News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by netcan on Monday August 24, 2015 @07:29AM (#10109016)
What I'm curious about is future changes in user behavior in response to this kind of stuff. Private data, public data and the public-private grey areas like pseudonymous posts, access restricted (FB-like) profiles and such are getting leaked all the time.

Paranoia is definitely building. Awareness of how exposed people are is building. Yet, exposure is going up not down. People are posting more stuff online. I wonder if, for example, the cloud hack has impacted the trend of people taking nude picture at all? I suspect it hasn't. I suspect that none of these leaks will impact user behavior.

On one hand, a leak of an Ashley madison profile or salacious photos makes people aware that the danger exists. On the other, it confirms how widespread and normal it is to do these things.

Here's my (soft) prediction: Norms concerning fidelity and/or modesty will give before online behavior does. If the choice is stop sending nudie pictures or stop getting embarrassed when they leak, we'll go for the latter. For infidelity… maybe strict monogamy will soften as a norm.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by fab13n on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:35AM (#10109290)
> maybe strict monogamy will soften as a norm.

Polygamy is already the norm in the West, only it's serial polygamy instead of parallel one, i.e. you're supposed to dump your previous partner before picking the next one. But most people enter most relationships being very open to the idea that it won't be lifelong, and that other partners will be part of their sexual, sentimental and patrimonial future: this constitutes polygamy, irrespective of the order in which you have sex with the several partners you plan to have.

Will insistance on serial polygamy soften? I'd say that the forces seem aligned for this to happen:

* reproductive control was the main reason for historical control over people's sexuality. With reliable contraception and easy paternity tests, those incentives are dramatically weakened.

* don't underestimate homo sapiens' urge to practice polygamy: historically we've had to punish adultery by gruesome death, it still routinely causes financial ruin in the US, yet people always kept committing it! They're still willing to wreck their own children's family and well-being, in exchange for some renewal in their sentimental and sensual lives! This urge seems to me at least as strong as the gluttony epidemic, which turns many Westerners into impotent, morbidly obese wrecks, one hamburger at a time.

* Exposure accelerates acceptance. Internet is bound to make affairs more and more visible, and as a result, we'll get used to them.

As for modesty, even before Internet, the list of which body parts / positions were naughty evolved fast and flexibly, within decades (think miniskirts, sleeveless tops, bikini, monokini, Frei Korper Kultur, or conversely, the comeback of islamic female garbs in middle eastern countries). With Internet as a great accelerator, we'll soon be mildly too bored to Google sextapes of our acquaintances. I known I already feel that way about celebrities. First time patrons of naturist resorts typically report nudity-induced awkwardness to last about 1/4h :-)

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by rue on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:58AM (#10109401)
‘Serial polygamy’ means a sequence of multiple simultaneous relationships. You mean serial monogamy.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by fab13n on Monday August 24, 2015 @09:20AM (#10109502)
I meant it as an electrical engineering metaphor, where you can string devices in parallel, or in serial one after the other, but where with a few adaptations both can lead to the same practical result.

Besides, my whole point is that this behavior constitutes a variant of polygamy, not a variant of monogamy, so I stand by that term. That there's a "serial monogamy" idiom describing it (I just discovered it thanks to you and Google, I'm not a native speaker) is tellingly disingenuous IMO.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by rue on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:07AM (#10109782)
I don’t know, I think it’s less useful to read ‘lifelong’ into the word monogamy. It simply describes the number of simultaneous relationships—whether it lasts for a week or forever is another dimension.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by netcan on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:17AM (#10109877)
I think you're splitting hairs a little, rue.

In fairness, fab was splitting hairs with me. What I meant is a softening of the monogamy using the currently normal relationship model as the definition. What he meant is that the definition of normal monogamy has changed anyway over the past few generations. Courtship became relationships, which really became marriage-like partnership.

He's right. What we call monogamy would not have held with our great grandparents. They would have objected to the serial partnerships much more than the infidelity which at least we have the decency to try and keep secret.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by fab13n on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:54PM (#10111199)
> infidelity which we had the decency to try and keep secret.

Moreover, infidelity was about sex. It might also have cost a bit of money, going to mistresses and bastards, for wealthy male adulterers, but it didn't affect patrimonial rights. Neither could the mistress be promoted as new wife, to the detriment of the incumbent one.

