a whole"? Where do you draw the line? Is Joe's Local Coffee Shack accountable to random fishermen in Indonesia? Is WalMart? To what extent should a country that you are neither a citizen of or a resident of be accountable to you? How is this different from shareholders and non-shareholders?

Governments are not required to try. Many don't. Publicly traded firms pretty universally are required to provide a degree of transparency to everyone. They also provide greater transparency to shareholders and are very directly accountable to shareholders... who can and have organized takeovers of companies.

Perhaps you say "accountable" and mean "I, personally, have power over whatever organization is convenient"?

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by wfo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:51PM (#10127429)
No, companies rely on forcing obedience from their employees through the threat to remove healthcare and livelihood. They rely on forcing compliance from their customers by hiring a team of highly trained psychologists who specialize in propaganda and brainwashing to try and subconsciously trick people into purchasing your product. They rely on anticompetitive business practices: forcing out competition, or competeting so hard that margins are so thin for everyone that there is no choice but "the lowest cost in dollars" which generally comes at the highest cost in social good or human rights. You're describing some utopia where people work for a company because they want to and have many choices of employer. This isn't the case for the vast majority of people. Saying a company gets your consent because you continue to work for them is like saying a rapist gets your consent because you didn't punch him hard enough when he assaulted you. It's not dadist at all, it's honest and practical. The alternative dishonest -- to perpetuate the myth that draws a hard line between 'consensual' actions -- those which are forced by our economic system -- and 'voluntary' ones like which brand of a product do I purchase -- those which don't matter.

Society is defined exactly in the way that you know it should be. Asking whether or 'society' for Joe's local coffee shop includes Indonesian fisherman is simultaneously saying you understand what society is and that you refuse to admit you know what it is. It's intentionally misunderstanding others for a rhetorical purpose, i.e. arguing in bad faith and you know it. Cut it out.

Western democratic governments are required to try. You're right dictatorial regimes operate more like large corporations and can do as they wish -- they are possibly even worse because they tend to include death camps as well. So if when I say 'government is generally more transparent than private industry' your response is 'what about the Syrian government', well, fine, you've made my point.

Publicly traded firms (a minority of 'industry') are "accountable" to a tiny group of the wealthy hyper-elite in that they have to publish very specific technical details about their accounting. That's quite a stretch.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Kalium on Thursday August 27, 2015 @11:31AM (#10130020)
You refuse to define your words, claiming that the meanings are obvious and that I'm dishonest for asking you to offer your definition. You define consent as impossible because incentives are possible. You change your positions as you go while simultaneously claiming you have not. Enough.

I wish you luck with your rhetorical games, but I shall not be playing them with you any longer. Perhaps someday you'll stop and wonder why the revolutionary change you wish for hasn't happened. If you've become wiser, you'll realize that the answer is that the revolutionary is you.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:10PM (#10125668)
Florida's Sunshine Laws [1] do provide a very high amount of transparency, and are a model that should be replicated across the US.

[1] http://myfloridalegal.com/pages.nsf/Main/DC0B20B7DC22B741852...

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by gress on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#10123541)
Private companies usually do everything they can to defeat competition - not to engage in it.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by jazzyk on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:46PM (#10124248)
s/defeat/remove
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by vtlynch on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:12AM (#10123415)
Private companies may be held more accountable, but they are done so by a much smaller group of people. I think its also fairly evident that when a private company harms the general public, the only thing keeping them accountable is the government.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by satanrepents on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @02:09PM (#10124923)
Uber has competition?
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#10123546)
But the future imagined was only dystopian because the government used that Uber-gathered data to lock people up.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by jazzyk on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:44PM (#10124216)
In real life:

- a private company is accountable to its customers, otherwise it will die (assuming there is choice of service providers).

