News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[deleted]
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by fluidcruft on Thursday August 20, 2015 @12:34PM (#10092930)
It's pretty easy to understand why it's being downvoted. It doesn't contribute to the conversation--it's a pedantic tangent that isn't any more interesting than noting that (1) the surface of the Earth used to be molten and (2) all matter in the known Universe was a lot hotter during the big bang. Is that relevant?
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @12:56PM (#10093089)
The surface of the Earth was molten some 4.5 billion years ago. The big bang was about 14 billion years ago. The start of the relative record is a mere 135 years ago. It is absurd to conflate the two, and it's a critical foundation for the statement.

By simple random odds (which given that weather stations are few and far between, simple odds of micro-climates can shift temperature slightly), even with zero influence of global warming or any other effect, it's entirely possible to break records set over such a short period. I'm far too lazy to calculate random odds right now, but setting a new high at a 17 year interval doesn't seem remarkable. It is in the context of global warming, but in isolation it really doesn't mean much.

This isn't an anti AGW comment, and it's unfortunate that it's impossible to even state something so fundamental without it becoming religious, but the truth is that we've been recording our planet for a very short period of time, with growing accuracy and coverage every year.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @01:57PM (#10093500)
Comments like these are not appreciated not because they're wrong, exactly, but because they're useless and irrelevant.

Imaging we have a coin that I claim is biased. (Just pretend that front-page story about how it's impossible to bias a coin didn't happen.) I've flipped it dozens or hundreds of times and nearly every time it comes up heads.

After I've done this for a while, I start saying, check this out, I'm pretty sure this coin is biased. I provide my data to support the claim. But it's an ongoing investigation, so I'm still flipping the coin, and it keeps coming up mostly heads. Every so often I publish a confirming tidbit, like, "I just flipped the coin 5 times and every time it came up heads. This is even more confirmation that it's biased."

What you're doing is basically taking that statement and saying, that doesn't mean anything, a fair coin would produce 5 heads in a row 1 out of every 32 attempts.

Then I do another experiment, flip the coin four times and each time it's heads. Your reply is that it's meaningless because a fair coin would reproduce this 1 out of every 16 attempts.

Another experiment. Six heads. You say it's meaningless, because a fair coin would do this 1 out of 64 times.

And we keep on going. With each announcement you point out, correctly, that this specific, individual result could pretty easily occur by random chance. And yet each of your responses is useless and misguided, because it ignores all the other results.

Setting a new high is not remarkable. Doing it repeatedly starts to get more interesting. Doing it while average temperatures have been rising steadily for over a century is more compelling. Put all the data together and, while each little piece can be said to mean little because it could have happened by random chance, the sum total is highly compelling.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:32PM (#10093713)
Comments like this (and predictable moderation of my comment) are what makes this whole discussion a religion. You profoundly and completely missed the entire context of my comment in your zeal to, you think, denounce anti-warming. It is tiring, pedestrian, and ignorant.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:34PM (#10093730)
Maybe if you explained a little more, I could actually have a shot at understanding what you think the problem is.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:52PM (#10093852)
This new record high for the month beat the previous record from 17 years ago, to begin.

Do you really think you want to understand? Again, the irrational histrionics of so many to this discussion (such as the conflation of billions of years with a period of time that is a tiny, tiny sliver of human history, much less periods of the Earth). It is impossible to discuss nuances without the predictable, boorish stomping of feet and announcing of positions. People must make everyone know how firmly and strongly they believe in global warming.

And the funny thing is that I fully and completely believe in and understand AGW. It isn't a religion, however, and I'm not waving a flag or announcing fealty, or angrily posting over the top responses to anything that is other than full-fledged Belief. It is the most toxic, bottom-feeding discussion going.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:59PM (#10093899)
I don't understand what the fact that the previous record was 17 years prior has to do with my response, or your response to my response.

You're right, the discussion is mostly awful. Climate change has been turned into a political issue, and awful discussion is a predictable result of that.

On the other hand, I don't see how your comment improves that any.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:19PM (#10094017)
Conflating six heads in a row with a periodic new record is unproductive. For any given area of the country we generally have several record highs per year, and record lows per year, and have every single year since 1880. That's the nature of having a very small period of records.

People acting outraged about a simple statement of fact like "since 1880", or the notional, obvious statement that a sporadic high or low is, by itself, not compelling, diminishes everyone.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by fluidcruft on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:45PM (#10094167)
You've choesn to insist on replacing the actual continuous data with a weaker derived parameter (period between record breaking events). Of course tests on weakend data have lower power. Should I be surprised that a test which relies on data extremes has less trend detection power?

