This condemns children to repeat the cycle. They (completely rationally) decide that they're just 'not math people' because they can't follow lists of arbitrary seeming steps to do something that no one they have ever met ever actually does in daily life. And some of them grow up to be teachers themselves.
Sigh, your statement reminds me of one time when I was in 6th grade geometry and was asked to complete this one proof. The problem was intended to get us to apply a concept we had been taught verbatim, but I couldn't remember it well and so I completed the proof a different way by extrapolating other basic concepts we had gone over into a method we had not been taught. I remember feeling very proud of myself when I finished, as I had created something which in my 12 year old eyes was a "novel proof". I ended up being given 0 points on the problem because I did not complete my proof using cookie cutter methods we had been taught (even though my proof was correct and it was not specified that I use a particular concept in the instructions).
I remember complaining to my teacher about how this was unfair and she kept saying something akin to "well you didn't do the problem the right way". The incident pretty much killed any interest I had in math, which wasn't rekindled until I stumbled upon machine learning recently in my 20s.
There are a lot of other people out there who will unknowingly be very discouraging, to both children and adults, but their opinions have no bearing on our ability to learn. I remember being in music class in grade 1 and it was my absolute favorite class. Near the end of the year I was told that I wasn't very good at singing by my teacher. I never tried to sing again, but I learned later that I have good pitch and a decent voice. I am not really interested in singing now, but I might have learned a different set of skills if I didn't avoid it.
Is there a way that I could have been prepared so that being told by the person I looked up to for validation, that I was no good wouldn't make me stop trying to improve?
I don't know about that, but if there's a way to teach that, it would definitely be a good lesson. It would certainly be nice if teachers didn't do things like that, but even if you could guarantee they didn't, you won't stop the bullies or the critics or anyone other hater as you get older.
To the grandparent: I don't think getting upset is at all irrational.
Not helping matters is the fact that most of the reformers are themselves ignorant chuckleheads who identify the heuristics that skilled arithmeticians use and codify them as a NEW set of rules to be memorized...
Failure to learn the standard algorithms impedes progress. You are unlikely to do well in the next course if you are slow and can't handle numerous cases.
Learning alternate algorithms is great... once you have the standard algorithms down solid and are ready to prove equivalence.
Have a look at the sample chapter from David Tall's book...
https://homepages.warwick.ac.uk/staff/David.Tall/themes/thre...
That said, I've definitely seen some of that "let's just replace method X with method Y" – how harmful that is depends on whether it is just presented as a default or as The New Standard Algorithm, I guess.
Of course it isn't, because such lunacy wouldn't be supported by competent research. But the people who do education research, the administrators making curriculum decisions, and the concerned parents trolling about the dangers of "Common Core" on Facebook are distinct sets with little overlap.
I think physically intuitive math and abstract math should be explicitly identified and treated differently in curricula. Else, the result will be clumsy contrived attempts to find physical relevance to abstract concepts and weaker students falling behind. Dreary contrived problems must be replaced with fun puzzles. Puzzles share the attribute of abstractness-and-apparent-uselessness with portions of the math curriculum.
Somehow teachers and parents find it hard to accept that some topics in math curricula are purely in the abstract realm.
The other meta problem and perhaps a big cause of math anxiety is that the curriculum and system doesn't have much wiggle room to fail at understanding something. The most important quality for success in later life is perseverance when you're stuck or when you hit a wall. The education system teaches the exact opposite: "it is not ok to hit a wall or fail to understand something, you have to learn this right now, else you're done for!" There is very little flexibility to allow students to fail, persevere, and repeat. This is worsened by the needlessly frenetic pace of the academic year.
Edit: D'oh, got 3/4 + 1/7 wrong, it should be 25/28
http://www.amazon.com/Help-Your-Kids-Math-problem/dp/0756649...
http://www.amazon.com/Math-Power-Child-Dover-Mathematics/dp/...
http://www.amazon.com/What-Help-Child-Math-Myself/dp/0974168...
Amazon.co.uk
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Help-Your-Kids-Math-Problem/dp/07566...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Math-Power-Child-Dover-Mathematics/d...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/What-Help-Child-Math-Myself/dp/09741...
My favourites are the Rob Eastaway / Mike Askew books:
http://www.amazon.com/More-Maths-Mums-Askew-Eastaway/dp/0224...
http://www.amazon.com/Maths-Mums-Dads-Rob-Eastaway-ebook/dp/...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Maths-Mums-Dads-Mike-Askew/dp/022408...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/More-Maths-Mums-Dads-Askew/dp/022409...
(Amazon: Please have some really easy way to give me a clean url for sharing. I am literally sending potential customers to your website.)
For the .co.uk links, concatenate: "amazon.co.uk/dp/",[10 character string in URL, aka ASIN]
So, your first link would be "amzn.com/075664979X"
I don't know how to draw a multiplication (and I think I'm not alone), but get some physical tokens that you can divide in 2 or 3 (like matches), and you can do all kinds of fraction multiplication and division with them.
The transcripts included in the research paper "Mathematics in the Home" (PDF: http://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nicole_Else-Quest/public...) are really telling. Parents who are comfortable with math will tend to ask their kids questions and give little hints when they're stuck, whereas parents that are uncomfortable with math will tend to just blurt out the solution whenever things are taking too long, or encourage strict adherence to one particular heuristic for finding a solution. Over the long haul, the result is that mathematics will start to look like just one long arbitrary list of rules. Of course, that's no fun, and so kids of mathophobes become mathophobes themselves.
Plenty of help available, though, for people who do want to help their kids: "Help Your Kids with Math: A visual problem solver for kids and parents", "Math Power: How to Help Your Child Love Math, Even If You Don't", "What Can I Do to Help My Child with Math When I Don't Know Any Myself?"