CSS still has the advantage over tables of better separating content from presentation. A big problem with CSS is it's still awkward to deal with layout, so it's somewhat understandable some people just prefer to give up and use tables.
2. Yes.
On the other hand, 2003 was the last year when I did layout using table. I did pixel-perfect cross browser layouts with CSS five years ago, and they had to work in IE5 back then. So yes, I do know what I am talking about and stand by my position.
Using just semantic markup, or with lots of divs within divs that have no justification to be there except to allow styles to be attached to them?
"Great pyramids of DIV" based layout is at most marginally better than table based layout.
(or, in the case of the particular HN username here, people who'd like you to think they know all the differences between multiple Lisp families and multiple implementations within families)
http://www.flownet.com/ron/css-rant.html
(How do you do links in HN comments? Markdown syntax doesn't seem to work.)