Re:What's new in CPUs since the 80s and how does it affect p...
by gizmo686 on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:19AM
(#10108354)
It is worth noting that many of the Mill features are also a "lie" (for example, the belt is still just registers and register renaming). Its just that the Mill uses lies designed for modern processor technology.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:What's new in CPUs since the 80s and how does it affect p...
by Symmetry on Monday August 24, 2015 @11:16AM
(#10110394)
The belt isn't an abstraction of the structures in a modern OoO CPU corresponding to registers and renaming but rather the bypass network further down the pipeline. The belt like the bypass network only has to store data for limited periods and the translation is much simpler than what an OoO CPU has to do when renaming registers.
Re:What's new in CPUs since the 80s and how does it affect p...
by zurn on Monday August 24, 2015 @10:42AM
(#10110124)
Yes, registers and the belt are just ISA features. Register renaming is a behind the scenes implementation tech to mitigate the problems of register semantics. It has unwanted costs that a belt machine doesn't have to pay, and it's incorrect to say that Mill does register renaming in the traditional sense of the word.
Indeed that's what the #1 paragraph at https://millcomputing.com/docs/belt/ says: "A large fraction of the power budget of modern superscalar CPUs is devoted to renaming registers: the CPU must track the dataflow of the executing program, assign physical registers and map them to the logical registers of the program, schedule operations when arguments are available, restore visible state in the event of an exception—all while avoiding register update hazards."
Re:What's new in CPUs since the 80s and how does it affect p...
by w0000t on Monday August 24, 2015 @03:36AM
(#10108408)
False. Mill does not do register renaming. ( Or use "lies". I failed to comprehend you second sentence. )
Here is a talk from one of the designers explaining how it is done: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QGw-cy0ylCc&feature=youtu.be...