News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by sloanesturz on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:25PM (#10098542)
I understand why the DMCA exists -- so that people can't post your copyrighted data (that you necessarily own) without your consent.

I understand slander laws -- so that people can't make up stories about you and present them as facts.

I do not understand the Right to be Forgotten -- if something is true and public information, why should Google hide the data from its search results? An article being about you does not mean that the information inside of it "belongs" to you.

>> "the links relating to a criminal offence that were removed by Google following a request from the individual concerned."

You can't request the BBC or Telegraph to take down true and legitimate articles (nor should you), so on what basis does the EU think that they can order Google to alter their search results?

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by _delirium on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:53PM (#10098747)
You can indeed request the BBC or Telegraph to take down articles under similar circumstances. For example in most European countries you can't publish a kind of "where are they now?" article that picks a few random '80s criminal cases, and tracks down the whereabouts of the people 30 years later. That kind of article, showing that a certain person (mentioned by name) now works as a web designer in Aarhus, while another person (also mentioned by name) has moved to Germany and is a welder, etc., would be seen as an invasion of privacy by gratuitously digging up and publishing this kind of 30-year-old information without a current public-interest justification.

It doesn't come up often with respectable media outlets, because they have mostly internalized this norm anyway, and wouldn't run such a story. But I could imagine a tabloid or daytime TV show doing something like that, if it were legal.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by alain94040 on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:29PM (#10098580)
Your question is covered by the EU's fact sheet on the topic. I found it very readable and clear: http://ec.europa.eu/justice/data-protection/files/factsheets...
[dead]
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by cromwellian on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:56PM (#10098769)
The only problem is, Google isn't the only way to find this information. It exists in social networks, on Twitter, Facebook, and even in Archive.org. It also exists in local search engines provided by the sites themselves.

If you have an uncommon name, and you were covered by the news media, or by social media, I can go direct to the AP, NYT, or Twitter search just as easily as Google.

It's sad that the internet can't forget, but the law can't make this a reality.

Does anyone seriously believe anyone doing serious research, stalking, or a background check on someone will be stymied by Google censoring links?

How many of you searching for pirated warez are stymied by DMCA takedowns and don't just go directly to Torrent search engines?

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by mattmanser on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:32PM (#10098999)
That's not a problem, the information isn't being removed, it's just being stopped from being the most visible representation of you, it's being de-emphasized.

Like in the old days everyone in the village knew Billy was caught with his pants down with a goat, but no-one brings it up every time they see him. Unlike "asshole" Uncle Google.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by tracker1 on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:16PM (#10099952)
It's funny that this is said a lot that the internet can't forget... but the internet can and has forgotten a lot, so to speak... especially with regards to frequency/recent models in Google, Twitter, etc... a lot of stuff falls off relatively quickly... and it's actually hard to find some stuff that happened in the late 90's and early 00's, because you're trying to remember when concert X was, or who was the opening act...

There are plenty of times that the "internet forgets" which archive.org works to prevent, but it still happens.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by kuschku on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:07PM (#10098851)
The idea is that, if you search for it with determination, it becomes legally something completely different than if you stumble upon it "accidentally" while doing a "standard google search of the new job candidate"
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by spinlock on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:26PM (#10098960)
In the EU we all know it is very hard to fire someone once they have been hired. Why won't employers start using background search services to find this information rather than Google?
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by kuschku on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:35PM (#10099417)
See, it is illegal to reject or fire someone for this (mostly) – just because you, as a kid, partied hard, doesn’t mean employers can discriminate against you.

A lot of employers started testing the "anonymous job application": They only get a UUID, your qualifications and CV, and only after they decided if they want to hire you or not the employer actually gets the name, age, gender, etc.

VW, for example, is taking part in this. Also makes sure that no one can complain about ageism/sexism/racism/transphobia/otherkinphobia/etc

Mostly: There are cases where some types of background checks are legal.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by darkmighty on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:07PM (#10099597)
This is an amazing practice. It's the double blind method applied to hiring!
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by genericuser on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:21PM (#10098935)
Eh I say if people honestly can't learn to accept that things about other people from a significant time ago might no longer be relevant, then have SEO become a more personal service, and if people want to have their search results managed, because of whatever, they can manage it themselves or hire a professional, much like they would a lawyer, accountant, plumber, electrician, realtor, or agent. I mean they are having to hire lawyers presumably to get forgotten.

It won't be hard to bury a 6 year old photo of a random person shitting on the beach under all the new content.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by bko on Friday August 21, 2015 @12:54PM (#10098753)
Designing legislation from the victim's perspective is not advisable.

Example: How would you feel if someone assaulted someone you love? I would likely believe this person should be thrown in jail for a very long time although its probably an unreasonable punishment for the crime.

