News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:05PM (#10094653)
There is an older discussion on HN on these topics. Think again what the site really was: probably 95% of visitors were men. That means that maybe 18 from 20 didn't find a "match"? Moreover, somebody mentioned that there were fake female profiles. Reduce the number of successful "matches." Most of the visitors probably didn't do anything. "But they intended!" can somebody say "and that is enough." Well then think again. How many weren't actually in relation but expected to get the "match" easier on the site where potential (not actual!) members aren't prepared to the long-term bind to the "matched" partner. Etc.

Do you still consider all these poor dastards as the big "sinners?" Which percentage of the persons on the lists "deserve" anybody's "wrath"? Do you really want to condemn everyone? Does that match your moral values? You can even ask how many of these hopeful to "do something" actually didn't do anything exactly because they tried to use the given site instead of, like, approach somebody who they knew in the physical world and who would respond, so maybe even the site existence was a "net positive" considering the happened and "intended" number of "immoral" acts?

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:19PM (#10094742)
I think saying "it's hard to feel bad for" is a far cry from "condemning everyone". This is a lot of words to try to absolve the members of a site explicitly about cheating on your partner of any wrongdoing.
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:22PM (#10094755)
Do you have any proof that even more than 50% "cheated"? I gave you arguments that it can be estimated that maybe one in 30 actually did cheat? Why do you want to condemn (edit: the more correct word were "accuse," I agree, but you did write that the given arguments don't "absolve" them, which implies that you've already found them "guilty") 29 of 30 people for actually doing nothing, most of them, according to their own data, not even being in relation?
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:23PM (#10094762)
Again, I'm not condemning anyone.

"It's hard to feel bad for" =/= Condemnation

All I said was that Ashley Madison explicitly markets itself as a site to cheat on your partners. You'll find plenty of people (myself included) who think engaging in a sexual relationship knowing that your partner is in a committed relationship is immoral alongside cheating on a partner.

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:25PM (#10094771)
Your actual words were

> This is a lot of words to try to absolve

just some post before (if they can't be absolved then they are, if I understand, already "guilty" in your view).

Do you want to accuse as "cheaters" 30 people on the list when only one of them cheated? When half of them weren't in the relation at all? Is that a moral thing to do?

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:30PM (#10094796)
I'm not accusing them of being cheaters, I'm accusing them of signing up for a website with the explicit goal of either cheating on your partner or entering a relationship with someone who is doing so. Whether or not that's moral is up the individual to decide (in my eyes, it's not, but that's pretty irrelevant to my point). Either way, leaking the data was NOT a moral thing to do.
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:33PM (#10094805)
> I'm accusing them of signing up for a website with the explicit goal of either cheating on your partner or entering a relationship with someone who is doing so.

Are they "guilty" even if that very action of them (signing in to the site and "just looking") effectively reduced the total number of cheats in the world? Is the site "guilty" if their "grand total" had the same effect?

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:39PM (#10094830)
Yes.

No, it's not equivalent to cheating on your partner, but it's still wrong.

Much like drawing/distributing pictures of sexualized children is still wrong even if it's an outlet that (and you can't prove this, which is where the real problem with your logic lies) prevents a child from being abused.

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:40PM (#10094835)
Thank you. I have no more questions.

The start of this discussion was the assumption that every person on the list made the actions that hurt others, validity of which I questioned (asking if even the majority did something that hurt anybody, giving the arguments that with the high probability most didn't actually hurt anybody and maybe even reduced the number of actual "cheats"). And you claim that you "don't condemn" everybody but still find everybody "guilty" for doing the "wrong" thing to the equivalence of an unproved but possible child abuse. O-K.

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Thursday August 20, 2015 @08:06PM (#10095318)
Quite the edit there. The start of the discussion was someone saying he found it hard to feel bad for those outed by the leak and then you writing some paragraphs about how he was condemning those individuals. All I was trying to add was a little nuance.

> Are they "guilty" even if that very action of them (signing in to the site and "just looking") effectively reduced the total number of cheats in the world?

This is what I was talking about, it's a classic defense of cartoon depictions of child pornography, which I find immoral. Go to a therapist if you're struggling with the temptation to cheat on your significant other, not a dating site for cheaters.

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Friday August 21, 2015 @01:39AM (#10096120)
> Go to a therapist if you're struggling with the temptation to cheat on your significant other, not a dating site for cheaters.

It seems that here most of these that you like "outed" and consider "guilty" haven't had the significant other.

Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by zajd on Friday August 21, 2015 @07:44AM (#10096901)
That I like outed? I told you the leak was not a good nor moral thing.
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by acqq on Friday August 21, 2015 @08:45AM (#10097084)
I agree with you: that leak was not a moral thing.
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by brillenfux on Thursday August 20, 2015 @05:16PM (#10094727)
sshhh! We want to feel morally superior!
Re:'More Ashley Madison' data leaked onto dark net by rjurney on Tuesday September 01, 2015 @11:44PM (#10157309)
I don't consider them 'sinners,' but you do make a good point.