The idea that marriage is first and foremost a love affair is a fairly recent one, and coincides with its demise (explosion of divorces, monoparental families...) The lifelong marriage was a patrimonial affair.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by angersock on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:42AM (#10110581)
It's not a variant of polygamy, though. If you were a polygamist and only ever had one partner at a time and weren't looking and courting others then you would be, de facto, practicing monogamy.

If I had a spouse, to whom I was devoted, and they were hit by a bus and killed, and then I had another spouse, who was killed by a falling meteoroid, and then a third spouse, who died of an aneurysm, and finally a fourth who left me because of a reasonable fear of death-by-misfortune--I would still be considered monogamous.

Yours is a very tortured interpretation of what polygamy is.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by fab13n on Monday August 24, 2015 @01:21PM (#10111451)
If you're a serial widower without being the cause of your spouses' deaths, then you're monogamous indeed. Monogamy does exist, and you can live morally monogamous lives although having several partners over your life.

But I don't think that's the topic. The original question was, will it become morally acceptable to be polygamous? And my answer was, you don't have to, of course, but you already can, in a contrieved way.

You can live the hookup culture without much stygma. You can dump your partners every 2-3 years, when novelty wears off, possibly having children with each of them. You can temporarily put up with a partner who doesn't satisfy you on some subjects, because you know there will be a next one who will fulfill those currently unmet needs.

TL;DR: polygamy isn't the only acceptable way, will probably never be, but some form of it already is a viable and non-stygmatized possibility.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by smtddr on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:17AM (#10109878)
I thought of it as how a CPU appears to be running several programs at the same time in a home PC, but we know the OS is actually switching between all the processes at an extremely high rate. :)
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by nyandaber on Monday August 24, 2015 @07:59AM (#10109123)
There's also the fact that for all those hacks, a non-negligeable portion of the people think the victims "had it coming". They feel it's wrong to take lewd pictures of yourself or join a site like Ashley Madison, so those hacks are justice being served.

They don't see the real underlying issue about privacy and informatic data. The day it's something more sensible like medical or financial records being leaked, I hope they'll change their outlook at it.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Lawtonfogle on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:28AM (#10109992)
>They don't see the real underlying issue about privacy and informatic data.

And many against even these hacks feel that the victims of hacks of hidden tor services 'had it coming'. Most people think that a sufficiently immoral online action means the hacked individual 'had it coming'. The difference is in what counts as sufficiently moral, not in the underlying view of if it is possible for someone to deserve to be hacked.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by LesZedCB on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:45AM (#10110150)
I am a part of the polyamorous (not totally distinct, but not the same as polygamy) culture, and I think it is slowly gaining some momentum. I'm not convinced it will ever see mainstream acceptance (who knows, LGBTQ+ people somewhat enjoy that now), but I think that it's a valid way to live life and enjoy romance and relationships. I have been with my current partner for 2 years, and we have both dated other people simultaneously. Many people don't believe that jealousy isn't an issue, but to be honest, for some people it's not an issue at all, and for others, trusting your partner is much stronger than worrying about what "could happen."

Then, when it comes to stuff like this, it's not even an issue. My partner wants to hook up with somebody else? Totally, go for it, enjoy yourself. Find love in others as well. It's not that scary, and I have no fear of ever being cheated on.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by angersock on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:59AM (#10110734)
It's a curious thing--from observation, I note that poly (along with a lot of other non-normal personality traits) tends to be notably prevalent in the tech and academic sectors. It is an open question whether this is because there's simply more visibility, or something else. There's also a decent amount of it in the kink sub-communities.

I have a hunch that it may be a byproduct of the ongoing evolution of the dating marketplace--if you have, for example, a rather uncommon kink or something, it makes sense not to voluntarily limit yourself to one supplier.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by icebraining on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:13PM (#10110835)
I'd say that belonging to the polyamourous community is more likely to limit you in the "dating marketplace" than giving you more options. You're essentially excluding the vast majority of the population, which is very much not OK with it.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by angersock on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:21PM (#10110912)
Well, yes and no, right? It's a smaller marketplace, but theoretically one with more chances to connect with people, because the resources are being more fully utilized and distributed.