I just don't see a way where a piece of legislation can be drafted and implemented that would protect your daughter and not be abused by those in power who want to change the historical record.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by fastandfurryous on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:29PM (#10100023)
Those in power who want to change the historical record already have the power to do so. They do not need this legislation to do what they want.

You do not have that power and this does not give you the power to change the historical record. It allows you to influence the bias in which Google, a biased search engine, displays information that should be relevant to your identity.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by mattmanser on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:38PM (#10099036)
How is it abuse?

This is where we differ, criminals have a right to move on too from google shaming.

There will still be professional criminal record check companies and credit check companies, if you need to check someone out, don't rely on Google.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by charonn0 on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:23PM (#10098944)
> Can she never move on?

Why should Google (or other search engines) bear the responsibility for covering up the mistakes of others?

Should libraries be forced to remove unflattering articles from their newspaper and magazine archives?

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by mattmanser on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:27PM (#10098964)
Because that's part of the cost of doing business in the EU where we have laws to protect individuals from companies.

No more, no less. It just is.

Or to put it in another way because you're highlighting the 'cost'. You want to make billions from the search business in the EU? Then you need a way to spend a few hundred thousand obeying the law.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by jsolson on Friday August 21, 2015 @06:03PM (#10100515)
Is it not obvious that you're going to get general-purpose search engines which explicitly do not operate in Europe that exist for the sole purpose of finding information that's been erased from Google under the 'Right to be Forgotten'?

In particular, search engines which prioritize/highlight information which has been erased making it easier to find things people wanted to keep hidden?

For background checks, I expect a whole cottage industry will spring up of extra-European companies which provide European employers with background information that's hidden on the continent.

It's not so much the ideal that the EC holds (that people have a right to be judged on their present rather than on an unaudited collection of searchable details from the past -- an ideal I can agree with), but that there seem to be a surprisingly large number of people who think the strategy they've adopted will actually be effective. It seems blindingly obvious to me (and I expect many other people who have been responding to you) that the inevitable outcome is going to be far far more effective at calling out things people would rather have forgotten than things as they stood before the ruling.

To me it seems as if a startlingly large group of people has said, effectively, "this ideal is so important that we must take drastic action that guarantees we can never achieve it".

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by MichaelGG on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:22PM (#10099312)
So if a free search engine did this, then it'd be OK since it wasn't a for-profit company? Pretty sure that's broken logic.
Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by mattmanser on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:30PM (#10099369)
Where did I say that?

If you're a small search engine, then it won't apply will it?

If you become a big search engine and you're free, it's another running cost just like servers, which you'll be paying for somehow.

If you run a free image hosting company you don't suddenly magically become immune from getting a knock on the door when you make no effort to remove kiddie porn?

That's why the logic isn't broken.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by Oletros on Friday August 21, 2015 @02:59PM (#10099551)
> If you're a small search engine, then it won't apply will it?

Why do you think it won't apply to a small search engine?

It applies to every search engine operating in the EU, independently of its size or status

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by mattmanser on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:06PM (#10099594)
Pretty obvious isn't it? If no-one knows about your search engine, they're not going to petition to have your results altered.

And even if you were asked and didn't, would the petitioner actually escalate it to being taken to court?

And on top of that, now we all know if you've got a search engine gathering data on EU soil you need to comply with EU law, you can build the functionality in from the beginning anyway. Which isn't prohibitively expensive.

I don't know why you're grasping at this 'cost' straw, search is fantastically profitable. The search engines now have a social responsibility the EU courts have given to them to comply with, which costs a little but of money. It's like crazy laws like 'no pollution' or 'have safety equipment'. This one's 'stop algorithmically persecuting individuals'.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by Oletros on Friday August 21, 2015 @04:06PM (#10099898)
> Pretty obvious isn't it? If no-one knows about your search engine, they're not going to petition to have your results altered.

You're a little confused, it is irrelevant if someone does a petition or not, every search engine has to comply the law and have the mechanisms available.

> I don't know why you're grasping at this 'cost' straw

When I have said anything about cost?

> And on top of that, now we all know if you've got a search engine gathering data on EU soil you need to comply with EU law

Really? Contradicting yourself?

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by charonn0 on Friday August 21, 2015 @09:43PM (#10101162)
> Because that's part of the cost of doing business in the EU where we have laws to protect individuals from companies.

This is not an answer to my question. Allow me to clarify:

What is the justification for the EU law requiring search engines to cover up the mistakes of others?

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by thrownaway2424 on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:38PM (#10099037)
This explains a lot about Europe's shit-covered beaches.

Yes I feel like it's OK if someone is permanently shamed over shitting on a beach.

Re:Google ordered to remove links to stories about Google re... by Oletros on Friday August 21, 2015 @03:00PM (#10099557)
What the heck are you talking about?