But I'll also note that you haven't even bothered to go back and compute the probabilities in the first place.

It was one thing to make this argument in the 90's, but two decades of data later it's plainly ridiculous and it doesn't take nuanced data analysis.

https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/sotc/service/global/glob/201506.gi...

https://www.ncdc.noaa.gov/sotc/service/global/lo-hem/201506....

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:33PM (#10094098)
Daily records at a point are completely irrelevant to this discussion. The fact that points set multiple daily records per year has no bearing whatsoever on the significance, or lack thereof, of a monthly, global record.

You're right of course, that a single record high is not compelling. Even when it's a global, monthly record high. My point in my original reply is that pointing this out is irrelevant and annoying.

Was your point merely that this data point, by itself, is not compelling? If so, my original comment, which you complained about missing the point, was exactly about that. Was it something else? If so, I'm having a seriously tough time figuring out what your point is supposed to be.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:38PM (#10094130)
The fact that points set multiple daily records per year has no bearing whatsoever on the significance, or lack thereof, of a monthly, global record.

Exactly the same principle applies.

Look at the title of this submission. Stop and before you knee-jerk a response, contemplate that this isn't "it's hot, yo, and getting hotter". It is specifically that July was the hottest month "ever recorded", which someone quite rightfully noted was since 1880.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by dang on Thursday August 20, 2015 @03:47PM (#10094179)
> before you knee-jerk a response

> zealots such as yourself

Stuff like this breaks the HN guidelines, and there is much of it in your comments. Please post civilly and substantively, or not at all, even when others are wrong. In fact, especially when others are wrong.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @04:28PM (#10094447)
The exact same principle applies, yes. But the quantities are way different.

Variation at a point is high. Variation for a period of a single day is high. Samples are taken frequently. Thus new records will be set regularly.

Variation for the entire globe is low. Variation for a period of an entire month is low. There are twelve samples per year. Thus new records would not be expected to be set frequently.

Again, what exactly is your point?

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Thursday August 20, 2015 @09:07PM (#10095465)
Thinking about this more, samples are actually taken at the same rate: yearly. The difference is how many different things you're tracking in each year.

For regional records, you're tracking 365 events per year. Each one is compared with that day on prior years.

For global records, you're tracking one event per year (since July will always be the warmest month).

Thus, if you'd expect to set a new record every 50 years, then you'd see on average one global record every 50 years, but you'd see about seven daily regional records every year.

Also consider that you should be seeing both record highs and record lows. Record lows continue at a good pace for regional daily records, but there hasn't been a global record low for well over a century.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by fluidcruft on Thursday August 20, 2015 @11:28PM (#10095838)
Records don't occur linearly for a stationary variable. That is you don't expect "an average record every 50 years". The longer you observe the signal the more more extreme the expected outlier.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by mikeash on Friday August 21, 2015 @10:41AM (#10097764)
Sure, that's just a simplification to illustrate the principle. Whatever the expected recurrance for records is, you'll get a lot more of them when you're testing 365 (really 730, since you have both highs and lows) separate values each year than when you're just testing one (realy two).
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by fluidcruft on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:19PM (#10093629)
Global warming is obvious from the data. End of story. The AGW debate is about the extent to which this very real warming is caused by human activity. At best, all those effectoids you prattle off are only interesting as confounds for the models that are used to tease out causes for the warming. The overall warming itself is indisputable.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:32PM (#10093720)
Interesting comment having positively nothing to do with my comment. That you fail to understand that speaks volumes. Of course, you're the one who conflates 135 years with 14 billion years, so not unexpected.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by fluidcruft on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:43PM (#10093787)
If you observe a pattern that what you think is your point is not getting across to your readers, it could well be that your readers are dense. It could also be that what you're writing is unintelligible.
Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by inversionOf on Thursday August 20, 2015 @02:56PM (#10093879)
The pattern is that it is utterly impossible to discuss any nuance of AGW, the data, or its meaning, without zealots such as yourself acting as strongly as you can to make sure everyone knows how much of a Believer you are.

AGW is reality. The disciples of AGW are profoundly intolerable, however.

Re:July 2015 was warmest month ever recorded by nitrogen on Thursday August 20, 2015 @12:36PM (#10092941)
If so, it's not nearly to the extent of modern temperature increases, and modern CO2 increases are certainly not part of a preindustrial trend.