And yes, the vocabulary here is somewhat on purpose. I think it's easy to argue that, if you're willing to treat the whole thing as matching providers and consumers, the poly approach is a strictly better marketplace than mainstream dating. Somewhat comically: the odds are good, but the goods are odd. :)

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by LesZedCB on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:39PM (#10111081)
Yeah, well I would say that when one is single and poly, the world is pretty wide open. When one is dating, certainly is makes it harder when you either have to find monogamous people who are ok with you dating other people (unlikely), or other poly people who are far less common than mono people.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by LesZedCB on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:37PM (#10111049)
I have actually noticed that as well. Almost all of my metamours have been in the tech sector.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by JustSomeNobody on Monday August 24, 2015 @07:45AM (#10109080)
Of course your prediction will come true, there's already a lot of evidence for it in the comments of most articles on the leak. Cheaters will be the victims and anyone who thinks cheating on one's spouse is bad will be considered insensitive.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by comrh on Monday August 24, 2015 @12:01PM (#10110752)
Can't you agree with both? The cheaters had their personal information stolen and leaked on the internet, and while they're engaging in unethical behavior (imho) that doesn't absolve the hackers.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by AlexandrB on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:08AM (#10109169)
> Cheaters will be the victims and anyone who thinks cheating on one's spouse is bad will be considered insensitive.

How do you know the spouse's opinion on the matter? That's the only opinion that matters regarding how bad it is.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by Karunamon on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:36AM (#10110534)
Because if the spouse is aware and accepting, it's not "cheating" anymore, it's just an open relationship.

"Cheating" implies dishonesty and deception.

..Something I think that keeps getting lost in this discussion that inevitably turns towards discussions of polyamory - this is not a discussion about whether polyamory is okay, it's a discussion about whether it's okay to lie to another person who you've of your own free will promised that you will be monogamous with.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by JustSomeNobody on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:37AM (#10109303)
Society can deem a behavior bad even while the individual can forgive and forget.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by JupiterMoon on Monday August 24, 2015 @07:37AM (#10109046)
> I wonder if, for example, the cloud hack has impacted the trend of people taking nude picture at all? I suspect it hasn't.

I've noticed recently that polaroid cameras are making a bit of a comeback. I wonder if this has any connection? (Not sure myself.)

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by prawn on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:01AM (#10109131)
No, it's purely a fashion/trend thing. Only ever seen them at parties and used as a gimmick to create a certain style of photo. Similar happens with vintage or modern photo booths hired for weddings.
Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by petercooper on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:01AM (#10109130)
I hope so. Humans have shown for millenia that they are unable to give in to certain urges. Some things are well worth fighting against, but in today's society strict monogamy doesn't seem to pose a major evolutionary advantage (though I could be wrong).

When Secret came out, I always assumed such a leak would occur, especially since it was linked to Facebook. So I only mostly posted fake secrets to troll people :-D I wonder if a certain level of mixing lies with reality will become the norm online to increase the doubt over information that leaks.

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by creshal on Monday August 24, 2015 @08:06AM (#10109152)
> in today's society strict monogamy doesn't seem to pose a major evolutionary advantage (though I could be wrong).

With the availability of reliable contraceptions (for both genders) and paternity tests, it has lost one of its main advantages: Ensuring that your offspring is really yours (for males) and that it won't have to compete with another mates offspring (for females).

Re:Here’s what Ashley Madison members have told me by netcan on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:32AM (#10110026)
If you're going to biology, absolutely strict monogamy is not really part of our package. But, some sort of monogamy (or pairing) is almost certainly. Culture makes these rules, not biology and culture is pretty malleable in this regard.

Your great grandmother might have had a much more forgiving reaction to this infidelity stuff as a lot of people today. She probably thought girls having extra marital relationships some lasting days and some lasting years (as is normal today) as immoral trollop behavior.

Side note on evolutionary monogamy:

A lot of birds are monogamous. A lot of foundational zoologists were Victorians so they saw eye-to-eye. There were a lot of studies of avian reproductive behavior for the entirety of the modern scientific period. Recently, DNA tests on nestlings revealed that birds cheat. The reason Victorians (and other later) rarely picked up on it is because they're so damn sneaky about it. It's a no no in bird marriages, but they still do it.