News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by nl on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:17AM (#10115647)
So this is really a subset of question answering.

A month ago I said[1] I thought the Memory Network approach to these tasks was some of the most important neural network being done atm. Now this comes along and jumps from 33.5% to 87% of the path finding question answering task, and to 97.9% on positional reasoning.

I don't know what the human benchmarks are, but I'd guess the positional reasoning rate is close to human levels.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9960852

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by ma2rten on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @10:33AM (#10116743)
I should point out that is an artificial dataset generated by computers according to some simple rules. Doing good on these doesn't necessarily mean anything.

Also, they didn't report the accuracy on any of the other 18 tasks. That makes me believe that they did pretty badly on those.

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by 336f5 on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:21PM (#10117569)
The /r/machinelearning discussion (https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/3iayyz/neu...) makes an interesting point about the 18 tasks thing:

> That was my first instinct too. Going back to the dynamic memory networks paper though, it turns out (§4.1) that these are the only two tasks it didn't solve almost-perfectly.

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by nl on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @07:44PM (#10120188)
It is true that this is an artificial test, but it seems to me that doing well at this is a necessary prerequisite to do well at more complex scenarios.

It's worth noting that these tests were introduced by Jason Weston[1] as "A Set of Prerequisite Toy Tasks"[2]

Also, they didn't report the accuracy on any of the other 18 tasks. That makes me believe that they did pretty badly on those.

Weston's work on Memory Networks has "solved" (or at least shown a good way forward) on 16 of those other tasks. These were the two that were furthest away from being solved (See [2], again). The remaining 2 look like they will fall to Memory Networks with some work.

[1] http://www.thespermwhale.com/jaseweston/

[2] http://arxiv.org/abs/1502.05698

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by pberlin on Thursday September 03, 2015 @10:28PM (#10168548)
Copied from Reddit FYI.

As the second author of the paper, I have to say "Wrong Guess", :), we didn't try the other 18. The story is as follows. We had this idea in early March as a reasoning component of our bigger (and cool) neural system. In early May my student intern (the first author) decided to implement it, but he said "why don't we try this on a couple of hard bAbi tasks on which Memory Net failed?", and then we are here. That said, I don't mean Neural Reasoner can easily solve them without any model tweaking, considering some of them are formulated slightly differently from the two we tried . But more importantly, it was never our goal to nail an artificial data set.

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by fpgaminer on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @12:05PM (#10117418)
The stated reason for only testing on two of the task types:

> For simplicity, we focus on the reasoning tasks which can be formulated as classification with predetermined classes.

Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by hyperion2010 on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @01:40PM (#10118237)
When we can get a neural net to ask the right questions I will be satisfied.
Re:Towards Neural Network-based Reasoning by p1esk on Tuesday August 25, 2015 @03:04PM (#10118785)
That "right" question might turn out to be: "Those biological humans get in my way. Should I wipe them out?"