- government's customers (citizens) have NO choice - they are stuck with the same people, despite elections. So the government's "accountability" is for the birds.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Apocryphon on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:48PM (#10124258)
Well, in the ridesharing space, how much of a choice is there? Lyft is barely holding on in the face of the Uber juggernaut, despite an existing public perception of Uber as vaguely sinister and evil (at least after last year's scandals).
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by jazzyk on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @03:18PM (#10125369)
Knowing that Lyft (or whoever) may quickly replace them if they turn expensive/unreliable will keep Uber on their toes. This is not the case with the government - you can't just start using another government service if the current one sucks.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Apocryphon on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @04:00PM (#10125616)
Ah, but you can vote it out.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by orblivion on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:12AM (#10123419)
What about its customers? Again, in principle.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:14AM (#10123436)
Customers only matter in traditional scenarios. In Uber's case, they're only accountable to their VCs and other funds pouring money into their (legally questionable) operations.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:27AM (#10123560)
Are you saying that the consumers are irrelevant to the funds that VCs are willing to dump on Uber?
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:45AM (#10123680)
Depends entirely on the burn rate and how much dumb money is flowing into Unicorns. You don't have to be a viable business, you just need to appear to be viable under certain circumstance.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:15PM (#10123953)
And having users isn't necessary to appear viable?
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by toomuchtodo on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:19PM (#10123991)
Users =! Ongoing revenue stream.

Snapchat. Twitter. And to a lesser extent, Uber if they're unable to reach profitability once its determined they'll have to recategorized drivers as employees.

Stupid money can make quite a few bad decisions before it catches up, even worse if it effects public policy in the process.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:23PM (#10124024)
You said that consumers don't matter in this scenario. I'm denying that claim, since consumers can simply leave the service/platform to force the VCs' hand.

Whether the company is profitable is irrelevant here.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by masklinn on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:13AM (#10123434)
A corporation is not accountable to its customers save through the government (and its courts). And zdw's scenario makes them eavesdrop on non-customers anyway.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by ancap on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:15AM (#10123449)
You forgot about the most powerful economic actor, the consumer.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by gress on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:26AM (#10123553)
That's because it isn't.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by masklinn on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:34AM (#10123145)
It could hardly be worse, and there's the remote possibility of holding your government accountable.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by bsbechtel on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:06AM (#10123360)
Huh? You hold Uber accountable by not using their service. That's much more accountability than being 1 of ~150million votes.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by pavel_lishin on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:10AM (#10123398)
Apparently 8 million people use Uber.

Being 1 of ~8 million isn't significantly better than being 1 of ~150 million, in terms of accountability.

But it's a faulty argument, anyway. It's not a single citizen that holds a government accountable, it's the masses, and the media, etc.

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by bsbechtel on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:30PM (#10124074)
Even if it is the masses and media that hold the government accountable, they can still be more effective by pointing their power towards Uber than a government. The media's effect on Nike's labor practices in the mid-90s comes to mind as an example.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by pavel_lishin on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @12:48PM (#10124260)
But not a particularly good example, as the labor problem was absolutely not solved by any of the bad publicity: https://rottenindenmark.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/we-are-not-...
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by bsbechtel on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:04PM (#10124403)
Sounds like the bad publicity did help, but as the problems moved, the publicity didn't follow. It also sounds like local governments were more than complicit in allowing these new problems to fester.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by pavel_lishin on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @01:17PM (#10124512)
Yup. And the changes in government seem to be sticking.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by donkeyd on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:35AM (#10123155)
In the Netherlands you can get an "anonymous chipcard" to check in to public transportation. There are cameras pointed at every check in point, wouldn't really call it anonymous then...
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by the-dude on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:10AM (#10123399)
Which you typically charge with your bank-card... And if it breaks and you still have money on it?

You need to fill out a form for reimbursement which asks EVERYTHING, including your gender!

Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by Lawtonfogle on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @10:39AM (#10123175)
In theory, even if not in practice, governments have limits that private companies do not.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by icebraining on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:28AM (#10123564)
And vice-versa.
Re:The Uber endgame: privatized public transit by josu on Wednesday August 26, 2015 @11:46AM (#10123690)
What about Uber free states then? Islands of liberty.

Your vision necessarily needs coercive governments to make sense.