For very beginners, any editor they're familiar with will do (but if they're beginner, how would they be familiar with any editor? Just start with emacs, it's as simple as any other, click and point etc; you can try it anything you do with Notepad, do exactly the same with emacs and you will get the same results).
And indeed, using a CL implementation in the terminal (but with rlwrap if you're use a read-line deficient implementation; clisp has it included), for your first steps can be a better learning experience than using sophisticated GUIs.
Just like I wouldn't advise to use Xcode or Visual Studio to a beginner starting to learn C or C++: just edit your code with ed(1), and run { cc -o hw hw.c } in the terminal.
Be sure to teach in advanced lessons about the ed(1) command:
! cc -o hw hw.c && ./hw RET
like: $ ed hw.lisp
hw.lisp: No such file or directory
i
(defun main ()
(princ "Hello World!")
(terpri))
(main)
.
w
59
!clisp -norc -q hw.lisp
Hello World!
!
1,$n
1 (defun main ()
2 (princ "Hello World!")
3 (terpri))
4 (main)
q
$
Somebody who lacks this experience, cannot understand the benefits of "IDE" or of emacs and slime. But also, the feature of calling out external programs like a compiler from an editor, exists in any good editor, not just emacs. Only it's emacs it's easier because you can customize it much more. It becomes clear when the newbie will have typed a hundred times: !clisp -l myprogram.lisp -x '(main)' RET
Then you introduce him to emacs and slime and he will feel you're Jesus came back to save him.Big point. The raw sbcl repl really hurts unless you use a superior mode or at least rlwrap.
You're just not that into it and blaming SLIME or anything else that's part of the ecosystem is just misguided and wrong.
You compare SLIME with Visual Studio when they have almost nothing in common and most lispers detest the idea that you have to have something like Visual <anything> to work with a language.
If you really want to learn Lisp, sit down with an editor and start running code instead of trying to optimize for a problem you're likely never to stumble upon. When you get it, you'll gladly write Lisp even if they mandate that you're only allowed to use a chisel and stone tablets.
It is kind of sad that one of the oldest languages that was in the genesis of IDEs and interactive programming should be like, only has Emacs nowadays in its open source offerings.