Re:The Manual One-Time Pad
by panic on Sunday August 23, 2015 @06:19AM
(#10105174)
And if you're generating your one time pads using a (hopefully cryptographically-secure) pseudorandom number generator, then congratulations! You are literally reinventing a stream cipher except with enormous, non-reusable keys.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Manual One-Time Pad
by ekyepyaport on Sunday August 23, 2015 @06:42AM
(#10105208)
non-reusable keys! what a critique on one time pads!
and enormous keys too! you might need to store them on some sort of notebook or large paper thingie!
The point is that the desire to use a OTP typically hinges on it being "uncrackable".
By using a PRNG (even if it is a cryptographic stream cipher) to generate your pad, you've just re-introduced the same "crackability" (by way of the PRNG), and your system is strictly worse (same security, worse logistics) than an existing system.