Re:Using Virtual Machines to Improve Container Security with...
by thinkingkong on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @09:34PM
(#10083255)
This might be viewed as slightly OT but this entire container security thing always reminds me how important it is to build on the right ecosystem.
This technology has been available for years on other platforms in a stable fashion. The fact that they never get used for different reasons is always sobering
Re:Using Virtual Machines to Improve Container Security with...
by eloff on Tuesday August 18, 2015 @09:06PM
(#10083170)
It's fantastic that you've reduced the startup and memory overhead to the point where it's almost negligible. That's quite an achievement!
One thing that was not discussed is the impact hypervisor-based virtualization has on runtime. I've seen plenty of benchmarks where AWS EC2 instances perform much more poorly than a bare-metal machine with a similar processor. Do you have any idea what the overhead might be for clear containers vs standard linux namespace-based containers?
Re:Using Virtual Machines to Improve Container Security with...
by eloff on Wednesday August 19, 2015 @01:45PM
(#10087187)
Thanks for sharing! So roughly 20% slower for computationally intensive workloads, likely due to nested paging putting increased pressure on the TLB. For applications using huge pages, the slowdown would likely be much less. Both docker and KVM introduce a lot of overhead with frequent, small IOs. That's likely the chattiness of the syscalls with the Kernel, which is a problem even without virtualization. Doing more work per syscall reduces those overheads. e.g. writev, readv, sendmmsg recvmmsg, etc. The context switch involved in syscalls (especially the cache and TLB pollution they cause) is very expensive.
This technology has been available for years on other platforms in a stable fashion. The fact that they never get used for different reasons is always sobering
One thing that was not discussed is the impact hypervisor-based virtualization has on runtime. I've seen plenty of benchmarks where AWS EC2 instances perform much more poorly than a bare-metal machine with a similar processor. Do you have any idea what the overhead might be for clear containers vs standard linux namespace-based containers?
It's exciting to see further investment in Intel® Clear Containers. At Kismatic, we have been fans (0) of Clear Containers since the beginning!
(0): https://kismatic.com/technical/quickstart-intel-clear-linux-...