It's a false dichotomy to say that you can only choose between 20 year research and 1 year marketing. Plenty of private money goes into research with long term payoff. There are private companies engaged in fusion research, because the payoff is huge if it is achieved. Even the public money that goes into publicly funded research comes from private earnings in the first place. So science and free markets are absolutely suited to each other. That's before we even start discussing corruption of objectives in totalitarian states, based on leaders whims (ie, Nazi science research, Lysenko etc)
Sorry to tell you but capitalist society as it exists is planned and managed economy. Large corporations are command economies.
You should see what science has discovered about the brain:
Most people in business view any sort of rigorous research as a "cost" center. And this thinking has diffused into government too.
On the other hand marketing and advertising produces the most value for dollar. Why ?
In a market those activities generate new demand - something that a capitastic system needs in order to survive.
Why spend 20 years doing research while we could spend 1 year aggressively expanding our market. Even a 1% growth would he worth it given a 0% growth if the money was spent doing research.
I like that rather than villify a single person Nate silver points the finger at the system. This type of thinking is where we should all be heading towards.