Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by tengkahwee on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @01:23PM
(#1010410)
Mashable doesn't seem to enjoy giving others credit. The only link to the author is just a tiny link with the word "share". Even the name isn't mentioned. The original author deserves more than that.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by pavs on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:37PM
(#1010574)
Thanks for this. I was about to write a comment dissing Mashable for this.
Also, please consider doing it more often. Mashable rarely links to the original source (if at all), many times I have to Google to get more information; an extra step that can be easily avoided. Its in good form to link the original source.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by Mystalic on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:55PM
(#1010771)
We link regularly to the original source, I'm sorry if it's not as visible, but I assure you we do regularly. The exception are ones coming in the form of company announcements, but even then we often link back to their blog posts.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by pavs on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @04:54PM
(#1010907)
OK, I should have said "from my experience". That was my experience most of the time when I was subscribed to mashable RSS, most of the time posts were deep linked to more mashable posts, instead of original source. It was a quite bit frustrating.
Anyways, I just checked the last couple of post you guys had they all seem to link to the source. The fact that you come here to reply to readers opinions, clearly means you guys care. That's good enough for me.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by lovskogen on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:09PM
(#1010667)
In your last image "Comparison of Firefox 4.0 and Firefox 3.5" – the screenshot of 3.5 has a bookmarks bar and multiple tabs, while the grab from 4.0 has not.
You are making it look like 4.0 gives way more room to browse, when the change is marginal.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by d0m on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @12:16PM
(#1010259)
Do you remember in the comics of chrome, they said they were doing it to help other browsers. They also said they'd really like to have their ideas borrowed to make the web a better place.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by treyp on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @12:58PM
(#1010348)
which parts are so Chromish?
the new Firefox button comes from Microsoft Office.
the space between tabs comes from either Opera or Microsoft Office.
the tabs on top, which is only a possibility at this point, comes from Opera first, but was implemented by Google Chrome down the line.
the use of so much transparency in the menu may come from Microsoft Office or Chrome.
the non-flat buttons can come from Opera or Chrome.
the use of only three buttons on the left, however, comes from Chrome. it should be mentioned that Firefox is playing with the idea of getting rid of a refresh button on the left by building it into the location bar. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Projects/3.7_and_4.0_Theme_...
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by pavs on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @01:13PM
(#1010378)
Have you used chrome recently? While they might have borrowed ideas from other UI designs, never before did Firefox look more like chrome.
Not that its a bad thing. Throughout its history FF have taken design ideas from IE, Opera extensively. For all we know, FF most likely wouldn't even consider such a drastic UI change if chrome wasn't in the picture. FF UI changes has always been incremental and subtle.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by jm4 on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:57PM
(#1010779)
That's not an accurate comparison. That's an improvement to the rendering engine that's shared between them. They all have the feature. It's a different story when you're talking about a feature you're planning to implement and then mention the competitor who already has it. It's just plain stupid.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by jm4 on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:55PM
(#1010773)
Yes, but, unlike some open source projects, Mozilla is out to make money from the project and their income is generated almost exclusively through a search deal with this particular competitor.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by ryandvm on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @11:57AM
(#1010220)
Very Chromish. I'm glad they're not too proud to borrow good ideas when they see them. Now if they can just improve stability and speed I may switch back from Chromium.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by andyking on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @12:52PM
(#1010334)
The Firefox menu in the top-left corner looks remarkably similar to the O menu that's appeared in the latest Opera alpha (http://goo.gl/Chfb).
I like the way a lot of the cruft from 1990s Windows applications is starting to disappear from programmes that really don't need it like modern browsers.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by mcantor on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:03PM
(#1010500)
Out of curiosity, why did you post a shortened link here instead of the canonical one? Does goo.gl give you some kind of clickthrough monitoring, or was there another reason?
