Re:Some Musings on Mathematics
by JadeNB on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @05:59PM
(#10082492)
Also, it occurs to me that the self reference can be avoided by an epistemologically insignificant dodge: "Are you about to say 'no'?" (This dodge is, I admit, a little dodgy; it admits things like "I wasn't planning to" as a perfectly sound answer. However, I'm taking it as read that we understand all questions as yes / no questions.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Implicitly, the "no" references the answer to the question itself, hence it's still selfreferential.
In other words, the fallacy is to assume the following response was fixed to be an answer to the question. If I answered "no" it would be obvious that i wasn't planning to say "no" prior ("about") to the question. There is just no context in which the question would make sense the way you suggest. It's non-sense.