No more, no less. It just is.
Or to put it in another way because you're highlighting the 'cost'. You want to make billions from the search business in the EU? Then you need a way to spend a few hundred thousand obeying the law.
In particular, search engines which prioritize/highlight information which has been erased making it easier to find things people wanted to keep hidden?
For background checks, I expect a whole cottage industry will spring up of extra-European companies which provide European employers with background information that's hidden on the continent.
It's not so much the ideal that the EC holds (that people have a right to be judged on their present rather than on an unaudited collection of searchable details from the past -- an ideal I can agree with), but that there seem to be a surprisingly large number of people who think the strategy they've adopted will actually be effective. It seems blindingly obvious to me (and I expect many other people who have been responding to you) that the inevitable outcome is going to be far far more effective at calling out things people would rather have forgotten than things as they stood before the ruling.
To me it seems as if a startlingly large group of people has said, effectively, "this ideal is so important that we must take drastic action that guarantees we can never achieve it".
If you're a small search engine, then it won't apply will it?
If you become a big search engine and you're free, it's another running cost just like servers, which you'll be paying for somehow.
If you run a free image hosting company you don't suddenly magically become immune from getting a knock on the door when you make no effort to remove kiddie porn?
That's why the logic isn't broken.
Why do you think it won't apply to a small search engine?
It applies to every search engine operating in the EU, independently of its size or status
And even if you were asked and didn't, would the petitioner actually escalate it to being taken to court?
And on top of that, now we all know if you've got a search engine gathering data on EU soil you need to comply with EU law, you can build the functionality in from the beginning anyway. Which isn't prohibitively expensive.
I don't know why you're grasping at this 'cost' straw, search is fantastically profitable. The search engines now have a social responsibility the EU courts have given to them to comply with, which costs a little but of money. It's like crazy laws like 'no pollution' or 'have safety equipment'. This one's 'stop algorithmically persecuting individuals'.
You're a little confused, it is irrelevant if someone does a petition or not, every search engine has to comply the law and have the mechanisms available.
> I don't know why you're grasping at this 'cost' straw
When I have said anything about cost?
> And on top of that, now we all know if you've got a search engine gathering data on EU soil you need to comply with EU law
Really? Contradicting yourself?
This is not an answer to my question. Allow me to clarify:
What is the justification for the EU law requiring search engines to cover up the mistakes of others?
Why should Google (or other search engines) bear the responsibility for covering up the mistakes of others?
Should libraries be forced to remove unflattering articles from their newspaper and magazine archives?