Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by cookiecaper on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:07PM
(#1010509)
This isn't really labor, first of all. For most of us it's both a leisure and educational activity that we participate in not for PG's benefit, but for our own benefit by learning and socialization. Making a sign that says "Hi Lili" and taking a picture of it is much less fruitful, even if it nets me $1 in money. The things I learn on HN net me much more money in the long run.
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by nostrademons on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:30PM
(#1010558)
But we have no way of knowing if Mechanical Turk participants think of their turking the same way...
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:03PM
(#1010653)
Except perhaps the ad-hoc (non-rigorous) studies that have been done before asking people why they turk. Someone mentioned last years submission of such a study further up the thread.
Of course you may be being philosophical about it. In which case, no we have no real way of knowing if they even think.
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by robryan on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:39PM
(#1010741)
The taking a picture task to could be though of as fun and something different compared to a lot of the jobs on there. So in this case someones motivation might not having anything to do with the dollar on offer.
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by whatusername on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @08:07PM
(#1011238)
And hey - if that $1 takes you 5 minutes, then that's $12/hour.
I'm pretty sure that might be above the US minimum wage.
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by tobych on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:44PM
(#1010594)
$1 - $0 = $1
Re:I hired 50 people today. This is what they look like
by nostrademons on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @05:06PM
(#1010929)
$1 / $0 = undefined ;-)
It's interesting to read all the comments that say "$1?!?! You're ripping off these people! Why would anyone ever do anything on Mechanical Turk?" How many hours do y'all spend on Hacker News? How long did it take you to write those comments? How much were you paid for it?
In strictly economic terms, Turkers are getting ripped off a lot less than news.YCers are. After all, $1 is infinitely more than $0. We labor for free so that Paul Graham can have a viable online community and pick of the top posters for his seed capital firm.