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by samdk on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @11:59AM
(#1010227)
This makes me very, very happy. I use Chrome on my netbook for two reasons: it's faster, and it takes up significantly less screen space. It's nice to see Firefox beginning to compete in at least one of those two areas.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by thehigherlife on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:23PM
(#1010703)
do you know of a way to set certain UI elements to load on every launch so that i don't have to type in 'set guioptions' every time i launch the browser?
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by metra on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @01:30PM
(#1010431)
How is this saving space? How is this Chrome-ish?
Chrome saved space by getting rid of the title bar (a bar that would just say "Chrome"). From these pictures, Firefox still has a whole bar that just says "Firefox." Why?
Mozilla, please allow us to place tabs on the Title bar!
And if you really want to blow Chrome out of the water, explore innovative vertical tab options. Tree style tabs is an immensely popular extension for a reason.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by yason on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:21PM
(#1010697)
All I ever wanted from Firefox 4.0 is the user interface latency (or rather, lack thereof) of Chromium and the process-per-tab / process-per-plugin model. The latter would probably help a lot with the former.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by Luyt on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @03:01PM
(#1010648)
I wish they'd optimize for vertical space instead of eye candy. Most applications use way too much vertically stacked menubars, toolbars, bookmarks bars etc..., nibbling away precious display space from the document.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by nopassrecover on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @12:09PM
(#1010245)
Some of the sample back/forward button mockups are quite nice and subtle but the one they use in the final 4.0/3.5 comparison image is terribly chunky.
Re:Firefox 4.0: New Design Changes Revealed
by ghotli on Tuesday December 22, 2009 @02:11PM
(#1010516)
I'm not sure I understand what you're saying. Chrome showcased multiple innovations in browser technology. Things like a single process per tab, a much tighter security model, and proof that javascript implementations could be much faster.
By doing this they have set trends in how browser technologies should progress and thus had an influence on their ability to implement "html 5" webapps in the future that work cross browser. It was much more than "check it out we put tabs in the title bar guys".
- Ben (Co-Editor)
Also, please consider doing it more often. Mashable rarely links to the original source (if at all), many times I have to Google to get more information; an extra step that can be easily avoided. Its in good form to link the original source.
I'll try to make it more visible in the future.
Anyways, I just checked the last couple of post you guys had they all seem to link to the source. The fact that you come here to reply to readers opinions, clearly means you guys care. That's good enough for me.
Thanks.
You are making it look like 4.0 gives way more room to browse, when the change is marginal.
the new Firefox button comes from Microsoft Office.
the space between tabs comes from either Opera or Microsoft Office.
the tabs on top, which is only a possibility at this point, comes from Opera first, but was implemented by Google Chrome down the line.
the use of so much transparency in the menu may come from Microsoft Office or Chrome.
the non-flat buttons can come from Opera or Chrome.
the use of only three buttons on the left, however, comes from Chrome. it should be mentioned that Firefox is playing with the idea of getting rid of a refresh button on the left by building it into the location bar. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Firefox/Projects/3.7_and_4.0_Theme_...
just want to give credit where credit is due.
Not that its a bad thing. Throughout its history FF have taken design ideas from IE, Opera extensively. For all we know, FF most likely wouldn't even consider such a drastic UI change if chrome wasn't in the picture. FF UI changes has always been incremental and subtle.
I recently watched an official video by Googlers about the Chrome extensions, and they mention Firefox by name many times.
I like the way a lot of the cruft from 1990s Windows applications is starting to disappear from programmes that really don't need it like modern browsers.
Chrome saved space by getting rid of the title bar (a bar that would just say "Chrome"). From these pictures, Firefox still has a whole bar that just says "Firefox." Why?
Mozilla, please allow us to place tabs on the Title bar!
And if you really want to blow Chrome out of the water, explore innovative vertical tab options. Tree style tabs is an immensely popular extension for a reason.
The screenshot mockups don't tell.
By doing this they have set trends in how browser technologies should progress and thus had an influence on their ability to implement "html 5" webapps in the future that work cross browser. It was much more than "check it out we put tabs in the title bar guys".
Again.