News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by randallsquared on Saturday January 19, 2008 @12:49PM (#100929)
If Dennett's argument (in the ordered list in that post) is stated accurately, it is obviously wrong. Having not read _Freedom Evolves_, I can't say whether this is an accurate summary, but it's clear that "to avoid the actions you'll deterministically take" and "to avoid objects" are not using "avoid" in the same sense.
Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by byrneseyeview on Saturday January 19, 2008 @02:32PM (#100979)
Sure. I get the feeling I'm not hearing an accurate summary -- like when Naomi Klein turns something like "the pursuit of rational self-interest maximizes collective gain" into "They're trying to convince people that by doing good you do bad, and that by being bad -- by pursuing your most selfish desires -- you do good." (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g2kTy7glZ9s).

I've read some Dennett, and I've never found anything amenable to the paraphrase AS quoted. I'm sure if you wanted to, you could find people who tell you how ridiculous Dennett was by quoting him that way, just as people have had a great time finding out what Milton Friedman said by way of Klein's parody. I suspect that AS just hasn't bothered to consider the possibility that he and his idol are wrong.

Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by yters on Saturday January 19, 2008 @03:38PM (#101002)
Later on q reaffirms aaron's argument (@ 2008-01-19T10:55:30), seemingly based on q's own read of DD's work. So, at least two seemingly smart people come to the same conclusion independently.
Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by hhm on Saturday January 19, 2008 @03:52PM (#101006)
Who is q?
Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by mhb on Saturday January 19, 2008 @04:53PM (#101026)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Q_

But I don't recall seeing Dennett in any episodes.

Re:How Dumb is Daniel Dennett? by yters on Sunday January 20, 2008 @02:54PM (#101308)
No idea. Some commentator.